Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you think this was too harsh?

102 replies

myladybelle · 19/06/2024 16:45

Second guessing myself and looking for opinions on whether this was an appropriate consequence for my 6 year old DS.
Yesterday evening before bed he was upset about something and hit me; as well as threw a small toy at my head. He didn't have school today and went out with our babysitter to soft play, and would usually get an ice cream afterwards. I told him in the moment he wouldn't get an ice cream tomorrow (today).
Today he woke up asking about the ice cream and crying and saying sorry. I'm still stuck at work so don't know how the day went but feeling really conflicted about it. Probably because I had to leave the house to crying and remorseful DS.
Too harsh?

OP posts:
Imnotticketyboo · 19/06/2024 21:21

JurassicClark · 19/06/2024 16:50

Delayed punishments aren't much use at age 6. In future I'd try find a more immediate natural consequence.

Yeah this. But also sometimes in the moment the immediate natural consequence doesn't come to you. I'm hardwired to say things like 'no screentime/dessert for you!' and it's taking a lot of unlearning to change. Basically don't beat yourself up too much. Being a parent is hard sometimes, being a kid can be hard too. If we all keep trying to do better next time then that's already alot!

Boltonb · 20/06/2024 11:49

FrazzledQuoka · 19/06/2024 18:14

By a "natural immediate consequence" are you suggesting hitting back? Yes I've seen dogs gently nip their puppies back if their puppies get too nibbly, but I don't think that's approved of by humans now. Apart from anything else hitting back is a little incompatible with the core message of "violence is not the answer".

While food as a punishment is slightly dodgy ground, missing one ice-cream is not overly harsh and you have to follow through. What would have been harsh is saying "you won't get the ice-cream tomorrow, you'll have to watch the nanny eat it in front of you."

Of course I’m not suggesting hitting a child. What a leap. Upthread I’ve already said I would have told him not to hit/throw and let him go to sleep. He was probably over tired if it was last thing at night.

I personally don’t feel the need to “punish” every little example of non perfect behaviour

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread