Haven’t read the whole thread.
I’m Catholic, and I don’t care that women can’t be Catholic priests, for two reasons. One, I’ve never met a woman who actually wants to be a Catholic priest, complete with lifelong celibacy. People complain that some hypothetical woman, somewhere, can’t join the priesthood, but no one seems to actually want to do it herself.
Two, being a Catholic priest is a fairly lonely, isolating job, that not many men want, and I don’t think women are missing anything great. Catholic priests are supposed to never have sex for the rest of their lives once they join the priesthood. They don’t even get a built-in community, like nuns; most of the ones I’ve met (including my uncle) live in shabby little rectories by themselves, or perhaps with the parish’s other priest as a roommate. (You’re not compatible roommates? Too bad.) They spend a lot of their time trying to negotiate petty bullshit with parishioners. Betty won’t stay on the funeral lunch committee if Sally becomes the head; Jim is mad that his daughter can’t wear a strapless wedding dress in the church; Larry has a grudge against Margaret because she rejected his ancient donations for the church library.
Sorry, I don’t think it’s all that tragic that women can’t have a stressful, lonely job in which they can never have sex, never have children, don’t have much choice about where they’re assigned, have to listen to pedophile jokes and comments about their profession, never get a break from other people’s problems, and, to top it all off, have to wear boring clothes.