Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I didn't have my daughter

428 replies

gingerbreadbunny · 28/04/2024 20:03

I have 4 children, 3 are lovely easy children and 1 who whinges and whines all day about anything and everything.
She's really hard work, the other 3 go straight to bed but not her she's up fussing back and forth for hours, it's exhausting.
She doesn't ever want to go anywhere and will make everything about her by just being difficult and awkward, she won't do as she's told,
if she doesn't get her own way she screams and tantrums and ruins everyone else's day.
She constantly and deliberately upsets her brothers and sister who have had enough, she'll only play with them if she gets her own way and if they don't want to play her way she'll ruin it for them or won't play.
She's 6 and I love her but I just know life would be so much happier for us all if we hadn't had her.
I feel like she sucks all the energy out of me every single day.
She always wants everything to be about her and will deliberately talk over any siblings who try and talk to me.
If I hold another's hand she'll pull them off me so she can hold my hand instead.
I just don't have any energy left, she's completely depleting me and dh.
She is full of anger and hatred and is wearing us down.
She can be lovely when it suits her but it's usually short lived, just until something doesn't go her way.

OP posts:
MumsGoneToIceland · 02/05/2024 05:33

Pantaloons99 · 28/04/2024 20:13

I'm going to roll out the line I know MNers love to hear 😬. Do you think there's a possibility she has additional needs, ADHD and or Autism? Your description and your feelings of utter despair are incredibly familiar to many parents of ND kids. It's usually because nothing you do seems to work.

I'd consider that before ripping yourself apart and trying every discipline tactic under the sun. I imagine you've already done that.

Was going to say the same, my daughter was similar and much later was diagnosed with ADHD.

instaready · 02/05/2024 05:50

I have 4. Coincidentally my second youngest is similar to yours. I was losing the plot a 3 years old. Mentioned to nursery. No issues there. Then great in school. Definitely had the coke bottle effect. Private therapy then managed to get a GP referral to CAMHS at 8. CAMHS tried to help with the anger with play therapy. Eventually referred for autism assessment. Nearly 12 years old before my child was diagnosed with autism, score was very high that the psychologist wondered how we got to the age of 12 without diagnosis.
Simple answer is good behaviour at school.

I would like to point out that there is no extra help after this stage. But it helps us as parents have a level of understanding.

Youdontevengohere · 02/05/2024 08:36

nopuppiesallowed · 01/05/2024 22:47

Right now, teachers are leaving in droves because of discipline problems in school with badly behaved children who have had ineffective boundaries. What many Mumsnetters consider 'hitting', I see as firm boundary markers - used rarely and acting as a deterrent. 'Gentle' parenting works with many children. It doesn't work with all. Unless something terrifying is happening in our society, most children are not ND. They need boundaries to ensure they become useful members of society.

So you fall into my second category then… you think inflicting physical pain on a small child is an acceptable thing to do. As I said, you need help.

Youdontevengohere · 02/05/2024 08:36

And if it worked as a deterrent… surely you’d only have to do it once?

nopuppiesallowed · 02/05/2024 08:52

With my children, I think I gave my 1st child a very rare light smack after verbal warnings. My other two realised that 'I tell you once. I tell you twice. The third time you will have a smack' was a promise. They don't seem traumatised by their upbringing. We have lovely relationships.

Youdontevengohere · 02/05/2024 08:53

A light smack? So did it hurt, or not?

Youdontevengohere · 02/05/2024 08:54

Actually don’t bother answering. You just tell yourself whatever you need to to justify inflicting pain on someone much smaller, much weaker and much more vulnerable than you 👍

Roundandroundthegard3n · 02/05/2024 08:59

Majentaplasticglasses · 02/05/2024 00:06

My daughter was like this at 6. She was arguably worse. However she was an absolute angel at school. A friend with an ND daughter made me aware that there were lots of flags for neurodivergency, and that "bad behaviour" is just a child's way of communicating their needs aren't being met. I researched ND friendly parenting methods and switched up my approach which helped massively.

I also actively worked on identifying what needs were unmet. After my daughter was calm, we would discuss her "big feelings", and talk about what made her feelings "grow" like that. It may be controversial but I made sure she didn't feel as though I was shaming her for her behaviour, because I wanted her to open up to me, so I could find and address the root of the problem.

I also made sure my expectations were very clear and simple, and got DD a star chart to reinforce this. It really helped as DD is super competitive. I also made sure that consequences for rule breaking were clear and consistent, and tried to only use natural consequences that were related to DDs behaviour.

I also booked to go on the Triple P parenting course to learn new parenting strategies. But COVID put a stop to that.

For what it's worth DD is 10 now, she's been diagnosed with ADHD, moderate learning difficulties, and a mild language disorder. She's also on the ASD diagnosis waiting list. The root of all DDs behaviour was quite simply that she sees the world around her, and everything within it very differently to her peers.

DD rarely gets defiant anymore, and meltdowns are non existent. I genuinely think changing my parenting strategies has done far more than her diagnosis. It was hard work changing everything I did. But it's been so worth it

This is a fab positive post.

Ilostseptember · 02/05/2024 09:10

Ilostseptember · 01/05/2024 09:27

My son was like this. He is adorable and the golden child at school, but a nightmare at home, clingy, insecure, only wants to do what he wants, but this went in phases. Eventually I read "the book you wish your parents had read and your children will thank you for reading" by Philippa Perry and he had a book called your inner chimp. It really helped! I had to put firm boundaries, routines, be stricter than I wanted to be and be very very direct about what I wanted him to do, when and why. I also have to prewarn/remind him of things scheduled in the day, he transitions between activities badly.

Also worth noting I had to get him privately assessed for dyslexia (he is) because when moaning to my mum about the behaviour she said "that's what you were like". The shear frustration of coping with school, knowing something is different about you but being hyper vigilant because the humiliation of not being able to read, spell, answer maths questions was too much to tolerate. I guess add it to your list of ND things to consider and research.

CaribouCarafe · 02/05/2024 13:47

Lol at the suggestion that gentle parenting = any parenting technique that doesn't involve smacking your child.

Honestly didn't realise so many people ardently believe in assaulting their kids in this day and age in the UK.

I'd like to add that because it's less common to be smacked now, the psychological impact of being smacked when you know your peers aren't is likely to be much worse than at a time where smacking was the norm.

I remember my best friend's horror when I told her I'd been smacked (this was 15 years ago), and finding out that other kids weren't smacked made me feel even worse about the whole situation.

buttnut · 02/05/2024 13:59

Yep I don’t know anybody in RL who thinks smacking is okay.

In the same way I’d be horrified if a man decided to give his wife a smack because she’d displeased him, why would that same action be okay on a smaller, defenceless child?

whatsitcalledwhen · 02/05/2024 22:00

nopuppiesallowed · 02/05/2024 08:52

With my children, I think I gave my 1st child a very rare light smack after verbal warnings. My other two realised that 'I tell you once. I tell you twice. The third time you will have a smack' was a promise. They don't seem traumatised by their upbringing. We have lovely relationships.

So you used physical pain as a threat and have on occasion carried out that threat, purposefully hurting your child to punish them.

It's not a healthy dynamic between parent and child. Not even close.

nopuppiesallowed · 02/05/2024 22:10

Yet I think sending to room or any form of isolation is cruel.

DanielGault · 02/05/2024 22:24

nopuppiesallowed · 02/05/2024 22:10

Yet I think sending to room or any form of isolation is cruel.

Have you ever taken pause to think you might be wrong? Hitting children is crazy. We give out to children for hitting their peers. How does us hitting them reinforce that message? The poor kids must be totally confused. It's entirely possible to parent a kid without slapping them

BustyLaRoux · 03/05/2024 07:19

nopuppiesallowed · 02/05/2024 22:10

Yet I think sending to room or any form of isolation is cruel.

Out of interest @Snippysocks would you smack a child with a physical disability? If the child was blind, say? Blind children can still misbehave! Or if they were wheelchair bound? Would you smack them then if they misbehaved?

You say you wouldn’t smack them regularly. How often counts as regularly and how often counts as rare? I just wonder where the cut off is as to what is acceptable and what isn’t?

You say “only a light smacking”, but how light would that be? Enough to make a red mark? Or is that too much? How hard does it have to be to be effective?

Youdontevengohere · 03/05/2024 08:26

nopuppiesallowed · 02/05/2024 22:10

Yet I think sending to room or any form of isolation is cruel.

Same. It’s not one or the other, is it?

Youdontevengohere · 03/05/2024 08:28

I wonder if when you’re old, weak and vulnerable @Snippysocks your kids might start smacking you when you don’t behave how they’d like you to.

Out of interest do you smack anyone else, or just those you know can’t fight back because they’re weaker than you?

ArtemisApollo · 03/05/2024 09:14

OneWorldly4 · 28/04/2024 23:40

How can a mother talk about her own child in this way?

Instead of posting of here, contact your GP and get help for yourself and your child.

Poor kid.

Absolutely. We all have overwhelming and negative feelings, but to actually write those down without pause or self-criticism is bewildering to me. This relationship is totally unbalanced, a child cannot have this much negative impact on a well-adjusted family life. The onus is on the parents to ensure they are able to absorb a new child into the family, considering the child won’t be a clone of the previous ones. Everyone wants a baby, rarely ever sparing a thought to the fact they grow up or might need more resources. Hope you get help for that little girls’ and her siblings’ sake.

ArtemisApollo · 03/05/2024 09:23

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 28/04/2024 23:46

She's just a mum at the end of her tether.

Kids don't come with a manual. I'm sure OP dearly loves her DD, she is just frazzled. Fortunately we live in this wonderful day and age of such conveniently wonderous things like sliced bread, microwaves and the Internet and the OP is just using the tools she has at her disposal to express her feelings and seek support.

I'm pretty sure mums helping mums is one of the reasons this entire website was created.

OP is showing zero self-awareness. I read about a “terrible child that shouldn’t have been born” and immediately my attention goes to bad parenting. My money is on little child has never had undivided attention from parents, siblings often boss her around because they are compliant and constantly reassured they are golden children, she shines at school because her efforts are recognised and she’s not always being compared unfavourably. These parents chose to bring a 3rd child into their family, the onus is on them alone to make it work. Poor child.

ArtemisApollo · 03/05/2024 09:31

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/04/2024 11:16

Not helpful.

You don’t seem to understand the breaking point ND can drive parents to. I wanted to frequently run away when my dd was little. She absolutely did my head in.

But l loved her ( and still do) more than the world. And now l look back and regret that we didn’t understand her earlier.

Parents are allowed to struggle with nd children.

Until OP has a diagnosis that her little daughter is ND, people need to stop using that card to justify the horrible language OP has chosen to write down. She and husband aren’t helpless, and it’s not the kids’ fault.

Roundandroundthegard3n · 03/05/2024 09:39

ArtemisApollo · 03/05/2024 09:31

Until OP has a diagnosis that her little daughter is ND, people need to stop using that card to justify the horrible language OP has chosen to write down. She and husband aren’t helpless, and it’s not the kids’ fault.

What's more likely to help this overwhelmed mum? Your posts, or some of the helpful ones where people suggest ways to manage the behaviour?

ArtemisApollo · 03/05/2024 09:45

MrsCBY · 29/04/2024 11:01

3 are lovely easy children and 1 who whinges and whines all day about anything and everything.
I just know life would be so much happier for us all if we hadn't had her

It’s painful for me to read how you feel about your daughter; I can only imagine how painful it is for your daughter to sense this is the way you feel about her, as I’m sure she does.

You talk about your family as if you, your DH and your other 3 DC are your “real” family and this DD is just an interloper who has come along and messed everything up for the rest of you. It’s heartbreaking. She’s your child, just as much as the others are; yes she’s different, but why are you making that her fault?

She got her genes from you. She gets her environment from you. She’s SIX years old, FFS; the agency she has over her own life is next to nothing.

Yes, I can understand it’s difficult to have this one child who isn’t docile like the rest and who you feel is spoiling things for your other DC, but bloody hell. She’s your child too. As a pp said, behaviour is communication: she has needs that aren’t being met, and you need to start recognising that. You are her parents and it’s your job to meet those needs, to love her as unconditionally as you love your other “easy” DC.

Your whole post is about how she is failing as your child. Because it’s easier for you to frame it that way than think it’s you who are failing her as her parents, and recognise it’s on you to keep trying till you find what works for you and for her.

You can wish she were different and blame her for it all you like - the way you describe her it’s as if you think she’s a defective model that you were unlucky enough to be palmed off with - but that won’t achieve anything at all; will only make things worse in the long run.

She’s part of your family; she is your family, just as much as your three “lovely easy” children. She is not an interloper who is destroying your family, she is an integral part of YOUR family, and it’s your job to give her the parenting she needs, however you make that happen, whatever support you need to get.

And that starts by stopping blaming her and recognising that she’s not some outside alien force doing this deliberately to hurt everybody, she’s just a very small child who’s obviously not happy and whose distress it’s your responsibility to alleviate. Because you are her parents. And she is your child.

100% this! I can’t imagine a parent writing how they wish they didn’t have their 6yo daughter. Yikes! Language matters.

ArtemisApollo · 03/05/2024 09:51

Roundandroundthegard3n · 03/05/2024 09:39

What's more likely to help this overwhelmed mum? Your posts, or some of the helpful ones where people suggest ways to manage the behaviour?

For me, my and other people’s posts’ not coddling an OP who refuses to take any responsibility for her part in her little child’s behaviour and chooses to voice that her child is ruining everything is the most helpful, but that’s because in life I’ve sought to know the truth to sort out problems. I totally understanding being that self-centred in feelings, but to actually write down the amount of terrible things she wrote about a 6yo child makes me doubt she’s got a grip on anything. Rude awakening and not coddling are often the best ways to learn. All I hope is that she figures out she isn’t hopeless and stops blaming her child for everything, for all their sakes. ND is a spectrum and seriously most people have strong ND traits. This is most likely purely family dynamics.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 03/05/2024 10:57

ArtemisApollo · 03/05/2024 09:51

For me, my and other people’s posts’ not coddling an OP who refuses to take any responsibility for her part in her little child’s behaviour and chooses to voice that her child is ruining everything is the most helpful, but that’s because in life I’ve sought to know the truth to sort out problems. I totally understanding being that self-centred in feelings, but to actually write down the amount of terrible things she wrote about a 6yo child makes me doubt she’s got a grip on anything. Rude awakening and not coddling are often the best ways to learn. All I hope is that she figures out she isn’t hopeless and stops blaming her child for everything, for all their sakes. ND is a spectrum and seriously most people have strong ND traits. This is most likely purely family dynamics.

Most people shit too, but if you're shitting all the time it's probably because you've got a disorder.

Off to fuck with your ableist comments.

ArtemisApollo · 03/05/2024 11:06

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 03/05/2024 10:57

Most people shit too, but if you're shitting all the time it's probably because you've got a disorder.

Off to fuck with your ableist comments.

It’s testament to your inability to co-exist with others in society that you feel the need to use aggressive language. You should look into that.
Kid has no diagnostic, OP blames 6yo child for everything and so many people here feel called out (projecting their own substandard parenting skills) that in their defensive minds the only possibility is the child is ND. Kid is, despite biased description by OP, demonstrating standard behaviour for a third child who is only 1 year younger than the next oldest, and only 2 years older than youngest, who undoubtedly noticed she isn’t considered in the same positive light as the other “easy” children (poor them also! The pressure alone to be compliant!), and who seems to never have 1-1 quality time with parents. They might be ND but choosing to see non-compliance and anger as ND is a bad take. Kids should be encouraged to see themselves as NT unless nothing else can explain destructive incapacitating behaviour, which isn’t the case here. People cheerleading for children to be labelled and put on a psych/medical pathway need to give their heads a wobble. Good parenting is very hard, and good parenting just isn’t for everyone, sadly.