Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of strangers’ life stories?

145 replies

Chaney · 14/04/2024 21:45

I know this will make me sound unsympathetic and cold. I’m generally not but, like most people, I have a lot on my plate and just can’t really take the mental load of strangers.

Twice this week I’ve had complete strangers tell me their sad life stories.

I got my hair done on Thursday and had a new stylist who spent the full three hours I was there yapping at me about all the awful things that had happened on her life. Poor woman really did have some awful events occur, but I was exhausted, drained, worried about stuff that’s going on it my own family, and left feeling like I paid £300+ to act as her personal therapist while stuck in a chair. I did resort to making non-commital “uh huh” noises and burying my head on my phone or a magazine after a while, but she persisted.

Then today I was in a small local shop. The owner was putting an order together for me while telling me about being widowed last year. Now, I certainly felt sympathy for her but I expressed it, but she just kept going on and on about the details of her late husband’s illness and premature death while very, very slowly fetching the items that were needed for my order.

I’ve always encountered this- strangers clinging on to me. I really don’t know why- I’m not especially approachable or engaging. I don’t share a lot about myself with people I don’t know. I’m assertive but it’s hard to ask someone to be quiet or move away from them when they’re in tears telling you about the abuse they’ve sustained, or a bereavement.

I think it’s gone much worse since Covid too- people just seem to want to over share.

OP posts:
choixduroi · 15/04/2024 10:05

I am more on the side of @ViciousCurrentBun. Yes of course it's annoying being used as a kind of flesh robot for random people to offload on. However I find that it takes me out of myself to find out about other people's lives, tbh I usually come away thinking blimey, we all have our cross to bear, often I learn really interesting insights through someone's comments or stories. And if they've had awful stuff happen it makes me more appreciative of my lot. Sometimes little interactions with strangers can be better than interaction with people we know well. We're all struggling on in life and I think it's quite nice to help each other. Especially lonely oldies, it may have really brightened their day to have that short chat with you. I do feel your pain with the hairdresser as in that situation you are a captive audience. I feel like a good hairdresser should either ask you polite, not too personal questions like the classic 'going on holiday soon', or should engage in light two-way chit chat about hair products or hair issues.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 15/04/2024 10:09

Interesting from the pp who wanted to share but put out when others do the same back.

Maybe THEY are tired of being talked at and that was their way of moving things along. Must be hard being a cashier as you can't get away.

When someone starts, you don't know if its a short chat or will go on for ages.

When people share, it's only normal to reply with similar experiences, if any.

It's a way of sympathising.

But the original sharer gets upset by the other person 'stealing' their moment.....
No self awareness that they're offloading to someone who may have the same if not bigger problems.

If you're a sharer, you should at least be willing to listen too.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 15/04/2024 10:14

My hairdresser mumbles, it's stressful having to concentrate trying to decipher what he's saying. Does it when washing your hair, so you've got the general salon noise, noise of running water then the mumbling 😅.

GoFaster83 · 15/04/2024 10:16

I get this but only when I'm with my dog. She's very friendly and a mix of several breeds with obvious features of them all (not designer - she's a mongrel). The amount I know about people's dearly departed dogs in this city is quite something! I don't mind though. My girl is clearly bringing them comfort and she is delighted with the attention.

Ohwellithappens · 15/04/2024 10:22

I hear you regarding the hairdresser, it was the same with my PT. I actually changed my hairdresser recently because I actually didn't have the emotional energy to listen as I had some stuff to deal with in my own life. And you're right, in London it's not hard to pay £300 for a cut, colour etc so you do want a nice experience.

TorroFerney · 15/04/2024 11:00

OneFrenchEgg · 15/04/2024 07:13

@ziggies wow you're probably one of those I told. So in response to 'my grandad died this morning' you don't say 'sorry' you decide to list all the deaths you know about. Think self awareness is lacking somewhere else.
I have never responded to someone saying their loved one was taken to hospital that day by redirecting to myself.

Id be sympathetic of course but id also be wondering why you wanted to tell me (a stranger) that your dad had died. Now that’s my hangup of course as i wouldn’t dream of telling someone I’d had a bereavement unless they were either close or needed to know eg my boss.

some people empathise by telling you something similar back, it’s a clumsy way of showing they know what it’s like.

TorroFerney · 15/04/2024 11:01

SOxon · 15/04/2024 09:56

Have you no soul? I found them fascinating, wanted to hear / know more.
these tragic tales are more genuine and captivating than the usual fare
VCB is intelligent, articulate, compassionate, read and learn

She’s not you!

zingally · 15/04/2024 11:06

The same happens to me OP.

The most recent one was a woman from my choir, who I've maybe spoken 3 words to in the past 8 years. She sat herself next to me, and launched into a saga about how she wants to break off her engagement! I've no idea why.

Allfur · 15/04/2024 11:09

I love hearing people's stories

SOxon · 15/04/2024 11:11

GoFaster83 · 15/04/2024 10:16

I get this but only when I'm with my dog. She's very friendly and a mix of several breeds with obvious features of them all (not designer - she's a mongrel). The amount I know about people's dearly departed dogs in this city is quite something! I don't mind though. My girl is clearly bringing them comfort and she is delighted with the attention.

Compassion in action, if only more people adopted your philosophy,
(and your dog’s)

GR8GAL · 15/04/2024 11:12

I'd take a casual chat with someone on the bus or the hairdressers over a 20 minute racist rant from a taxi driver any day of the week. They're the worst for it, and assume we're all bigots and anti-this or that. I've gotten to the point now where I ask to turn the radio up as a firm hint to stop talking.

LadySlipper · 15/04/2024 11:17

My worst one for me was queuing for security in a very busy airport; it was taking forever. Guy behind me got chatting, by commenting that it was the first time he'd been back to his hometown for 26 years. Oh my, says I, I guess you'll be in 'for a time'!! - local expression for some big time partying. Yep he says, swinging up his supermarket carrier bag, taking my sister home to bury her. Stage 3 cancer and she was gone in a few weeks. I was fighting back the tears by the time we got to the scanner and he had to discuss the urn in his bag at the checking point. Totally ruined MY buzz for going home to see my family.

Heatherbell1978 · 15/04/2024 11:23

I get this a lot and without sounding ridiculous (I hope) I think I have a kind face! I have big eyes and I'm sure they're linked to empathy or something. My young DD on the other hand has a resting bitch face that no one can compete with...she even told me the other day that her goal in life was to be a 'boss bitch'

RaraRachael · 15/04/2024 11:26

Glasgow is the worst place on earth for this. Every single time I'm in a shop, bus queue, food queue - basically anything - the person beside me has to strike up some chat or other. I know some people say that it's the friendliest place but some of us just want to be left alone.

SOxon · 15/04/2024 11:36

Heatherbell1978 · 15/04/2024 11:23

I get this a lot and without sounding ridiculous (I hope) I think I have a kind face! I have big eyes and I'm sure they're linked to empathy or something. My young DD on the other hand has a resting bitch face that no one can compete with...she even told me the other day that her goal in life was to be a 'boss bitch'

I was early twenties, working for a demanding boss
when exhausted one Friday telling my flatmate how I felt put on, she said,
“well you look approachable”
ie it’s your own fault,
“no one asks the Office Bitch for help, do they?!”

WhatNoRaisins · 15/04/2024 11:52

I do sometimes like hearing people's stories but honestly I'd rather pick a good time, get a cup of tea and listen to a podcast rather than have it sprung on me. Not to mention only potentially interesting stories end up being recorded. Maybe we're a bit spoiled and before radio programmes and the internet people appreciated listening to other people's stores in person a bit more.

SabreIsMyFave · 15/04/2024 11:59

Ohhhhh my god, I know what you mean. And I absolutely love this thread. Grin

I have also become absolutely sick to death of hearing about other people's problems and 'issues.' Whether it's at the local hobby groups, or a checkout/standing in a queue, or walking around the shops and the high street, or walking around my village. People stop me, and tell me about the surgery they're having next week, the fact their husband/wife died 10 years ago, they can't get a plumber in to fix their leaky tap, they can't get to see a doctor for 5 weeks and other issues and problems in their life.... (I am sorry for anyone whose partner has died, but I literally don't know this person from Adam, and most of us by middle age have lost someone we love.)

I had one woman, cornering me for half an hour the other week (on a walk in my village.) I didn't know who she was, but she spent 97% of the time just talking about herself and her 'problems.' When I tried to talk about anything else, (in the 3 breaths she took in 30 minutes!) she just looked the other way for 2 seconds, and talked over me/carried on talking. After HALF AN HOUR, I literally cut her off mid-sentence to get away - and said 'anyway I gotta go, I have an appointment,' and I jogged off. She looked like Shock I didn't care!

I don't look 'kindly' at people and smile a lot at them. I actually don't look at people when I am walking around outside/in the shops. I try to avoid them because I can't be bothered with other people's chit-chat and problems. I've actually done an extra 10 or 15 minute walk down another road to get home, just to avoid speaking to somebody in my village, that I know is going to keep me talking for 20 to 30 minutes. I don't save much time (as my walk is longer,) but at least I have just my own company, and am not bored shitless by someone else's problems.

It's the same thing on '24 hours in A and E' and 'Ambulance' and similar emergency services programmes. These used to be really good and interesting programmes.' But now every single patient and their family has got a fucking story to tell ... We have to hear about their whole life, along with a sob story, about every illness they've had, every loss, every financial issue, every family drama, etc.. Along with how long they've been married and how many children they have, how many grandchildren they have, if they're 80-odd how they met their spouse at a barn dance in 1963, and how HE worked 75 hours a week down the mines to look after her and their 7 kids la la la...

And now it's moved onto the paramedics. They're starting to come out with their life story/sob story, like how they lost their dad when they were 23, how their first husband left them, how they struggle financially with having to support their little boy, how their mother can't get out much, and they have to take her shopping twice a week. Sob story after sob story, that are all what many other people go through. I'm sorry they have issues and problems in life, but why does everyone need to hear about it? It's actually ruining the programmes.

I literally do not give a flying fuck about other people's problems. I just don't. Fortunately I've not got many problems in my life at the moment and I'm quite lucky right now. But up to the last probably 7 or 8 years (aged 50-ish now) I had to deal with a bunch of problems and losses in life. Including being bullied at school, the death of my parents in my 30s, big financial problems, a business going under, marriage problems for a few years, problem after problem with a house we owned, coping with my children being bullied at school, and being bullied out of a job once (myself.) AND we had neighbour problems that drove us out of our house about 15 years ago.

I've had my problems - and losses - but I never used to corner people and start blathering about them for an hour. Everyone has their problems, why does anyone think everyone needs to hear about theirs? And why on earth would anyone tell a stranger about their personal problems (and losses and bereavements?) Confused

And like a previous poster said, I'm sick to death of being told we need to talk a lot more about menopause, periods, depression, womens health, children with SEN blah blah blah ... when (as they said,) we don't seem to stop talking about these issues (and similar ones.)

Every other woman and her cat, and every other man and his dog, and every other child, seem to have some 'issue' or 'problem' that we must ALL know about. They tell us about it all, or post something on the Internet (for Internet clicks and likes and attention,) or attention in the street. It really does my head in. I think this is why some people hate picking up the phone now! Don't want to be trapped for an hour by someone boring them to death with their 'problems...'

I think it's gone too far now and people always share far too much and I can't be arsed to hear it! And as has been said, these people only want to talk about themselves and are not interested in you. Drives me absolutely batshit. I'm so glad it's not just me, and load of posters here feel the same!

It's very hard to avoid it at the hairdressers though. One of the reasons I stopped going, and do my own hair now! (Stopped when covid hit 4 years ago, then never went back after realising I can do my own hair!) It's such a relief not having to hear a load of drivel and bollocks for 2 hours, whilst trapped in the chair!

WhatNoRaisins · 15/04/2024 12:08

I remember years back I started calling the X factor the psychiatric factor because of how much time was spent listening to the contestants talk about their angsty backstories and how much this opportunity meant to them. The producers must have been putting them up to it at least some of the time I reckon.

I think hearing constant tales of woe actually hardens us rather than making us "be kind" in my experience.

SabreIsMyFave · 15/04/2024 12:35

WhatNoRaisins · 15/04/2024 12:08

I remember years back I started calling the X factor the psychiatric factor because of how much time was spent listening to the contestants talk about their angsty backstories and how much this opportunity meant to them. The producers must have been putting them up to it at least some of the time I reckon.

I think hearing constant tales of woe actually hardens us rather than making us "be kind" in my experience.

Edited

I definitely agree with this. I think it all started with Gareth Gates on Pop Idol in 2002. Very cute, very shy, young man (teenage boy actually,) who'd got a stammer that he really struggled with and he was bullied at school. Then he opened his mouth to SING and had the voice of an angel ... It was a wonderful, authentic story of a shy bullied teen lad becoming a pop idol - and famous, and loved..

A bit like Susan Boyle ... This very awkward middle aged woman, who seemed a little bit dotty and a bit weird, and people LAUGHED at her. Opened her mouth and sang. Again... Voice of an angel. Whole audience was rapturous, and people at home had a tear in their eye. I do every time I watch that clip where she sings on BGT for the first time (I dreamed a dream,...)

So forevermore, when Pop Idol continued as X Factor, there always had to be a sob story, but they were not authentic like Gareth's story. And on Britain's Got Talent, again, they tried to have this awkward/slightly odd middle aged woman - or man, who people roll their eyes at, but then SHOCKER - they have quite a nice decent singing voice and everybody stands up in the stadium and cheers, and the judges try to force tears out of their eyes.

But it's not real/authentic.. It's forced. Because with Gareth and Susan, the awkward shy teen boy and middle age woman (who's actually got a brilliant voice and becomes really famous,) it was only one off. They have tried to replicate it time after time after time for the last 15 to 20 years - and it just hasn't worked. It's laughable and pathetic. Contrived and fake.

These talent shows are shite now. Most of the acts are scouted - and the sob stories are largely made up and/or exaggerated. And even if they're not, I don't give a shit about them. Just do your fucking act. I'm not interested in your 'sob story.'

WhatNoRaisins · 15/04/2024 12:48

I remember reading an article about the teenage girl from the Welsh village where there had recently been a series of teenage suicides. She and her mother said it hadn't even occurred to them to mention this but the producers saw the town on her address and heavily encouraged her to talk about how it had affected her so much and she wanted to bring some joy to her town bla bla bla.

Blahblahblabbaba · 15/04/2024 13:23

Flowerpotcat · 14/04/2024 23:14

SEN children are flawed children.. .yeah, that's really fucking offensive.

Yeah but I didn't say that did I? Read it again. Are you over sharing re your child and did it hit a nerve by any chance?

Was waiting for this comment and bingo here you are!

PamPamPamPam · 15/04/2024 13:28

The trick is headphones and a resting bitch face. One of my friends is constantly on the receiving end of these songs stories as she just looks so kind, I on the other hand have one of those faces where unless I am actively smiling I look incredibly angry which serves me well! I am also good at 'deadening' my eyes where I just stop focusing and look through people-so I'm not a captive audience for them.

Practice your resting bitch face a bit in the mirror OP, it might help things. Look at Cillian Murphy in interview-he's amazing at it!

Abitofalark · 15/04/2024 13:34

I'm not sure it's something about you - your face or whatever - although it's natural to assume that. I used to. Now I suspect it's more to do with being recognised as that class of people, namely women, who are perceived as available and suitable passive recipients of conversation and confidences.

If you are a loud gabbler yourself that might ward off at least some of these strangers with a story or a lament to share. Adopting a deliberately closed rigid stance and staring fixedly ahead might also work by communicating aloofness and unavailability. It's harder, though, when you're stuck in the hairdresser's chair and want them to do a good job on your hair.

Odiebay · 15/04/2024 13:37

I had this with my hairdresser. She kept pausing to show me photos and videos of her kids. I am not the least bit interested.

Final straw for me was when she told me way too much personal info on her 3 year old daughter and her boyfriend... You can guess what happened there. I felt sick. I was so sad and upset that messed me up that night and I couldn't get it out of my head.

Elephantswillnever · 15/04/2024 13:37

I think I too have “the face” of a good listener people tell me deeply personal things within moments of meeting me. I’m not sure why I met a new colleague who has told me so much about his personal struggles with life, his suicide attempts, bereavements, his wife, in a training afternoon. My boss asked how we got on I mentioned he was a bit intense, he had absolutely no idea about any of his struggles.

I do wonder if I should retrain as a counsellor/ therapist and embrace it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread