Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I an ungrateful brat?

121 replies

2021x · 16/03/2024 03:16

This is not something I am proud of, and I am aware that I am going to come off as spoiled and entitled, but here goes.

I have a big birthday coming up- the type where you question all your life decisions. I live alone in a different country which I am pretty isolated in, and will be spending my birthday alone, so am already a little emotional about it.

My mum said she wanted to buy me something special. I am not big on gifts and normally she just sends me a big bunch of flowers which I love, but this was important for her. I have been burnt many times by her gift giving and then she gets upset when I don't like what she gives i.e. clothes, chocolate etc. We have very different tastes and to avoid situations like below I am very explicit about what I want. However its important to her to surprise people as that part of the reason she likes to give gifts.

I suggested a high value item from a specific manufacturer. These are extremely expensive new but are such good quality it is considered an investment, so was very happy to go second-hand. She agreed and we saw some items in a retailer, but when I looked up this retailer there are some buyer beware reviews about the quality and the price and I discussed it with her in Janurary.

I found an official re-seller approved by the manufacturer and have been looking online. I found some items that I really liked and sent them on. After chekcing them everyday there was one particular item which I still really liked, and sent a message saying this is what I would like for my birthday. A few days later it comes off of the website.

This morning I get an email from the first retailer telling me that they will send me the gift my mother has bought me........and predictably I hate it. Its is not my style and I would never wear it, was nearly double the price of the one I selected and because of the reviews I don't trust the retailer. She has bought it because at the very beginning I said it would be cool to have something manufactured in the year I was born- but I after looking at the options that was thrown out the window pretty quickly.

I was in floods of tears for 2 hours just through sheer repeated frustration of not being heard. After I pulled myself together, I realise my options are to just not say anything and feel like shit about the present and what it represents, to not say anything and buy me what I wanted anyway, or to say something before it is shipped and run the risk of being labelled ungrateful, spoiled etc. Also because the retailer is a bit dodgy there is the risk that she might not be able to get her money back i.e. exchanges only but as I don't trust the manufacturer there is nothing that I would prefer from them.

My parents are not hard up by any means, but as it was such a lot of money I chose the hard option and messaged her saying I was grateful for the effort but its not my style is there anyway we could get a refund. I also emailed messaged the retailer and asked them to hold off sending it. I am in a different time zone so she won't see the message until later.

So AIBU for telling the truth and causing her pain or should I have put-up and shut-up and be grateful that I got something similar to what I asked for.

OP posts:
Meadowfinch · 16/03/2024 03:28

Being in 'floods of tears for two hours' over a birthday present, a piece of jewellery, is a bit daft. Don't you think that's a bit of an over-reaction? OK, you're a bit disappointed but no-one died.

Your mum has bought you an expensive item of jewellery from the year of your birth, a kind & generous thing to do.

If you cannot (or don't want to) exchange it, then you had two reasonable and good mannered options.

  1. Say thank you, then tuck it away in a jewellery box until it comes into fashion or your tastes change.
  2. Say thank you and then quietly sell it and buy something you prefer with the proceeds.

Getting into a row with your mum will just cause a lot of hurt and achieve nothing. But it's done now. You'll both just have to make the best of it.

moonfacer · 16/03/2024 03:30

YANBU for telling the truth. I really hope your mum gets a refund. Do distance selling rules apply?

But as you have been burnt many times by her gift giving, I think you could possibly have foreseen this and not asked her to buy such a high value item.

I think I would also just tell her that you don’t want to exchange gifts in future. It’s causing you more angst than joy. Also stop sending her birthday gifts.

telestrations · 16/03/2024 03:40

My Mum does this all the time though on a less grand scale. The gifts have nothing to do with me it's all a dopamine hit for her and anything I actually want, need or suggest just doesn't do it. I'd really prefer that she just spend it on herself.

Deebee90 · 16/03/2024 03:45

I’d tell her. Is it jewellery, bags, shoes what? If it’s that special you need to be honest ask for the money back and say exactly what you want.

HawkersEast · 16/03/2024 03:49

Sorry, I think being in a flood of tears for 2 hrs because of a bday present is ridiculous so for that alone you're being unreasonable/ungrateful.

HappiestSleeping · 16/03/2024 03:51

moonfacer · 16/03/2024 03:30

YANBU for telling the truth. I really hope your mum gets a refund. Do distance selling rules apply?

But as you have been burnt many times by her gift giving, I think you could possibly have foreseen this and not asked her to buy such a high value item.

I think I would also just tell her that you don’t want to exchange gifts in future. It’s causing you more angst than joy. Also stop sending her birthday gifts.

But as you have been burnt many times by her gift giving, I think you could possibly have foreseen this and not asked her to buy such a high value item.

This 👆

My mum is terrible for this. I am grateful that she thinks of me and wants to buy a gift, but frustrated that she asks, but doesn't listen to the answer, and knows me so little that she has no concept of what I might actually like.

I have settled on a stock answer these days that I don't want / needanything, but if she would like to buy me something, please don't spend more than £10.

KomodoOhno · 16/03/2024 05:08

I think it's normal to be disappointed but not in a flood of tears. One of my biggest regrets is being ungrateful for a gift my mom gave me. I was a total spoiled brat about it. Later I loved the gift used it every day. She's say and see you hated it when I gave it to you. To this day I use it weekly. I still feel ashamed about it. My daughter recently didn't care for some gifts and let me tell you I got my karma.

TealSapphire · 16/03/2024 05:22

I would have just asked her to hold off until you'd found the specific item you wanted, rather than confusing her with multiple suggestions.

MississippiAF · 16/03/2024 05:24

It’s fine not to like a present but your reaction is OTT

Are you questioning your life decisions in the run up to this birthday, as you said?

TiredCatLady · 16/03/2024 05:36

YANBU, from bitter experience.

Whatever happens, I hope you have a lovely birthday.

PoochiesPinkEars · 16/03/2024 05:41

Your reaction was entirely private so able to be raw and honest no harm done, and understandable given the context of your emotional landscape right now. It's not just the gift, it's everything now and before that's connected to your birthday the gift and your mum. You're just vulnerable at the moment.

Custardcreamandcoffee · 16/03/2024 05:45

In answer to your question, yes you are being an ungrateful brat! Get over yourself

BlastedPimples · 16/03/2024 05:45

Are you so upset because over and over again you don't feel heard by your mother?

Not just about the gift?

donteatthedaisies0 · 16/03/2024 05:46

HawkersEast · 16/03/2024 03:49

Sorry, I think being in a flood of tears for 2 hrs because of a bday present is ridiculous so for that alone you're being unreasonable/ungrateful.

It's a bit erm childish .

Kwasi · 16/03/2024 05:48

I get where you’re coming from. DH spends a couple of hundred quid every birthday and Christmas on Pandora charms I don’t like or wear. He thinks I am ungrateful because he’s spent a lot of money. I want Pandora charms for Christmas about as much as he does.

hattie43 · 16/03/2024 05:49

YANBU

Why on earth people ask you what you'd like for your birthday and then get something totally different is beyond me .

Years ago my dad got me a hideous watch for my 21st despite me showing him what I'd like . It stayed in a drawer for years unworn so far from being a treasured item I've never seen it and couldn't tell you where it is now , presumably lost after many house moves .

If people go to the trouble of asking what you'd like then take it then aren't lying and buy what they'd like , simple .

bradpittsbathwater · 16/03/2024 05:49

Kwasi · 16/03/2024 05:48

I get where you’re coming from. DH spends a couple of hundred quid every birthday and Christmas on Pandora charms I don’t like or wear. He thinks I am ungrateful because he’s spent a lot of money. I want Pandora charms for Christmas about as much as he does.

I don't blame you. Pandora is tacky crap

Rosiiee · 16/03/2024 05:53

Eh if it makes you feel better I turned 30 this week and didn’t get anything from my parents. I’ll take whatever it is you’re getting off your hands x

PoochiesPinkEars · 16/03/2024 05:55

I also have a mum who does terrible gifts, but she's well meaning just daft. She's not ignoring my preferences. She also thinks surprises are important 🤦 funnily enough I don't. 🤣
I think you'll never change your mum so you may as well just smile and say thanks to most gifts. Rant to a friend, make it funny if you can.

But I get why you messaged her on this one. I don't think there's a right choice here, given you had the chance to save her from an expensive mistake it was worth a try. You were part of the buying process so it's not as though your interfering. The risk is, if she doesn't act or the purchase goes ahead cos she can't cancel she also came really give it to you.
Will it spoil your relationship then?
It's a bit lose lose whatever you do.
You can tell her that you appreciate her intentions but since it hasn't shipped yet you wanted to give her chance to avoid wasting her money because you love her.

PoochiesPinkEars · 16/03/2024 05:59

Kwasi · 16/03/2024 05:48

I get where you’re coming from. DH spends a couple of hundred quid every birthday and Christmas on Pandora charms I don’t like or wear. He thinks I am ungrateful because he’s spent a lot of money. I want Pandora charms for Christmas about as much as he does.

That's mad! Why on earth does anyone think lots of money spent overrules any style or taste preferences. I don't get that mentality at all!
Must drive you mad.
Have you said what you said here to him... That you don't want it anymore than he does.... Surely he'd get it then!?

Commonsenseisnotsocommon · 16/03/2024 06:07

Goodness me, sorry to say it but you sound both a spoilt brat and a drama queen. Might do you good to volunteer some of your time to actually helping others to understand just how good you've got it and how ungrateful you're being. Rein it in, not very attractive behaviour at any age.

hattie43 · 16/03/2024 06:27

Commonsenseisnotsocommon · 16/03/2024 06:07

Goodness me, sorry to say it but you sound both a spoilt brat and a drama queen. Might do you good to volunteer some of your time to actually helping others to understand just how good you've got it and how ungrateful you're being. Rein it in, not very attractive behaviour at any age.

What a ridiculous response .

There's nothing wrong with being upset over being given a rubbish present when you've put so much time and effort into helping the person ie her own mum , get her a gift she wants .

Maybe you have such low value of yourself you're grateful for anything no matter how awful .

Commonsenseisnotsocommon · 16/03/2024 06:47

hattie43 · 16/03/2024 06:27

What a ridiculous response .

There's nothing wrong with being upset over being given a rubbish present when you've put so much time and effort into helping the person ie her own mum , get her a gift she wants .

Maybe you have such low value of yourself you're grateful for anything no matter how awful .

No, not at all. I just appreciate kindness and have good manners enough to accept well intentioned gifts with grace. Jeez, if this makes op cry for 2 hours how the hell does she cope with daily life?! Oh, and by the way, if you don't like my response that's fine but you need not try and belittle me, it reflects poorly on you.

GoingOnHol · 16/03/2024 06:53

TealSapphire · 16/03/2024 05:22

I would have just asked her to hold off until you'd found the specific item you wanted, rather than confusing her with multiple suggestions.

That's what I was thinking,why send links to a website that you wouldn't buy from because it had dodgy reviews?!
I'd have done my research and sent one link asking for one specific thing
But too late now unfortunately.

Kickstartplease · 16/03/2024 07:07

But you don't know when in the process she actually purchased it do you? She could have purchased it as soon as you made the year suggestion & so even though you changed your mind it was done.
My Mum nearly always gives me gifts I don't like, but she tries & that's what is important

Swipe left for the next trending thread