Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex FIL angry at DC's when they visit

137 replies

HairdryerMary · 10/12/2023 20:37

Split up about a year ago. I instigated the split and stayed in the family home. Ex refuses to come here.
He moved back in with his parents. Sleeps on their sofa. He says he has no way of being able to move out which is probably true as we live in an expensive city and he is a retail assistant.
Therefore one day of the week, I drop our children (7 and 8, one has additional needs) to his parents and pick them up at 6/7. His parents are older and had looked forward to having a bit of peace. I can feel that my ex FIL is annoyed at having to share his weekends/ home/ tv with small children again.
Recently he has been shouting at them and being short tempered in general at them. Sometimes there is a reason but mostly it's for relatively small things. The worst thing is he stays angry at them (not saying bye and being off with them/ sitting in a different room). The kids notice and say that they don't want to go there anymore.
I completely understand that it must be frustrating having to share your house with a grown up son and small children again but it's one day a week and it's not my children's fault. If he wants to, he could say to his son, my ex, that he needs to move out. He could kick him out and see if he would be able to get social housing (unlikely I know).
Until then I don't know how to protect my children. They're not angels but they deserve to feel safe and loved and valued. I don't want them to go somewhere where someone rolls their eyes and walks out of the room when they come in.
Has anyone found any magic solutions? I know in the summer it's easier for my ex to take them out all day but in winter it's cold and he doesn't have limitless money. On one day after school they stay in a cafe for four hours with him so they don't have to go back to his parents house. It's far from ideal.

OP posts:
HairdryerMary · 11/12/2023 11:15

@Bearbookagainandagain yes I think this might be the best option. Thanks x

OP posts:
Haydenn · 11/12/2023 11:53

I think the support, kindness and understanding you are showing your ex is admirable. But in all of this your children should be the absolute priority.

if you ex-father makes them unhappy or uncomfortable then the kids shouldn’t be around him. Any financial security you have should support your children-unless your ex puts in a formal claim against you. It isn’t up to you to financially help your ex see his children.

you sound like a tough cookie OP. But you shouldn’t have to fix everyone

Firefly2009 · 11/12/2023 14:57

It seems unreasonable to me that he won't spend time in the family home to see his children.
If he won't do that, and you reasonably don't want them in the crowded, grumpy grandparent's home, then he has to accept he sees them in the family home or for a lot less time somewhere in a public, but warm place.

None of this makes a lot of sense to me. You've always supported him yet he won't get professional help and won't come to your home. It's almost as if he's sabotaging whilst you try to rescue. Bizarre.

GoonDog · 11/12/2023 15:34

OP I applaud you for trying everything here. I don't agree you should sell your house to help financially.

If it helps, my Dad was mentally unwell, who did kill himself. When my parents split, he wouldn't see us at the family home, and he was in a hostel, so it wasn't safe for us to go there. He lost his job too, so we couldn't do anything that cost money (there were 3 of us kids).

We only had 1 summer and 1 winter before he died, but summer was definitely easier. We tried the libraries, museums etc, but they soon get fed up of being treated as a creche. We did do things outdoors, such as tobogganing down big hills when it was muddy. Sounds odd, and it was dirty, but clothes can be washed and it was fun. We actively got involved in looking in the local newspapers for free events, so we got to try things we might not have been taken to. Mum sent us out with packed lunches etc. We didn't always go though, so we saw less of him, because sometimes we just didn't want to, or we didn't want to be cold etc. We always had the choice.

Squirrelsonthescaffolding · 11/12/2023 18:08

‘I stopped counting when I got to the 2nd “early dementia “post.

Can the armchair psychiatrists PLEASE stop saying this!!! Early onset dementia is an horrific disease and manifests itself in way more ways than someone being a bit grumpy and unreasonable. So please FUCKING STOP IT, unless you have either lived experience or psychiatric qualifications.’

This seems unnecessarily harsh. First, my comment was posted before the info about the other adults living there was posted by OP. Second, mood changes are a well-recognised feature of early dementia, eg see NHS website. Ie the early stages of the disease. I didn’t say early onset dementia which is not the same thing. (And I don’t know the FIL’s age so wouldn’t assume early onset.) Third, this was only raised as a possibility and I also posted suggestions re the situation . I would never ‘armchair diagnose’ . Fourthly, and perhaps less relevant really in this context because I don’t think it’s necessary to have these to point out a possibility, but yes, I do have almost daily ‘lived experience’ and clinical experience with dementia, very sadly.

OP, I hope you’re getting useful advice and all the best to you and your DC.

alexdgr8 · 11/12/2023 18:57

Nosleepforthismum · 11/12/2023 05:46

You sound lovely OP but I actually think you are possibly harming your children by allowing them continued contact with their dad who is an addict. My mum was an alcoholic in my childhood and had many, many relapses. In my experience it is nearly impossible to get clean and stay clean without professional intervention. I don’t get from your posts that your ex has gone down this route? Which means the likelihood of a relapse being extremely high.

Honestly, in your position, I’d not allow contact until he’d got proper help and had somewhere safe for his kids to visit. You have to protect your kids from this. You can still be kind and tell them that Dad is poorly and needs to get better before he can see them again. If he is suicidal, there is not a single thing you can do to stop this and you need to harden your heart a little because you cannot expose your children to this sort of stuff. Don’t continue contact for your exes benefit over your childrens.

this is spot on, OP.

Bleakmidwinter1977 · 11/12/2023 19:29

HairdryerMary · 10/12/2023 21:29

You're all making very well meaning suggestions and I sound very negative but my ex is very vulnerable at present. He is a recovering addict with a lot of trauma and although I had to stop him living in the house for our wellbeing, I don't want him to have to fight for contact or feel even shitter about his situation than he does. He has alienated everyone in his life through his addiction and doesn't have much confidence in leaving the house aoart from to do stuff he knows. He feels like it's too tempting at this stage in his recovery. I want to do all I can to help and for him to stay clean but I can't let our children be shouted at.

I'm not sure I would be happy to allow unsupported visits given the circumstances.

I would insist he visited at the family home or take matters up with the court.

You might be concerned about him, but it's the children that need to come first, the man sounds like a liability.

converseandjeans · 12/12/2023 00:15

They have two other adult children living at home who are in the other bedrooms.

I think ex FIL is probably fed up of his grown up kids still living there tbh.

You sound lovely. Could either of you afford to book a Travelodge or YHA occasionally so they could all stay overnight somewhere? Use the TV & have more privacy? YHA would be cheaoer as you can prepare food there.

Also is MIL around to help entertain them - baking, out to shop etc.

I think he sounds worn down by it all & if he works 6 days a week for minimum wage, can't drive, can't afford a small flat then I'm not surprised he's not full of positivity.

Sunday is actually a hard day to entertain kids.

NaughtybutNice77 · 12/12/2023 08:29

It's not ideal no, but it's not your FILs job to facilitate your childrens visitation. Long term you need a plan but in the meantime could he see the children at the marital home and you go out? You probably don't want that, but then neither does your FIL and they're your children.

Firefly2009 · 12/12/2023 08:47

@NaughtybutNice77 I have suggested this too. It seems like the obvious, easiest option that solves most of the issue. For some reason he can't or won't do it.

Scintella · 02/05/2024 21:34

GPs pay for him to take them to eg football training or similar and DF gets to socialise with other dads. DCs get sport exercise, they are out of the house. Fills as morning.

Spinningroundahelix · 02/05/2024 22:18

Please don't set yourself on fire to keep somebody else warm. You and your house is your children's security. If your ex was that bothered about his children he'd come to your house to see them. If you sell your house you 'll be dependant on the whims of landlords and the rental market. You are unlikely to get that security back. Do not jeopardize the security of children including one with a disability to prop up your ex.

Even if you did sell and give him money, he might still kill himself and where would you be then - in a rented flat.

He might not even keep paying the rent or get evicted for not keeping the terms of the lease and lose the bond. After all it was his behavior that meant the relationship went bad. It doesn't look like he or any of his siblings have managed living alone and that is not your responsibility. You would no longer have your house and he'd be back at his dad's.

There are people who are limp reeds. They suck the life out of other people because they can't take responsibility for themselves. Ithink your ex may be one of those.

I think the previous poster who suggested less but better time is the right way to go.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page