I still can’t work out of this thread is meant to be serious or not, it seems very air-headed.
I quite like Starmer and think he’s doing okay.
I’m not sure how useful his YouGov approval rating is, particularly without comparison to other party leaders, past and present. His approval ratings appear to be significantly better than Sunak’s at least, which is the most important thing.
As to why Starmer’s approval ratings are low, I’d assume that’s largely a reflection of the influence of our Tory-friendly media, a portion of Labour voters perceiving him as being insufficiently left wing, where we are in the election cycle (I don’t think it’s easy for any opposition leader to gain much traction before a general election campaign) and probably a few policy items - like the trans issue. I do think he is also a bit lacking in charisma, although that doesn’t concern me personally.
I also suspect that appearing as the least-worst option to the widest section of voters is part of his electoral strategy. It’s all well inspiring lots of very enthusiastic supporters (like Corbyn did) but that doesn’t necessarily translate to electoral success.
Would it be nice if Starmer had a little bit more charisma? Yeah, probably. Should he have a ‘makeover’? No - in fact I think he’d be widely ridiculed if he even tried it, like when William Hague tried out a baseball cap and I dare say would lose him support.