Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say to parents of fussy eaters…

143 replies

dogssaywoof · 25/08/2023 09:31

That it’s not your fault?

I’ve seen lots of posts on here where parents of fussy eaters are told that it had just fed their child a better diet/didn’t give any other options/let them try different foods as a baby etc etc that they wouldn’t be such a fussy eater. it always sounds like there’s an underlying blame on the parents for not trying different or more adventurous foods because someone else said they fed their baby a better diet and now they eat quinoa and olives and honey smoked salmon etc.

i just wanted to post to say that this is NOT always the case.

as a baby, I was fed a multitude of different foods from weaning. As a 2 year old I ate mussels, asparagus, garlic mushrooms, and all sorts of other weird and wonderful foods. I ate every fruit and vegetable. Was as far from a fussy eater as possible. But as I got older as a child that changed completely. I like vegetables now but only a few types vs every type as a 4 year old. I used to love seafood and physically don’t think I could swallow it out of disgust now. I don’t like egg yolk, again, something I loved and had no problems with it. There’s a list of things I dislike now. If I get a burger I have to get absolutely everything off it. No cheese. No salad. No pasta. No pizza. No red meat. No dressings/dips/sauces. You get the drill

im not saying it’s good to be a fussy eater because obviously it can be restrictive but what I am saying is that it’s not always to do with the foods etc you feed them as an infant. Otherwise I would be the most adventurous eater in the world! My mum took me to the dr as a child who said it’s just the way some people’s tastebuds are and it’s normal. Sometimes tastebuds change over time and people can dislike things, some people will dislike more things than normal but if your child is fussy please don’t blame yourself because actually it’s probably nothing to do with what you fed them and it’s just the way they are!

OP posts:
NorthernSarcasticandDownrightFantastic · 28/08/2023 10:33

Brieandcamembert · 25/08/2023 20:12

Absolute amen to you.

People use ready made baby food pouches to wean, give children bland rubbish and I even heard a parent say to a toddler the other day "no you can't try it, you won't like it, it's spicy"

A very tiny minority of people have genuine sensory sensitivity to food. Even then, if they had never been fed a chicken nugget, smiley face chip, instant noodles or a tin of spaghetti then they wouldn't be able to restrict their diet to that. Even with genuine restrictive eaters I gave no time for parents complaining their child eats turkey dinosaurs, Coco pops and micro noodles because they shouldn't have been fed if in the first place a a meal option.

I was never given anything but home cooked, "adventurous" food.
Didn't have a McDonald's til I was 12
We occasionally got fish and chips at the seaside as a treat, no takeaways, no "freezer food" ever.

I ate plain pasta, plain boiled rice. Because they're safe. I knew exactly what they would taste like.
I still do, or freezer food, when I'm feeling overwhelmed in other areas of my life. It is literally all I can eat at those times, or I won't eat. Fed is best. If you dislike your kids enough that you want them to suffer so you "win", that's on you.

HappyMummaOfOne · 28/08/2023 18:32

I am an extremely fussy eater and it has NOTHING to do with my parents or what they fed me! It’s so annoying when people make all sorts of stupid comments about they should have done XYZ …as if they didn’t try!

even as an adult I can’t make myself eat lots of foods due to a type of anxiety (my heart starts racing, I get hot and sweaty, I feel sick, I want to cry and if I manage to get the food into my mouth I start gagging and can’t swallow.) and that’s if I can even manage to get it near my mouth, mostly I just refuse to try the food.

when I was a kid and refused food my parents tried everything and nothing would/could make me eat something….

  • you won’t leave the table without eating this meal - ok I slept at the table.
  • you won’t have anything to eat unless you eat this - fine I won’t eat
  • my mum trying hiding the vegetables ect..I knew and wouldn’t eat anything on the plate. —one time after not eating the night before I came down to breakfast and my mum had warmed up the tomato soup from the evening before….so I sat at the table until she had to take me to school. I came home from school and guess what was for tea, yes tomato soup! I still refused and so my mum eventually got me something else. So the whole idea of someone eating something if they are hungry enough is ridiculous to me.

Over the years I have realised I only eat white/beige food as I see them as “safe”. I have no idea where this comes from and I WANT to eat better but I can’t because I literally go into an anxiety attack. So blaming my parents is silly as it’s not them it’s just me and my brain stopping me :(

Doone21 · 28/08/2023 20:43

I don't think people blame parents for having fussy eaters, I think they blame them for giving in to fussy eaters. Totally different.

bluebellmountain · 28/08/2023 20:44

HappyMummaOfOne · 28/08/2023 18:32

I am an extremely fussy eater and it has NOTHING to do with my parents or what they fed me! It’s so annoying when people make all sorts of stupid comments about they should have done XYZ …as if they didn’t try!

even as an adult I can’t make myself eat lots of foods due to a type of anxiety (my heart starts racing, I get hot and sweaty, I feel sick, I want to cry and if I manage to get the food into my mouth I start gagging and can’t swallow.) and that’s if I can even manage to get it near my mouth, mostly I just refuse to try the food.

when I was a kid and refused food my parents tried everything and nothing would/could make me eat something….

  • you won’t leave the table without eating this meal - ok I slept at the table.
  • you won’t have anything to eat unless you eat this - fine I won’t eat
  • my mum trying hiding the vegetables ect..I knew and wouldn’t eat anything on the plate. —one time after not eating the night before I came down to breakfast and my mum had warmed up the tomato soup from the evening before….so I sat at the table until she had to take me to school. I came home from school and guess what was for tea, yes tomato soup! I still refused and so my mum eventually got me something else. So the whole idea of someone eating something if they are hungry enough is ridiculous to me.

Over the years I have realised I only eat white/beige food as I see them as “safe”. I have no idea where this comes from and I WANT to eat better but I can’t because I literally go into an anxiety attack. So blaming my parents is silly as it’s not them it’s just me and my brain stopping me :(

This is a really helpful insight, I always wonder how it feels to my 4 year old! When he does show an interest in new food and says he wants to taste it I watch him and can see that it's almost physically impossible for him to put it to his mouth. It's like his arm just won't do what he wants it to do!

I was advised by an older Health Visitor to re offer the same food to my son who refuses to eat, I was horrified!

lavenderlou · 28/08/2023 20:47

Doone21 · 28/08/2023 20:43

I don't think people blame parents for having fussy eaters, I think they blame them for giving in to fussy eaters. Totally different.

What is "giving in?" Not force-feeding your child? There are pages and pages of posts on here about how you cannot get some children to eat certain foods and forcing the issue is only likely to create long-term issues around eating.

NeelyOHara1 · 28/08/2023 20:48

As food is such a fundamental it's peculiar why it can be so contentious an issue. Is it a recent thing in countries that no longer struggle with simply having any food at all or a thing in general, regardless?

Doone21 · 28/08/2023 20:59

Giving in for example by spending your life cooking 3 different meals for all your fussy eaters.
Take it or leave it always worked up til now didn't it? My parents didn't force me to eat anything I didn't like but neither did they waste their time trying to please everyone and panicking because their little precious only had a sandwich all day.

Theoriginalmrscillianmurphy · 28/08/2023 21:10

I'm a bit of a fussy eater. There's no chance I could learn to like any food.

I go green at the gills at the thought of eating certain foods, lobster, prawns, chicken livers, any kind of livers oh Jesus no

Takacupokindnessyet · 28/08/2023 22:43

Doone21 · 28/08/2023 20:59

Giving in for example by spending your life cooking 3 different meals for all your fussy eaters.
Take it or leave it always worked up til now didn't it? My parents didn't force me to eat anything I didn't like but neither did they waste their time trying to please everyone and panicking because their little precious only had a sandwich all day.

So choices

  1. give in and prepare separate meal
  2. Force feed by nasogastric tube indefinitely
crushercreel · 28/08/2023 23:50

Doone21 · 28/08/2023 20:59

Giving in for example by spending your life cooking 3 different meals for all your fussy eaters.
Take it or leave it always worked up til now didn't it? My parents didn't force me to eat anything I didn't like but neither did they waste their time trying to please everyone and panicking because their little precious only had a sandwich all day.

Take it or leave it always worked up til now didn't it?

No it fucking well didn't.

Like I said to the other poster who bragged about repeatedly sending her son to bed hungry, I ended up in hospital as a result of that approach.

Doone21 · 29/08/2023 06:53

I don't think mental illness can be lumped together in the same category of dealing with day to day fussiness which is just normal for children trying out their independence.
You sound like you're still angry with your parents for how they chose to approach the problem

Takacupokindnessyet · 29/08/2023 07:59

Doone21 · 29/08/2023 06:53

I don't think mental illness can be lumped together in the same category of dealing with day to day fussiness which is just normal for children trying out their independence.
You sound like you're still angry with your parents for how they chose to approach the problem

Yes all children will be fussy at some point but that doesn't make it ok to assume that any child refusing to eat is simply being fussy and that parents have just given up without trying everything they can think of.
There are many reasons for food issues including mental illness, neurodiversity, food intolerance and other conditions affecting the digestive system or the chewing and swallowing processes and it isn't always easy to get to the door of the problem and get a diagnosis.

crushercreel · 29/08/2023 09:16

Doone21 · 29/08/2023 06:53

I don't think mental illness can be lumped together in the same category of dealing with day to day fussiness which is just normal for children trying out their independence.
You sound like you're still angry with your parents for how they chose to approach the problem

Who mentioned mental illness?

Doone21 · 29/08/2023 09:40

Because refusal of food when hungry or in need is not normal anywhere in nature.

crushercreel · 29/08/2023 10:26

Doone21 · 29/08/2023 09:40

Because refusal of food when hungry or in need is not normal anywhere in nature.

And so the only possible explanation is mental illness?

I was not mentally ill at the time. Turns out I'm autistic with sensory issues, which was assumed to be what you so flippantly describe as "day to day fussiness".

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 29/08/2023 11:02

Doone21 · 29/08/2023 09:40

Because refusal of food when hungry or in need is not normal anywhere in nature.

Yes but where else in nature does the consumer of the food have the ability to cognitively like or dislike foods/tastes/textures, actively refuse and then make a decision to seek an alternative from the many thousands of food options open to us as humans?

It's all well and good saying "cows aren't picky" when all they have available to them is grass.

Kazzybingbong · 30/08/2023 14:12

Peony654 · 25/08/2023 10:01

I agree. Babies and children can eat anything, obviously with being careful with salt. I think being a "fussy" eater as an adult is mostly a choice though, you can learn to like any food.

No you can’t. I hate nuts and I hate tea, they’re both vile and there is no way I could ever learn to like those things. That’s a ridiculous statement.

Whatafustercluck · 30/08/2023 14:18

We congratulated ourselves when our eldest came along and tried everything, and ate most things. What great parents we must be!

Then our youngest came along...

Yanbu.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page