I don't generally go on these threads as it hasn't been relevant to me until now, but does it ever come up that different ways suit not only different mums but also different children? I don't know if that is true but something to think about perhaps? Maybe some children thrive at nursery etc. I don't know, I'm not experienced enough.
I guess for me another salient question harking back to what Xenia said is is it better for a child to be at home with a crap SAHP or be in good childcare? If a child is at home but just plonked in front of cbeebies (no judgement having just discovered the benefits of this myself in distracting a clingy 8 mo!) or in a nursery being stimulated and having lots of company.
I'm not saying SAHP stick their child in front of the tv but if they do would the child be better of in stimulating childcare?