When you are on the other side of the recruitment stuff, you do really see why there are different parts to the process though. Loads of the people you interview really won’t have the skills, experience or disposition for the job. And they’re the ones that got through a screening process to interview!
I’ve interviewed people who cannot outline the headline findings of the PhD they literally just finished (which matters a great deal for a job which listed the ability to communicate complex issues to non-expert audiences), people who genuinely don’t know some absolutely basic stuff (pretty alarmingly so in some cases) and in some cases people whose personal values are pretty terrifying (we’re talking in the realms of expressing actual racism and stuff 🤦🏻♀️).
Equally, we’ve all worked with people who most definitely should have been weeded out and not offered a job too. So that helps to underline why the processes do need to be fairly rigorous. And sometimes why the cultural fit stuff is especially important. I’ve interviewed at companies where I knew I wouldn’t consider taking the job because it became apparent that I would most definitely not be a good cultural fit there.
I’ve also left jobs because, frankly, they were awful places to work and the culture was just horrendous (right from the top!). I feel lucky that I’m in a position now
where professionally I can make these kind of choices because I’m beyond the needing to take any job I can stage.
My eldest son is at the trying to get started phase of jobs and it’s definitely really tough. There are loads of candidates for every job and he’s had some pretty dismal
experiences. He did have to quit a job because he genuinely felt unsafe working there - being expected to work with unsafe electrical equipment and to deal with aggressive, drunk customers without any security support. His employer won’t have improved anything - there are enough people who desperately need the work and don’t have the ability to quit and look
for something else.
The other issue is underemployment at that end of the market. Even when you get a job, they just don’t seem to offer full time hours. So many employers, it seems, would rather employ loads of people and give them too few hours than actually offer proper, full time jobs. The government unemployment figures like to hide this though by focusing on how many people have any kind of employment.