Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Black Monday anyone? The tories should be in jail

994 replies

Upthebracket22 · 26/09/2022 06:51

The pound is now at its lowest point against the dollar since decimalisation in 1971 at 1.03. It’s probably going lower and the Bank of England will likely need to step in with an emergency interest rate rise today. Black Monday possibly?

All because of the mini budget on Friday. The Tories should be in jail. Especially if their rich backers were shorting the pound as it appears to get rich.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
1dayatatime · 26/09/2022 14:04

JuliaDorneys · 26/09/2022 09:33

People have very short memories.

When Gordon B left office and A Darling left a note on the desk saying 'No money left' the UK was in one of the worst positions for years thanks to Blair but more Brown (who sold our gold and raided pensions.)

The Tories inherited massive debts. You can't turn that around in months or even a few years.

People also forget that - for good or bad- interest rates have been almost zero for years. Good for home buyers, crap for savers and investors.

The past 3 years have been dominated by Covid, global oil prices and gas/oil issues (and yes, the UK ought to have foreseen that one and planned.)

It's been proved time after time that hiking taxes for the very rich doesn't work.
1 There aren't enough of them to make enough impact- it doesn't really help 'the poor'.
2 It creates a brain-drain or tax -location ( just think how many companies now operate out of Dublin!)
3 Companies find a way around it.

The bankers' bonus is one example. When their bonuses were capped by an EU law, all that happened was their base salaries increased. And they pay tax on that and bonuses.

Labour left us in a right old mess. I have not heard anything to convince me they are any better now.

When Labour won the election in 1997 debt to GDP ratio was 35%, 13 years later at the time of the 2010 election it had risen to 62% when the famous "there's no money left " note was found.

However 12 years later the ratio had now risen to 95% and rising.

Both Labour and the Conservatives cannot hold themselves out to be fiscally responsible but at least under Labour the money was spent on improving public services rather than tax cuts.

scaredoff · 26/09/2022 14:05

Blossomtoes · 26/09/2022 12:56

Oh, I think it does - unless you live in a parallel universe.

Well you were the one who cited bookies. It turns out they all disagree with you, and agree with me.

They must all be living in a parallel universe too.

SafeMove · 26/09/2022 14:06

I am a bit of a geek and like to condense (and simplify language as much as possible) and save party manifestos. Tory manifesto in 2019. Only 3 years ago but amazing to see how different lenses are applied for different times Hmm

I know that manifestos aren't worth that paper they are written on but it's interesting to see what has/hasn't been done. I am at the point now where I am so cynical about politics that I am apathetic. I have let the bastards grind me (and my finances) down.

Black Monday anyone? The tories should be in jail
Abhannmor · 26/09/2022 14:10

A lot I could say. But @scaredoff already said it.

Blossomtoes · 26/09/2022 14:13

scaredoff · 26/09/2022 14:05

Well you were the one who cited bookies. It turns out they all disagree with you, and agree with me.

They must all be living in a parallel universe too.

Unless those odds were produced this morning they’re meaningless.

MissWired · 26/09/2022 14:13

They are planning to set up charter cities where UK law does not apply.
No Magna Carta, no employment rights, different taxation laws, no environmental rules. You could literally be owned as a slave there, and you could do nothing about it.

I suspect what is actually happening here is that gas and oil supplies are almost running dry, all over the globe, and that suppliers and governments are aware of this and are beginning to panic, as they unable to tell the public the truth - that without oil and gas, millions if not billions of us will simply die as thefood chain collapses.

Consider this - why have they just opened the borders to 3.6million Chinese, and why are they letting in even more in the next two years, especially given we about to experience Great Depression II?given that we are a tiny island with no ability to feed ourselves and no natural resources? Because the only thing standing between our financial system collapsing entirely is the continued inflation of the insane ponzi scheme that is our housing market, that's why. Because in 2008, the housing bubble nearly destroyed the entire monetary system of the west, so we were forced to bail them all out with taxpayers money.

if it blows again now, every single bank in the western world will go under...and this time, we cannot print our way out of trouble - the market just called time on money printing.

Anyone holding cash in Western banks right now is out of their god damned minds.

as the ship begins to sink, the Tories are looting the hold. And being bribed by their petrochemical masters to do so.

and in the new Charter cities, Magna Carta will no longer apply, and once again the ordinary British will be serfs, as they were for 1500 years.

the Black Death taught us this: that overpopulation means slavery.

There are no vacancies - they want you to work as slaves in the Charter cities, for food, or die.

it's the enclosures acts and the Highland Clearances, all.over.again.

scaredoff · 26/09/2022 14:14

Freudenhaus · 26/09/2022 13:35

other authors being KK and Priti Patel

The point is only 80,000 people voted for her. Hardly put to the public was it

Of course it was. It was put to the public in the form of the EU referendum, combined with the 2019 election for the Tories to Get It Done. Brexit was always a libertarian-right deregulatory wet dream, from conception to completion, and the true intentions of those promoting it were all out there for anyone to see and consider if they wanted to. But they didn't want to, because . . . foreigners.

MermaidEyes · 26/09/2022 14:15

BambinaJAS · 26/09/2022 13:22

Its amusing to see some Brits blame the opposition for the Government doing stupid things.

God, what a basket of deplorables you folks are.

You really do get the Government you deserve.

That's because they're generally the Tory voters who can't bear to think they got things wrong

the80sweregreat · 26/09/2022 14:15

Miss wired
Just shoot me now :(

Suetwo · 26/09/2022 14:17

Zonder · 26/09/2022 07:24

They're not even hiding what they're doing. They're literally getting away with murder and there's nobody to hold them to account.
The BBC are more concerned with examining Labour than holding the government to account.

Are you seriously claiming that the BBC leans towards the Tories? The BBC is virtually a woke, left-wing propaganda unit. They don’t even bother to hide it anymore.

Don’t worry everyone, Labour are ready to take control. They’ll sort the economy out (excuse me while I roll around on the floor laughing). We need Angela Rayner in power. She’ll save us.

BambinaJAS · 26/09/2022 14:17

scaredoff · 26/09/2022 14:14

Of course it was. It was put to the public in the form of the EU referendum, combined with the 2019 election for the Tories to Get It Done. Brexit was always a libertarian-right deregulatory wet dream, from conception to completion, and the true intentions of those promoting it were all out there for anyone to see and consider if they wanted to. But they didn't want to, because . . . foreigners.

This is correct

When it comes right down to it the Brits are incapable of blaming themselves. They revert to the default state of "it must be somebody elses fault", which is why foreigners were an easy target.

The reality has been there all along: the quality of British politicians.

Now the denizens of the UK are about to experience what happens when their reality distortion field is crushed by economoc realities.

vera99 · 26/09/2022 14:20

scaredoff · 26/09/2022 14:00

Labour grasped that and put Starmer in charge. Now there's no shortage of people saying how there's "no effective opposition" and no point voting Labour because they'd barely change anything. And you know what? They're right.

This is a fucking ridiculous circular argument. Labour under Corbyn produced two manifestos outlining a different way of taking the country forward. People made a free choice not to elect them. But they remain unelected because people didn't elect them, not the other way around. The fact that they didn't get elected doesn't prove retrospectively that they were "unelectable". To be electable, all people had to do was vote for them, which was a choice.

There's a serious point here. We're in the early stages of momentous historical change. This is not just your everyday minor squabble about whether the base rate of tax should be 20% or 19%, within a balanced mixed-economy consensus that most people feel comfortable in and trust to look after their future prosperity. This is the death throws of the international capitalist system that has never really recovered since 2008, combined with the additional unprecedented challenges of climate change.

Most people are in complete denial about the scale of radical change that is necessary, and is GOING to happen one way or another - whether from the left, as Labour attempted in 2017 and 2019, or from the right supporting Trump's attempted takeover of American democracy and now winning government in Italy. Meanwhile, they convince themselves that they obviously "CAN'T" vote for someone who has a beard and was the subject of a series of fabricated character assasinations by the right wing press. They can't vote for him because he's unelectable, and he's unelectable because they can't vote for him!

I'm not even saying all Labour's proposals for change were the right ones. But anyone who thinks we're still in ground central exercising healthy suspicion about anyone suggesting changes that require more than a three-word soundbite to understand, is kidding themselves. That ship has sailed.

Radical change from the left under Corbyn was one of the options. The other was radical change from the right, which is what we're now getting. The difference is that Corbyn was honest about it.

100% this.

Parsley1234 · 26/09/2022 14:20

@MissWired what are the charter cities

BambinaJAS · 26/09/2022 14:20

MermaidEyes · 26/09/2022 14:15

That's because they're generally the Tory voters who can't bear to think they got things wrong

Sure.

But at a certain point, when the evidence is so colossally against your viewpoint, some sanity must prevail.

Thats the problem now.

I am not seeing "sanity". I have only see this twice before in my lifetime: Trump in the US, and Bolosonaro in Brazil.

The only realistic result of this now is massive empoverishment of the UK population.

scaredoff · 26/09/2022 14:24

Blossomtoes · 26/09/2022 14:13

Unless those odds were produced this morning they’re meaningless.

They're updated in real time, and bookies whose business isd ealing with thousands of pounds worth of bets aren't going to just leave inappropriate odds on offer after a game-changing event that could potentially bankrupt them.

Come on, just admit you were wrong. You may well be right that the Tories will be voted out, but you were wrong to say someone could get fantastic odds and "clean up" by betting on the fact. They can't.

If you really wanted to, you could consider what factors might be feeding into those bookies' judgments that you hadn't considered in a situation that seems obvious to you.

WatchoRulo · 26/09/2022 14:25

Skyellaskerry · 26/09/2022 12:28

Another item I am dreading the detail of is the reference by KK to reducing planning restrictions as all I can think is that this will remove or massively reduce current environmental assessment requirements.

Large housebuilders are already allowed to whatever the fuck they like (including but not limited to ignoring any planning conditions) around here so it's only regularising what's already happening.

SerendipityJane · 26/09/2022 14:27

But at a certain point, when the evidence is so colossally against your viewpoint, some sanity must prevail.

Not really. Look at all the "raptures" that never occurred and people still queueing up for them. Religion has been subverted by politics. Hence the almost messianic faith in things like "Brexit". Chesterton was right.

vera99 · 26/09/2022 14:28

MissWired · 26/09/2022 14:13

They are planning to set up charter cities where UK law does not apply.
No Magna Carta, no employment rights, different taxation laws, no environmental rules. You could literally be owned as a slave there, and you could do nothing about it.

I suspect what is actually happening here is that gas and oil supplies are almost running dry, all over the globe, and that suppliers and governments are aware of this and are beginning to panic, as they unable to tell the public the truth - that without oil and gas, millions if not billions of us will simply die as thefood chain collapses.

Consider this - why have they just opened the borders to 3.6million Chinese, and why are they letting in even more in the next two years, especially given we about to experience Great Depression II?given that we are a tiny island with no ability to feed ourselves and no natural resources? Because the only thing standing between our financial system collapsing entirely is the continued inflation of the insane ponzi scheme that is our housing market, that's why. Because in 2008, the housing bubble nearly destroyed the entire monetary system of the west, so we were forced to bail them all out with taxpayers money.

if it blows again now, every single bank in the western world will go under...and this time, we cannot print our way out of trouble - the market just called time on money printing.

Anyone holding cash in Western banks right now is out of their god damned minds.

as the ship begins to sink, the Tories are looting the hold. And being bribed by their petrochemical masters to do so.

and in the new Charter cities, Magna Carta will no longer apply, and once again the ordinary British will be serfs, as they were for 1500 years.

the Black Death taught us this: that overpopulation means slavery.

There are no vacancies - they want you to work as slaves in the Charter cities, for food, or die.

it's the enclosures acts and the Highland Clearances, all.over.again.

You may sound apocalyptic but I went to a talk by George Monbiot at the excellent Kite Festival in the summer where he talked about the collapse of the soil ecosystem. The staggering level of complexity and interdependence has been threatened like never before. Our politicians shouldn't be venally lining their pockets but working together to guarantee our collective survival. A non-Tory progressive coalition is our only hope and one that carries the majority of the population behind it with hope and shared sacrifice and responsibility.

www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/may/07/secret-world-beneath-our-feet-mind-blowing-key-to-planets-future

Grumpybutfunny · 26/09/2022 14:28

@MissWired you do realise he's talking about investment zones? The idea is to scrap planning laws and lower tax in exchange for businesses investing in areas that need it. UK employment law has swung to far towards to worker in terms of international competition the idea is to try and reverse that. Say you live in the North East (we do) you have large areas where generations of people have never worked, if you can bringing in investment in say manufacturing and then force these people into the jobs it could be great for the country as a whole. Up here the loss of low pay manual jobs hasn't pushed people towards bettering themselves its results in a group that never works

scaredoff · 26/09/2022 14:28

Suetwo · 26/09/2022 14:17

Are you seriously claiming that the BBC leans towards the Tories? The BBC is virtually a woke, left-wing propaganda unit. They don’t even bother to hide it anymore.

Don’t worry everyone, Labour are ready to take control. They’ll sort the economy out (excuse me while I roll around on the floor laughing). We need Angela Rayner in power. She’ll save us.

The BBC produced a news segment during the 2019 election campaign featuring a mocked-up graphic of Jeremy Corbyn in a Russian hat in front of a backdrop of the Kremlin. They commissioned a "documentary" about the supposed antisemitism crisis in the Labour party without inviting any right of reply from those being accused. What did they have to say about the candidate who is on record as using racial slurs against black people and muslim women?

StJeanDeVence · 26/09/2022 14:33

The BBC is virtually a woke, left-wing propaganda unit.

Give me strength.

Richard Simon Sharp (born 8 February 1956) has been the Chairman of the BBC since February 2021. A former banker, he worked at JP Morgan for eight years, and then for 23 years at Goldman Sachs. Sharp was an advisor to Boris Johnson during his tenure as London Mayor, and to Rishi Sunak as Chancellor. He has donated more than £400,000 to the Conservative Party.

Tim Davie (Director-General of the BBC) Davie stood as a councillor for the Conservative Party in Hammersmith in 1993 and 1994[9][10] and was deputy chairman of the Hammersmith and Fulham Conservative party in the 1990s.

Robbie Gibb, brother of Conservative MP Nick Gibb, was the head of the BBC's political programme output before leaving the BBC in July 2017 to become Director of Communications at 10 Downing Street for Theresa May.

I'm sure I can find you some more if you like?

How you people can say this stuff with a straight face genuinely fascinates me.

vera99 · 26/09/2022 14:35

scaredoff · 26/09/2022 14:28

The BBC produced a news segment during the 2019 election campaign featuring a mocked-up graphic of Jeremy Corbyn in a Russian hat in front of a backdrop of the Kremlin. They commissioned a "documentary" about the supposed antisemitism crisis in the Labour party without inviting any right of reply from those being accused. What did they have to say about the candidate who is on record as using racial slurs against black people and muslim women?

Yes utterly shameful - Corbyn threatened the establishment like no other politician since Keir Hardie.

Black Monday anyone? The tories should be in jail
Mojitoo · 26/09/2022 14:37

Say it louder for the people in the back!

Oh, how utterly foolish. You've even lost the bloody Daily Mail.

Tory apologist cannot see fiscal catastrophe shocker.

BambinaJAS · 26/09/2022 14:42

Grumpybutfunny · 26/09/2022 14:28

@MissWired you do realise he's talking about investment zones? The idea is to scrap planning laws and lower tax in exchange for businesses investing in areas that need it. UK employment law has swung to far towards to worker in terms of international competition the idea is to try and reverse that. Say you live in the North East (we do) you have large areas where generations of people have never worked, if you can bringing in investment in say manufacturing and then force these people into the jobs it could be great for the country as a whole. Up here the loss of low pay manual jobs hasn't pushed people towards bettering themselves its results in a group that never works

What would those investment zones produce?

The folks who do not work have limited to no skills. Companies do not make expensive long-term investment decisions based on "what if" scenarios. The returns on any investment need to be reasonably well known with certainty before pressing the "go" button.

You would need at least 10 years to improve their productivity via skills training.

And thats only one problem

Companies and people in general do not relocate to those areas because the infrastructure is poor. Bad housing, poor schools, poor transport options etc..

"Investment Zones" = pipe dream without massive public investment.

CurseOfBigness · 26/09/2022 14:46

sst1234 · 26/09/2022 07:38

The pound didn’t drop just because of mini budget. The bigger problem for the markets is that interest rates are not going up at the same velocity as the US. If you’re going to have the largesse of printing £450bn in two years to shit down the economy, then rates have to rise to deal with it. The US can afford to to do this because it has a strong economy right now, because believe it or not their economy is structured in exactly the way that people around here don’t like. There is no easy way out of this. You don’t like it, but growth is the only way out of it. This low productivity economy has been on QE life support for too long. The re structuring of the economy though lower taxation and big investment (private and public) is needed. That latter is yet to happen and takes a lot longer.

But why is it so difficult to have rational debate here. When you read the comments on this thread, it’s hysterical shrieking.

You’ve just made a good argument for why the mini budget is so bad for ordinary people.

They helped the rich get richer and poor get poorer in the mini budget. There was no emergency for that.

Then the interest rates go up to again make the rich (savings have higher interest rates) richer yet again and poor (with mortgages etc. poorer again).

Is that correct? A double hit? In the space of a week.