AIBU?
I know this will be contentious - cost of living rise
qualitychat · 31/08/2022 19:57
My mum is a pensioner and gets Disability Benefit and Mobility Benefit and Pension Credit. She receives almost what I get in a month. She is moaning about the Government not doing enough about the cost of gas and electricity, which I agree with. The thing is they have said that people on benefits and pension credit will be given lump sums towards their bills. I am a middle earner and so is my husband. We will likely get nothing. Do you not think it will be the ordinary working families who will be squeezed the most if something is not done?
Am I being unreasonable?
AIBUYou have one vote. All votes are anonymous.
PeloAddict · 31/08/2022 21:25
CredibilityProblem · 31/08/2022 20:05
In general, people with disabilities and older people are more likely to need to use their heating than working age people with no disabilities. So even with the same income it would be reasonable for the government to give her more support.
Also in general, working age people may have more opportunities to work extra hours to increase their income or ask for a pay rise than disabled pensioners.
I can't work any more than 40hrs a week due to health issues. But I'm not sick enough to claim anything. Also live alone and no DC and I suspect single people will get massively screwed over, can't split the bills with anyone but still have to use gas and electric
It's frustrating to earn too much for hell hut not enough that it's a proper living wage
girlfriend44 · 31/08/2022 21:26
Sally99 · 31/08/2022 20:10
There are no extra hours or pay rises to be had for those of us who already work full time, just tightening of belts.
I'm not convinced that you live in real life
CredibilityProblem · 31/08/2022 20:05
In general, people with disabilities and older people are more likely to need to use their heating than working age people with no disabilities. So even with the same income it would be reasonable for the government to give her more support.
Also in general, working age people may have more opportunities to work extra hours to increase their income or ask for a pay rise than disabled pensioners.
Absolutely can't imagine many getting a pay rise or getting extra hours if shops etc are having to close and lose staff. It's not that easy.
Greenstar22 · 31/08/2022 21:27
I totally get what you mean op but I myself was on benefits for a long time. Yes I had enough money, I could even save a portion because there was no travel, childcare costs etc. But the lack of control over my life really affected me. I was worried the amount would be cut or that I would have to work a job far away with no childcare. Of course some people are scroungers with no intention of ever working but I found it really demoralising having to explain my situation and my children seeing no one in the house working. Thankfully my dh is now working and I am a sahm not claiming anything other than child benefit. By working you are teaching your children the right way, best to put those that aren't out of your head, you can't change it so just worry about your own family.
Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 21:27
saveforthat · 31/08/2022 21:24
It's pretty shit to resent anything that your Mum gets and there's no way she has been getting her state pension since age 50. There is a really nasty theme to some threads recently based on resentment of what other people might have/can claim that you can't.
qualitychat · 31/08/2022 20:44
My mum has had these benefits since she was 50. She is not badly disabled, doesn't need a carer, doesn't walk with a stick or anything. She is at home more but that's because she's not out much. I can absolutely assure a previous poster that she does receive all these benefits. I will never receive anything like what she gets when I retire.
Yep. A lot of it is aimed at disabled people. One question people seem to be reluctant to answer though. Looking at the extra money is fine, but are you prepared to accept the disability that goes with it. Because it’s not extra money if it’s eaten up by the effects of that disability is it ?
girlfriend44 · 31/08/2022 21:27
RosetteNebula · 31/08/2022 20:12
Exactly what me and my Mum have been saying. It's workers who will suffer. I'm willing to believe they exist but I don't know a single pensioner or person on benefits who is struggling for money.
They will be when their bills go up and they are on a fixed low income.
chinuptitsoutonwards · 31/08/2022 21:27
Not unreasonable at all. Very true.
DH is a copper and on the home screen of their group page at work is contact points for local food banks. Of his team of ten, three are planning to use them when winter comes. It's madness and it's the same across emergency services.
If the people supposedly keeping us safe can't even afford to feed their families without support there's no fucking chance for the rest of us.
Babyroobs · 31/08/2022 21:29
rainbowmilk · 31/08/2022 21:25
She has no kids, not 3 kids. That’s why she’s not entitled to anything.
Babyroobs · 31/08/2022 21:22
On that income she would definitely be entitled to help especially with 3 kids and rent to pay.
maddiemookins16mum · 31/08/2022 21:14
My colleague (and dear friend) at work, single, no kids, rents a one bedroom flat. Takes home 1480 a month. I’ve sat with her 3 lunchtimes on the trot, helping her see if we can jiggle her budget. After all bills/rent are paid, she currently has £162 left a month for food, petrol and, well just having a life. This is before the increase in her utilities. She is entitled to nothing, yet another colleague will get help as she gets top up benefits as ‘can only work’ limited hours as she won’t pay for childcare.
Sorry must have read the 3 lunchtimes as 3 kids ! Apologies. Yes it's pretty shit for low earners living on their own I agree.
Gazelda · 31/08/2022 21:30
Wow.
I've never seen such blatantly unpleasant and bitter posts aimed at older people and those who have a disability.
And some are event resentful of their own parent for rolling in the benefits they scam off of honest working taxpayers.
Shameful.
Bloody hell.
Ithinkthatisenoughnowthanks · 31/08/2022 21:30
I have a very young baby so have the need to heat my house too, probably to a similar level as a pensioner
You work. You are out of the house during the day? A pension will not be out of the house during the day, particularly given that many pensioner clubs, activities, day centres etc. have lost funding, closed, or are operating reduced hours.
I'm a civil servant so have no option to ask for a payrise OR to increase my hours. Actually I could be 1 on the 91,000 to lose to be made redundant
But you are a healthy adult who could find an additional job to do to bring in some additional income? If you are made redundant, you will be entitled to a redundancy payment and if your household income is then low enough, you will qualify for benefits.
My husband already works 40+ hours so has no option to work addition hours
I have been a single parent for years. Teach full time. Have a couple of side hustles to bring in extra money. If I can do it, as one parent with 3 children (one of whom has a disability), why can't you do it as two parents?
antelopevalley · 31/08/2022 21:32
Gazelda · 31/08/2022 21:30
Wow.
I've never seen such blatantly unpleasant and bitter posts aimed at older people and those who have a disability.
And some are event resentful of their own parent for rolling in the benefits they scam off of honest working taxpayers.
Shameful.
Bloody hell.
I agree, I notice OP does not put any figures. All her mum would get is £182 per week plus disability benefits. OP could get disability benefits if she was disabled too. Nothing to do with age.
MoistBandana · 31/08/2022 21:32
On the spectrum.
On the left, wealthy on £170k won't notice cost of living
On the right, unemployed on £4k a year, pensioners on 10k a year, disabled and sick and people on carers allowance etc will starve and freeze and need to use food banks and heat banks.
I'd rather be nearer the left of the spectrum and have options like lowering bills, cutting outgoings, dropping a car, ditching a holiday.
Wouldloveanother · 31/08/2022 21:32
we’ve pretty much farmed out elderly care to private companies who gouge the elderly for care fees to the point where they have to sell everything they own before they get help
why shouldn’t they pay for their care? We have this bizarre mindset in the U.K. that the elderly shouldn’t have to pay for anything, that they’ve ‘done their bit’ (even though the proportion of SAHMs back then was much much much higher, how much tax did they pay?!) and to expect them to fund anything in unreasonable. I reject that.
Babyroobs · 31/08/2022 21:33
antelopevalley · 31/08/2022 21:30
Because the disability benefits your mum would supposedly get are attendance allowance, which means she needs someone caring for her.
It doesn't necessarily mean they need a carer, just that they have difficulties with personal care. To be honest I have helped hundreds to claim Attendance allowance and it is pretty easy to get. A lot lot easier than disability benefits for people under pension age .They don't even do an assessment.
Thelnebriati · 31/08/2022 21:33
Imagine being jealous of someone that is so disabled they receive mobility. Show your Mum this thread, let her know what you really think of her.
Its not a race to the bottom. Many people will need help. If you want that to happen, do something about it instead of being so credulous you turn on people less well off than you, the group who are more likely to die this winter.
Babyroobs · 31/08/2022 21:35
Wouldloveanother · 31/08/2022 21:32
we’ve pretty much farmed out elderly care to private companies who gouge the elderly for care fees to the point where they have to sell everything they own before they get help
why shouldn’t they pay for their care? We have this bizarre mindset in the U.K. that the elderly shouldn’t have to pay for anything, that they’ve ‘done their bit’ (even though the proportion of SAHMs back then was much much much higher, how much tax did they pay?!) and to expect them to fund anything in unreasonable. I reject that.
I never fail to be amazed by how few women have never hardly worked in their lifetime. I regularly come across women who have barely worked and so barely get much of a state pension and have to rely on pension credit.
edwinbear · 31/08/2022 21:36
@biscuiteer I’ll hold my hands up and admit to having previously been a Tory voter. I will never vote for them again - they’ve shafted absolutely everyone in the country. Low earners, average earners, high earners (by that, I mean high, not super high), disabled people, carers, children, civil servants, small business owners, people who need to use the NHS or a dentist, the list goes on and on.
But, I can’t vote Labour. I’m terrified of a wealth tax. DH is in his 50’s and has an old defined benefits pension worth a lot on paper, he was made redundant from the company that provided it and has struggled to find another decent paying job ever since (being in his 50’s). We have a ‘normal’ semi detached home in London (mortgaged), but being in London it’s worth a good amount. I earn well, but with DC of 10 and 13, we’re not rolling in it. We won’t have to turn the heating off, but it will have to go on less, and if I lose my job, we’re fucked. The thought of a labour government that introduced a wealth tax on our pensions and require us to magic up £20/30/40/50k maybe more, is terrifying. We couldn’t pay it. Who do I vote for?
PrimarilyParented · 31/08/2022 21:37
The problem is that working wages for low wage jobs aren’t significantly higher than benefits. The stagnation in wages over the last decade, whilst benefits have a yearly increase in line with inflation has squeezed this gap ever more. People on benefits aren’t rolling in it, in fact most people on benefits (excepting pensioners) are in work too. The fact is that working people are paid too little and as a country we have become accustomed to low wages and don’t challenge these as much as we should.
EveningOverRooftops · 31/08/2022 21:38
Well done everyone. You’re doing exactly as they planned. Fighting over scraps whilst those at the top rake it in and fail to address the real crushing issues.
fight to change the actual problems not the things we’re being lead to believe are the problems.
1- energy company parent companies making sky high profits whilst their subsidiaries claim they need the price rises.
2- stagnating wages.
3- rents and mortgages that were astronomical in cost compared to wages pre-2019 and have only gotten worse.
4- companies not paying adequate taxes
5- absolutely shocking treatment of workers especially those forced to take zero hours contracts or skilled work only being paid minimum wage because cheap as fuck companies know tax credits and universal credits will top up their employees wages whilst they still make substantial profits.
6- mental and physical health of a great proportion of this country is absolutely shot since March 2020.
7- the countries public services have Been systematically underfunded for over a decade under the guise of austerity but we still ‘can’t afford’ to do many of the things that would significantly improve the health, wellbeing and lives of the populace.
it’s not disabled persons, a pensioners or a benefit claimants fault this shit show is happening anymore than it’s the fault of those working for piss poor wages and/or paying sky high rents.
focus your rage at the ones throwing the fucking breadcrumbs.
Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 21:39
Seafretfreda · 31/08/2022 21:08
Agree wholeheartedly with @Tigerstigers and @NameChangeLifeChange
Both work full time here, decent middle management level, and our take home pay is about the same as FIL’s pension each month! We have a small 3 bed, DC and a second hand car. Our outgoings are higher than theirs as we have a mortgage. PILs get winter fuel payments, free bus passes etc, senior citizens’ entry to everything and are minted compared with us! No mortgage, big brand new car, multiple holidays each year, private health cover, shop at Waitrose, every middle class stereotype going. MIL has never worked full time, more like a day a week for 10 years or so. It’s a joke!
Why is it a joke ? They’ve worked for it, the same way you’re working for it now. Presumably they have no mortgage because they’ve paid it. Do you have children ? If so, would you be happy about people questioning whether you should get that ? When you get to pension age, would you be happy that your state pension is begrudged ? Having children is a choice, being elderly or disabled is not. You’ll be old yourself one day and by then your perspective will change - especially if your health has deteriorated to the point where you have to rely on disability benefits. This is a horrible thread.
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.