Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this a fair punishment for a DC?

87 replies

Justfiguringitout · 21/08/2022 20:14

Today I've been reflecting on something from my childhood. My mum has always held this up as an example of good parenting.

When I was young I had a special item of jewellery that my parents gifted to me, I adored it and wore it all the time.

When I was about 11 or 12 I was at a friend's house and when I got home I realised it was missing (I think I'd taken it off to get in her pool!). I was so upset and filled with an ice cold fear - my mum cannot find out about this. I can feel my chest tightening as I remember this panic!

In the age before mobiles I had to wait until school on Monday to pray the friend had found it. I couldn't risk using the home phone to call her in case mum heard.

Unfortunately it was gone, she hadn't and couldn't find it. I remember weeks of worry over this, my plan was to take all my upcoming birthday money and try and buy a replacement, I just had to keep it quiet until then.

Of course, one day my mum mentioned I wasn't wearing it. I said I just didn't fancy wearing it and mum insisted I went and got it and showed it to her (I'm guessing my poker face sucked!). All hell broke loose.

I actually cannot remember what was said at all. I know she was angry (not physically or screaming though). I remember crying my eyes out both in front of her and privately and apologising profusely.

The next morning all was calm and happy but I felt very on edge. Went to school, picked up, everything still happy. I'd gotten away with it!!

Then I walk into my bedroom and it's stripped bare. Everything is gone. Pictures, posters, clothes, teddies everything. My wardrobe has school uniforms and a pair of pj's in it. I just sat down in it in shock.

Later I go down for dinner, mums Eyebrows are in her hairline. I'm told I obviously cannot care for possessions and therefore I'll have to "earn" everything back.

Eventually most things were returned over the course of months though I always suspected some "junk" was thrown away. Obviously this was quite a distressing time as I was very attached to my possessions.

Funnily enough about a year later I pulled out the bag I'd taken with me and the item fell out. In my panic I can't have checked through it properly, it was stuck in a seam i think. I have never worn it since, I still own it though but can't really look at it. I also now live as a total minimalist, I own no jewellery, nic naks etc. I have absolutely no attachment to any possessions, valuing something makes me quite anxious actually - though my children have plenty of stuff!!

To my mum this is an example of her "no nonsense" parenting and how she could keep all of us in line. As I parent my own DCs and reflect on some of my childhood I'm starting to think this is not normal... what do you think?

YABU - this is a fair and standard punishment for what you did.

YANBU - this was not fair or normal. I would not do this to my DCs.

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 21/08/2022 20:16

No, it was utterly ridiculous and quite abusive. I’m an adult and sometimes I lose things - the punishment for losing a prized item is that you no longer have the prized item. And if it’s extremely valuable then the parent should have the common sense not to allow a kid to wear it out and about.

Was your mother abusive in other ways? I notice you were seized with fear even before this happened which suggests to me you were conditioned to be afraid of making mistakes for fear of these disproportionate punishments.

Pinkflipflop85 · 21/08/2022 20:18

It's nasty and abusive behaviour.

Kanaloa · 21/08/2022 20:18

But I wouldn’t tolerate it being brought up now. If she mentioned it/brought it up as an example of good parenting I’d just say ‘yes that was very upsetting, you handled it very poorly. It was frightening and really broke my trust in you as a child. But never mind, I’m just glad I know how to handle things properly with the kids so they don’t need to live like that.’

MaChienEstUnDick · 21/08/2022 20:28

Dear god that's psychopathic. I absolutely would not tolerate that being brought up as an example of good parenting, and if it's ever brought up again I would say something like 'I don't remember that the way you do. I remember it as being harsh and cruel and I don't wish to discuss it further.'

Awful behaviour, just awful.

Teadrinkingmumofone · 21/08/2022 20:33

Thats horrendous. I can't imagine how you must have felt :(

pointythings · 21/08/2022 20:37

Abusive and appalling parenting, and if she brings it up as an example of good parenting, tell her straight. You don't have to be aggressive, but firm and assertive is fine.

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 21/08/2022 20:39

I wouldn't have someone in my life who had treated me that way. Are you still afraid of her?

IsTheOffDutyDoneYet · 21/08/2022 20:40

YANBU.

That is completely over the top and out of order. I can’t even imagine thinking to do that. She knew how much it meant to you as you wore it so often, it was an accident that you lost it. Does she know that you ended up finding it? The fact she’s quite proud of what she did is just odd. The punishment didn’t fit the ‘crime’ at all.

LizzieSiddal · 21/08/2022 20:41

I feel so sorry for the little girl you were, what an awful thing for any parent to do.Flowers

How do you deal with her when she tells this awful story to illustrate what a “wonderful parent” she was?

pigsDOfly · 21/08/2022 20:42

Absolutely appalling behaviour from your mother.

It most certainly isn't an example of good parenting, it's abusive and spiteful.

You were clearly terrified of her reaction even before she knew you'd lost it. I can't imagine wanting to have my children feel like that about me. Awful.

If she ever brings it up again please don't keep quiet. Let her know that far from being good parenting, her behaviour was abusive.

winterchills · 21/08/2022 20:42

That's absolutely horrendous!! Next time she brings it up you should set her straight and how much it upset you!!

Justfiguringitout · 21/08/2022 20:43

Oh my goodness, your replies have actually brought tears to my eyes. I'll try and go through and answer some of your questions!

OP posts:
KentuckyDerbyandJoan · 21/08/2022 20:44

This was cruel and abusive. So sorry this happened to you OP.

Penguinfeather781 · 21/08/2022 20:45

The “punishment” was that you no longer had the item, she shouldn’t have needed to go beyond that. I’d regard what she did as emotional abuse.

Sunnyqueen · 21/08/2022 20:45

I would go as far as to say that is some sort of psychological abuse to be honest.

Justfiguringitout · 21/08/2022 20:45

Kanaloa · 21/08/2022 20:16

No, it was utterly ridiculous and quite abusive. I’m an adult and sometimes I lose things - the punishment for losing a prized item is that you no longer have the prized item. And if it’s extremely valuable then the parent should have the common sense not to allow a kid to wear it out and about.

Was your mother abusive in other ways? I notice you were seized with fear even before this happened which suggests to me you were conditioned to be afraid of making mistakes for fear of these disproportionate punishments.

So it's one of the first "events" I can clearly remember but yes, I'd picked up on this fact that I was absolutely terrified of her finding out. So obviously things had happened before then.

It was always the case of having to walk on eggshells as a teenager (and quite frankly now as an adult!) And I imagine must have been the same when I was younger.

OP posts:
CheesyColeslaw · 21/08/2022 20:47

Not normal. The consequence of losing something is that you no longer have it. She should have comforted you and asked you where you last had it etc to check it was really lost.

justforthisnow · 21/08/2022 20:47

Completely and utterly abusive.
If you still have the item I would present it to her, and go very low contact. Especially as she is still raising to this day.

Auntpodder · 21/08/2022 20:47

That's a truly awful, abusive thing for your mother to have done. You mentioned that your parents had given it to you - what was your father's role in this?

dementedpixie · 21/08/2022 20:48

Who are in the 4% who think this was ok??

It's a horrible thing to do to a child

whiteroseredrose · 21/08/2022 20:48

What a horrible woman. No, that never was good parenting.

Fairislefandango · 21/08/2022 20:49

What an awful, cruel thing to donto a child. Ir to anyone, actually! She sounds like a nasty, vindictive woman.

Justfiguringitout · 21/08/2022 20:50

@IsTheOffDutyDoneYet yes she did know I found it, I remember running to her to show her I'd found it. I cant remember 100% but I think I just got a scoff and rolled eyes. If anything was said I don't remember it.

I do remember being so afraid to lose it again though that I put it in a jewellery box and it hasn't left it to this day (over 20 years later!!)

OP posts:
SalmonEile · 21/08/2022 20:51

My blood went cold reading that.
your mother is awful.
im so sorry.

littlepeas · 21/08/2022 20:54

Really horrible. Not normal at all.

My mum is not without her faults but when I lost something of hers I had borrowed she hugged me and said that these things happen (I was distraught - burst into tears telling her - similar in age to you).

Swipe left for the next trending thread