[quote XDownwiththissortofthingX]@Packingsoapandwater
I concur to an extent. I spent a lot of time researching early mental health care provision, so sanitoriums, asylums, workhouses, and yes, the tales of the crimes of the inmates and patients are both hair-raising, and just as violent and sickening as anything we read about today. It's nothing new.
Where I disagree is with the entire notion of 'evil'. It's a concept entirely invented by mankind and doesn't exist as any sort of entity that can influence the actions of human beings. In every instance of a horrific crime, there's a sociological, environmental, or pathological factor involved, even in those carried out by the well-to-do middle and upper classes with seemingly nothing to want for.
I particularly dislike threads like these which invariably bring out the rants about 'evil', because all it does is provide a handy cop-out, and it is just a cop-out, that helps us deflect from our failings as a society, and enables us to avoid asking difficult questions. Also, normal, healthy people do not go around killing small children, so it also acts as a panacea for the 'hanging is too good' types.
Unfortunately any attempt to point out that an 18 year old mother who kills her child by neglect perhaps has pretty significant underlying reasons for her lack of responsibility, gets shouted down as 'excusing' or 'exhonorating'. Evidently some people don't understand the basic difference between an 'excuse' and an 'explanation'. Thankfully the law doesn't pander to reactionary vindictiveness, because the only way we are ever going to progress to a point whereby these things no longer happen is by accepting that they happen because we fail, not because of 'evil' or any other nebulous concept.[/quote]
This. What's the point in asking how and why when the answers get shouted down and it's all "evil, I don't care"?
What's the point in demanding change when the whys and hows are ignored and we can all pat ourselves on the back that we'd never do it and it's just "evil".
There are plenty of things that can be done at an individual level, there are even more at a systemic/population level. But that costs money, time , it takes effort and continued interest , it takes commitment,understanding, an overhaul of mentalities and how society views it's weak and vulnerable. It's hard work.
So instead we cry evil and wish it dead .