Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Overbearing mother in law

81 replies

Jay16ea · 20/06/2021 02:20

I am a first time mum who’s due soon. My MIL came to visit today and told my husband she will take the baby for a few days to stay with her when it’s born (without either of us there with the baby). Bare in mind I was sat right next to her but she didn’t even look at me or acknowledge me when she said that like I don’t have a say. My response was very polite but i said ‘No, you cannot take a newborn baby’ she then looked at me in surprise as if she wasn’t expecting me to respond. She then changed her response to ‘You both bring the baby and stay at mine for a week’. Of course my partners response was no and I also said no we will have health visitors, appointments etc.

I told my husband how I felt about the whole conversation and he just said she’s joking and of course we won’t let her take the baby like that. Of course my problem isn’t the fact that she’ll be able to take my newborn but it’s more about how she thinks she can ask her son and not me (the mother of the child). Once I explained how I felt he apologised on her behalf. But I know she will always behave like this and cause stress for me.

A few months ago she said something very similar to my husband over the phone. Something in the lines of keeping the baby over at hers during the weekend. At the time his response was yes you can just to make her happy because she was upset about something. During another phone conversation she referred to my baby as ‘her baby’ which I found quite strange. My SIL also mentioned to me that ‘mum is very excited about the baby, she might steal him’. I just find it very strange for MIL to behave like this.

I feel like this is just the beginning and there will be a lot of boundary issues in future. I understand this is her first grandchild and they have every right to be a part of my babies life. But I do feel there has to be boundaries which will be very hard to set with her as she can become a very difficult person. My husband and her often get into arguments due to her overbearing personality.

OP posts:
IrishCharm · 20/06/2021 02:23

Forewarned is forearmed - keep to your boundaries and before baby comes along insists your husband backs you up - which it sounds like he will (fingers crossed) x
Good luck with her and the rest of your pregnancy xx

FetchezLaVache · 20/06/2021 02:26

Your DH needs to stop telling her what she wants to hear to appease her. I can imagine it's very stressful to have anyone announce that they're going to take your newborn away from you, for whatever reason and for however long, and he must make it clear to her that not only is it not happening, but any more of that sort of talk and she won't be meeting her DGC for a looooong time.

Blondebakingmumma · 20/06/2021 02:28

Firm boundaries from the start! I imagine your MIL will try to cross those boundaries too, so be prepared.
Remind your partner that you don’t parent by committee if she tries to have a say on how your child is raised. Don’t let her have your child overnight until YOU feel comfortable with it.
Good luck!!

Aquamarine1029 · 20/06/2021 02:37

Rock solid boundaries from the start and don't ever allow her to take your baby anywhere alone. Not for a very long time, anyway.

If she doesn't stop all this nonsense, I wouldn't be seeing her or speaking to her at all if I were you.

sprinkleyumnut · 20/06/2021 02:53

This is extremely creepy. I wouldn't leave baby with her unsupervised even for a moment.

QueenBee52 · 20/06/2021 03:05

@sprinkleyumnut

This is extremely creepy. I wouldn't leave baby with her unsupervised even for a moment.

it sure does...

is she stable ?

Classicbrunette · 20/06/2021 03:09

Don’t let her have your baby without you there. Is your mum around ? Because you may need the extra help as it’s an exhausting time. I’m sure MIL means well and she’s overexcited about the new baby. But keep her at arms length. Good luck.

ohthestruggles · 20/06/2021 03:19

She sounds like hard work. Be strong and set boundaries now, it will likely get worse when you have a newborn and your mood will be all over the place so likely to be a lot more upset by her behaviour. I didn't really have a problem with MIL before but now we have a baby she's just a lot more irritating and I find her saying 'my baby' or referring to things as 'ours' fucking annoying.

Also be prepared for 'can I have a shot now?' 🥲🥲

1forAll74 · 20/06/2021 03:21

You should try and speak to her very much face to face, and tell her that it will not happen. that she cannot have your baby whenever she feels like it. It's shocking that she thinks likes this. If you have the support of your Husband, that is much better. Don't let her try and control you in anything, even though she might be a person who gets huffy about things. Just do your own things, and ignore any interference.

Jay16ea · 20/06/2021 03:24

@Classicbrunette I’m planning on having my mum around for a few days for postpartum support etc. I know this will get my MIL more jealous as she’s that type. But honestly I do not trust her at all and can only be around her for a few hours max. @QueenBee52 I don’t think so haha she’s always been like this (complains a lot) which is why my DH and her don’t get along often but I feel like he is making more of an effort with her recently due to baby coming soon which I wish he didn’t.

OP posts:
Jay16ea · 20/06/2021 03:30

@FetchezLaVache

Your DH needs to stop telling her what she wants to hear to appease her. I can imagine it's very stressful to have anyone announce that they're going to take your newborn away from you, for whatever reason and for however long, and he must make it clear to her that not only is it not happening, but any more of that sort of talk and she won't be meeting her DGC for a looooong time.
Yes, I deffo need to have a proper discussion with DH re this. I think that’s what upsets me to even think she can ask to take the baby for a few days like who does that?! 😩Especially as she’s also a mother and should know what it’s like to be a new mum. She has zero considerations or sympathy for me.
OP posts:
Jay16ea · 20/06/2021 03:37

@IrishCharm definitely warned 😅 and thank you ☺️ I’m just worried to even think about her behaviour once baby arrives. She’s also suggested to staying over 😣 oh, hell nooo!!

OP posts:
Classicbrunette · 20/06/2021 03:46

I’d get your mum involved as much as possible and push MIL out. Is your mum or MIL retired ? How far away is she compared to mil ?

BonnieDundee · 20/06/2021 03:52

Get your DH to lay down the law. Speaking from experience, get DH to tell her that YOU will decide when she has.baby.and there.is to.be no . pressure. If pressure.is.put on you, distance yourself massively. My first mat leave was ruined by.this.sort.of thing

georgarina · 20/06/2021 04:31

honestly I do not trust her at all

Why is this OP? Do you feel there would be issues with her having/looking after the baby (beyond the annoyingness)?

Of course it's up to you who sees your baby and when. Amazed she wants full care of a newborn tbh!

Justilou1 · 20/06/2021 04:40

He needs to be told that being a “Yes Man”
in an attempt to stop her crocodile tears is going to create a rod for his own back. It will divide you as a couple before this baby’s first birthday. This is one of those situations where he needs to accept that if he doesn’t stand firmly with you, then he is against you. (Also, Mummy’s Boys are just not sexy!)

bloodyhell19 · 20/06/2021 05:33

Does your MIL have keys to your home? Change the locks. I'm also v close to delivering and I could not think of anything worse so just remember, your body, your baby, your rules. DH can appease his mother another time. I would be very surprised if your MIL crosses your DM to get to the baby, but at least she will be another barrier of defence if she tries it. Just because you had a baby doesn't mean it's open season on your home either! You don't have to see anyone or do anything. You don't get those first few days back so be selfish.

custardbear · 20/06/2021 05:34

Boundaries all the way!
Thank you but we'll let you know if we need babysitting from you.... never!

Sorry, babies need their mum for bf in the night

Good luck. Firm boundaries abd train your DH to grow a pair and support you

Lavinia321 · 20/06/2021 06:09

My MIL did this with DC1 - we were really struggling so went to stay with my mum. She ‘told’ us that we needed to send dc1 to stay with her for a week (without me} and she would look after him. He was breastfed so she also thought I should quit breastfeeding so she could have him on her own.

Basically these people aren’t actually wanting to help. If you asked her to unpack the dishwasher and fold some laundry she wouldn’t be interested at all. For my MIL it was that she wanted to ‘play mum’ but hid it behind offers of help so it would seem unreasonable to decline them. The need to play mum is why they want sole charge of the baby.

You just need to be really assertive from the start. Laugh off any stupid suggestions and just say ‘9; course not’ and if she asks why just be honest. ‘I don’t want to send baby to stay with you’. It’s impossible for her to try and dispute that and it makes clear form the outset that what you want is what happens - you’re in charge.

ShowGirlCoaching · 20/06/2021 06:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Soubriquet · 20/06/2021 06:36

Are you planning on breastfeeding?

If you aren’t, it might be an idea to give it a go because then your dh has to say no because baby needs you for food.

He does really need to grow a backbone and say no anyway but this could be a way for him to start

Mummyoflittledragon · 20/06/2021 06:44

In situations, where in laws and parents are controlling, I always wonder how their in laws and parents were when their children were young / babies.

Of course YANBU. I don’t think the solution suggested upthread to crowd your mil by getting your mum heavily involved is the correct one. This, you could also live to regret.

As stated, you are in charge. This is your time in the sun. Your dh needs to get on board and create boundaries.

Weenurse · 20/06/2021 06:49

This is difficult.
Especially if MIL is jealous type.
When our DC were little, parents and PiL lived 9 hours away.
I would fly on my own to visit with 2 DC under 2 years.
PIL were upset that they did not see DC as much as my family.
My DM had cot, change table, pram, car seats etc.
PIL had nothing. It made sense to stay where the required equipment was.
They did not see this.
Set boundaries now.
Deal with expectations “that won’t be happening “.
As suggested, breast feed, easiest excuse not to leave baby.
Good luck

ittakes2 · 20/06/2021 07:06

As everyone said - set your boundaries but most importantly get your husband to agree boundaries and WRITE THEM DOWN TOGETHER. And I really mean that - set aside a time where you are at a table and both engaged in the conversation so there is no confusion after the birth as he will be under pressure. You won't have a m'n'law issue unless you end up with a husband issue ie he bends to her wishes.

Waspsarearseholes · 20/06/2021 07:20

Oh my goodness, she sounds utterly unbearable. I'd not be able to ignore shit like that. I'd have to repeat her nonsense back to her. So if she said she is taking the baby for the first week I'd say, you want to take a baby away from its mother? Why do you think the baby will need you instead of it's mother? Drive it home that she is not the baby's mother, you are.

Swipe left for the next trending thread