Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sil is kicking off because I haven’t taken her child shopping

105 replies

Amberleaf12 · 20/03/2021 13:40

During Xmas I discussed with Sil what to buy her child for Xmas . I told her I didn’t want to buy her just anything because as she’s growing (9YO) she has a certain style and interests which I’m not familiar with.

Sil immediately said, please don’t buy her anything but take her shopping for something she wants.

Today SIL sent a message telling her brother (DH) how do you think my child feels ? Your wife has gone back on her promise.

There is a long history with SIL. Her self worth is based upon whether people around her give into her demands and do as they’re told and if your opinion differs then a war of words begins.

Your love for her is measured by whether you’re able to visit her often, but her gifts to make her feel loved and take her out to dinner. If you don’t do those things then she will pull you upon how much you don’t care about her.

I’ve always stood my ground but respectfully. I just won’t give in. I’ve never given in into anyone if their attitude is used as control and power over your life.

The simple answer to my SILs dilemma is, the shops aren’t over due to the global pandemic. Nothing more to it really.

I would buy said child something online but the original conversation was around taking the child out shopping. I’m happy to buy child something online now but then I could have just done that at Christmas. The reason I didn’t is because the child has her own style. Something I understand because I’m the same!!!! It’s so much easier to take her out and let her choose!

I explained this to DH and he agreed wholeheartedly without question. Whilst I’m not close to the child I do really enjoy her company. She’s wacky and cool and makes me laugh and DH can see this. She’s only kept at arms length because it’s not possible to have a relationship with her without SIL making demands and throwing tantrums.

I mentioned to DH it seems that our love for her daughter is now starting to be measured just like our love for her is being measured by what we do for her.

DH responded simply by saying it will happen soon but he didn’t say anything about it being because shops aren’t open which is slightly annoying but I can forgive him for failing to mention that. He tries to remain neutral as much as possible as I do.
Also if we explained the reason he said no doubt she’s so emotionally unstable right now she’ll find another reason to be angry and it’ll just spiral out and become a slanging match.

It’s been almost a year now where we’ve learnt to listen and not put her right factually because it ends up with dragging the past up about how she feels about how we treated her . And by that I mean not giving into her demands.

I feel a bit frustrated. I know not to say anything. The less we say the less longer her anger will last. The more we say the longer her anger will last.

The last time I saw the child we were laughing and joking and being dorky. It’s just so fun.

I really despise the fact that SIL holds onto every little thing we do or don’t do.

It’s upset me a little and I’ve had a cry. But I’m okay now. I just feel anxious again.

OP posts:
ILoveSlipperss · 20/03/2021 14:08

@Babyboomtastic

Then her age, why didn't you give the child a choice to choose something or wait until the shops open again.

You sound a bit hard work tbh.

I’m absolutely baffled at how you think the OP sounds like hard work?
dontdisturbmenow · 20/03/2021 14:09

I agree that at 9 years old, 3 months to wait for something they are excited about is a long time. It made sense knowing it wouldn't be fair many months to suggest either to wait until the shops she likes open or offer a voucher for her to order something online.

Saying nothing about it at all after a promise was made is not very nice.

HermioneMakepeace · 20/03/2021 14:12

Send her a card with money in.

DeepfriedPizza · 20/03/2021 14:14

I promised DD a shopping trip to spend her Christmas money. She understands shoos have been shut and we still talk about it but she understands it will happen, just not yet. She’s 10. I like the idea one pp had about sending a card to say how you’re looking forward to the shopping trip.

Mayvis · 20/03/2021 14:14

I disagree with those saying 3 months is too long to wait for a 9yr old. Children that age know the shops are shut, all it needs is a sensible adult to remind them that they’ll take them shopping once things are open again.

My children haven’t received some Xmas presents still and know they’ll get them when we are finally allowed to meet our family. No big drama needed.

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 20/03/2021 14:16

I tried to make it as anonymous as possible re gender

Why? Confused

WonkyCactus · 20/03/2021 14:17

She's 9, even if she does have her "own style" Confused I'm sure she'd have been happy with a gift you could have got online and sent her at any point between Christmas and now. So YABU to let this drag out.

NoSquirrels · 20/03/2021 14:17

Yeah, but have a 9 just turned 10 year old. They’re well aware the shops are shut! If my DC couldn’t wait for their promised gift I’d be having words with them. Delayed gratification is actually a useful skill in life. Kids have been learning a lot about it this year. DN is not a toddler, it’s fine.

1FootInTheRave · 20/03/2021 14:18

Cut the stupid bitch off and send the kid a voucher.

NoSquirrels · 20/03/2021 14:18

Yeah, but have a 9 just turned 10 year old. = I have a ...

At that age it’s not a massive big deal - or shouldn’t be. It’s not like it’s her parents that forgot Christmas, after all.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 20/03/2021 14:23

I really like the idea of sending your niece a card that says "can't wait to take you shopping when the shops are open properly again - where would you like to go?"

Your SIL sounds like a real PITA. And lacking in any form of sense, assuming you're in the UK and have all been in the same lockdown scenario!

Alreadyinmypyjamas · 20/03/2021 14:31

Her mum sounds like a bully.

NormanStangerson · 20/03/2021 14:31

Some people seem to have missed the bit where OP said the vile SIL binned presents sent by them before because she was in a pissy mood with them. It sounds like she’s in another one of those now so anything sent will likely be binned, disappointing the child and wasting OP’s money. The SIL doesn’t seem to be motivated by her own kid’s well-being. Confused

Anyway, I’d send my bordering-on-the-abusive text but probably the sweet card directly to the child is a nice idea.

Otherwise, don’t engage. I doubt the nine year old is gazing out of a rain-lashed window wondering when the day will finally come that she can go shopping with her aunt and uncle.

legosnowqueen · 20/03/2021 14:34

Definitely wouldn't get a voucher - sadly not all businesses will reopen. I'm sure your DN will enjoy the shopping trip when it's possible OP, your SIL sounds hard work!

BigFatLiar · 20/03/2021 14:35

Send a card telling your niece you're looking forward to the shopping trip. It's probably not just a present but having a day with her aunty, shops, burger/pizza, cake. Trip to the cinema maybe. Just make sure SiL doesn't tag along (get DH to suggest something else to get her out the way).

Howshouldibehave · 20/03/2021 14:38

I’d just send your DN cash next time-sounds like it will be easier to let her choose something she likes herself.

Cassilis · 20/03/2021 14:38

Could you just send a cheque covering Xmas (£20) and Birthday (£20)?

At least if SIL bins it you won’t lose out?

WaxOnFeckOff · 20/03/2021 14:39

@RedMarauder

In future get your husband, whose blood relation it is, to buy the girl a voucher or money for Christmas and birthdays at the time.
For real?

The Op is allowed to feel an attachment to a child that isn't a blood relative and buy gifts!

I have 12 great nieces and nephews. The two I am closest to are no blood relation - one on DHs side and the other the child of my brother's step daughter.

I didn't realise that I shouldn't buy them gifts given that they aresn't blood relations. Looks like I can cut those two and my nephew's step son of the list next year.

Nancydrawn · 20/03/2021 14:41

I agree your SIL sounds awful.

That said, 3 months is a long time when you're 9. I'd probably have sent her a card with some cash in it with a note that said how much you were looking forward to going to the shops with her to spend it on what she liked. Kids like tangible things rather than promises.

Nith · 20/03/2021 14:41

@Babyboomtastic

Then her age, why didn't you give the child a choice to choose something or wait until the shops open again.

You sound a bit hard work tbh.

How on earth do you make out that sticking to her agreement makes OP "hard work", @Babyboomtastic? These simplistic MNisms applied without any thought are seriously irritating.
Nith · 20/03/2021 14:41

@Babyboomtastic

Then her age, why didn't you give the child a choice to choose something or wait until the shops open again.

You sound a bit hard work tbh.

How on earth do you make out that sticking to her agreement makes OP "hard work", @Babyboomtastic? These simplistic MNisms applied without any thought are seriously irritating.
cherrytreesa · 20/03/2021 14:45

Then her age, why didn't you give the child a choice to choose something or wait until the shops open again

You sound a bit hard work tbh

Grin That's just hilarious. How on earth did you come to this conclusion. Talk me through it...

1forAll74 · 20/03/2021 14:46

What an absolute drama queen your SIL is, and an awful person, for binning some gifts. Her mindset and odd temperament must be very hard to fathom, and hard to deal with.

Can you not ask your niece,,in private, what she would like as a gift, then order her something on line.

Skiptheheartsandflowers · 20/03/2021 14:50

Tell SIL and your husband that you're passing gift buying duties to him as it looks like he'll make a better job of it.

Looneytune253 · 20/03/2021 15:00

I reckon SIL saw an opportunity for a child free day and is now having a tantrum cos you haven't done it yet. Whatever you do, when you do it, make sure it's shops and home in half an hour. I'm only joking cos u prob want to spend time with your niece but it might be fun to wind SIL up a bit and mention you'll be back in an hour or something lol

Swipe left for the next trending thread