Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents who have home schooled throughout all this have had it much easier

111 replies

LifeIsaShitShow · 05/03/2021 10:41

Compared to parents of children who have special needs and do this day in day out not just in a pandemic. Now this is just my opinion but before I’m flamed just wait as it comes from me, a parent who has a child with Sen who has been completely failed by the education system/ school/ the local authority, a parent who has had their dc in and out of school for the last six years, on reduced timetables, excluded, sent to schools miles away out of borough with no support what so ever.

My ds is 11 next month and he is currently at a specialist school. By the age of 9 he had been to 3 schools, not including nursery where he was, at age 3, only allowed to attend for 1 hour a a day, and was also “asked” to leave wrap around club which meant I had to leave work as I had no childcare for him which was essential for me to do my job. He was excluded (by the back door eg managed moved forced on us) from his first school age 5 after spending most of reception on a reduced timetable and being sent home every couple of weeks. No school in borough could/would take him due to his complex needs/spaces available in school, so he ended up at a school in the next borough meaning I had to drive approximately 150 miles a week to get him there. I was that drained mentally that I didn’t even think to ask the local authority about parental mileage, which I later found out I was entitled to (and owed thousands by the time my ds left this school) and they didn’t tell me of course so I cracked on taking him to school.

After the first 9-10 months things started to go downhill and my ds was put on a reduced timetable again and I was expected do work with him at home in the afternoons which I did for about a year. This was horrendous as he would have huge meltdowns over doing it but his teacher would phone me if he didn’t do it and make a big deal about it.

The LA had meetings behind my back with the school and one day I went in and was told my son couldn’t go back after half term and they had found a specialist school for him. This school was completely unsuitable, they wanted him to go to a school for kids who (solely) had behaviour problems. My son is autistic and needed a small specialist setting with children similar to him and staff who were trained in supporting dc with autism. I refused to send him and ended up home schooling him for six months and had to go to a tribunal appeal, spend money I didn’t have, pay for independent reports which I had to use my credit card for and I’m now in debt. Whilst at the same time trying to provide my ds with some form of education. I was mentally physically and emotionally drained but eventually I got my ds into the school we so desperately wanted. He only started a year ago is now year six and I am faced with the sobering fact that my ds has more or less missed out on his entire primary education. It’s time we will never get back and despite the fact that he is very able in some ways, I very much doubt he will ever meet his potential due to all that he has been through.

Whilst I don’t doubt that home schooling has been hard for some parents, and I do get it,
I also find it hard to feel that much empathy for some people in particular who have the time, energy, money, resources to put into home schooling their kids yet do nothing
but moan. They really have no clue what it’s like to do this all the time and with a child who has Sen. Whilst I wouldn’t change my ds as he’s amazing, I can only
Imagine what it would be like to be able home school a neuro typical child who doesn’t face the challenges my ds does. Compared to what I deal with on a filet basis I honestly think it would be a walk in the park. So maybe on reflection people who are in the fortunate position to be able to spend extra time with their kids who are more able and who’s kids are happy to spend more time with them, maybe just see how lucky you are

OP posts:
maddening · 07/03/2021 12:17

It's not a race to the bottom. And why is this comparison of misery required, can't we all agree that for most it has been shitter than normal, and whilst the level of shit varies there is no need for derision.

I work full time, have done from home throughout and home schooled, it is harder than someone who has not had to work or is a sahm for example, but ds is 10 and generally well behaved, so it has been most likely easier than a whole lot of people's experience, but then so what? What do you want? I am not apologising, I have not caused anyone's hardship, I can't help you. I can empathise with you, it must be really shit, but if you want empathy then why effectively criticise /attack others, it is a crazy way to approachthe argument.

There are a ton of people who would kill to be in your position even, but attacking you for your perceived easier life would not garner support and empathy.

In general though op, I don't think that anyone would not support calls to support you and your dc better. Wishing you well x

Skysblue · 07/03/2021 12:28

Everyone has problems. Some people have bigger problems, some people have smaller problems.

Everyone likes to moan to their friends about their problems. It’s a form of stress relief. It helps bond friendships by saying ‘I care and I understand’.

Telling people they shouldn’t moan about their problems, because they aren’t as big as your problems, just doesn’t work. It’s like telling everyone in Europe they should never moan because they don’t know how lucky they are not to have been born in North Korea. It’s saying “You have to listen to my problems, but I don’t have to listen to yours because yours are not as important as mine.” I have a sahm friend who has a cleaner 3 x a week and also a nanny and I admit I find it a little hard to listen when she moans about them but I still listen and make supportive noises because I am her friend...

BurgundyBells · 07/03/2021 12:31

And you, op, have it much easier than parents who have SEN children and also live in a war-ravaged Country.

So suck it up, crack on and stop moaning. Plenty are worse off than you.

OhCaptain · 07/03/2021 13:08

@LizzieAnt I have ‘listened’.

There was absolutely no need to have a go at parents who are struggling. No need at all.

You can look for empathy without getting digs in at everyone else.

LizzieAnt · 07/03/2021 14:26

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SuperSange · 07/03/2021 14:38

So you're slagging everyone off who's been homeschooling because you have it hardest, but you then say it's not a competition? ODFOD.

OhCaptain · 07/03/2021 15:12

@LizzieAnt did you actually read the OP?

Ylvamoon · 07/03/2021 15:20

It's not a competition

LizzieAnt · 07/03/2021 15:20

@OhCaptain Yes, of course.

Sirzy · 07/03/2021 15:43

I have a lot of sympathy for the position the OP is in.

I don’t have any sympathy for her turning that around as a chance to slag others off for also struggling with what they have been given.

As I have said previously in this thread in the past I have had people who are on the surface in a much better position than me upset because of what they are going through. It would be insensitive of me to say “but I have things much worse” when at that point it is the other person who just wants someone to listen to them.

LizzieAnt · 07/03/2021 16:14

@OhCaptain
The OP's opening point was:
Parents who have home schooled throughout all this have had it much easier compared to parents of children who have special needs and do this day in day out not just in a pandemic.

I have personally homeschooled one child with SEN and MH issues for the last four years (as the local schools were unequipped to provide him with an education and the authorities don't much care ). I imagine I will have to continue this for the next 6 years. I have home schooled his siblings for parts of the last year. They return to school on Monday. Which do you think sounds easier? (And if you say that you couldn't possibly tell then you're being disingenuous Smile)

I absolutely know all families are different, but I can't see what's so outrageous about the OP's opening statement. She goes on to describe years of struggles and hardship for her son. He has missed out on his entire primary education more or less. It's an appalling picture she paints, if you pause to notice. Society still manages to fail people with SEN and SN fairly spectacularly.

Did she fail to show empathy for the hardships others can face? Yes, maybe she did. She's certainly not alone there as I think this thread has proved. And maybe she's weary of it. I know I am.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread