Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To NOT host Christmas?

123 replies

SunshineAngel · 03/01/2020 11:58

In a bit of an odd situation.

I'm living with my partner, and our parents live in the same town. So, for the past few Christmases, we've gone to lunch at our respective families' houses, then I've joined him for the evening, and we've gone out for a meal with my family on Boxing Day. It works for us both, and is quite an easy solution.

His family have three siblings (including him) and the parents. His parents always used to do Christmas dinner, but now his brother and sister take it in turns as it's too much for his parents.

For a while now, there have been a lot of comments about how we don't host Christmas and "take our turn".

The thing is, their houses are a lot bigger than ours, with entertaining space. Our house is small, with just a kitchen and living room downstairs, and the only space we have to sit at a table is a 2 person breakfast bar jutting out from the work surface.

Christmas dinner for his family alone would involve cooking for and seating 11 people - plus obviously if we were hosting I would have think about inviting my family as well, which is another 5.

There is NOWHERE for that number of people to sit, and not enough space for us to serve up Christmas dinners for that number of people.

They then suggested that perhaps we could invite everyone for the buffet on Boxing Day that his parents usually do - but this includes MORE people, as uncles and aunties come, too! Think 20+ people.

There is no way that we could have that many people in this house at the same time. We have 2 seats in the kitchen, nowhere to put buffet food, and 4 seats in the living room. Even spare chairs would just get in the way of people walking round because of the layout. His siblings' kids both have learning disabilities, one of them gets seriously stressed in crowds, so this would be a nightmare for him anyway and would probably cause a meltdown - no kid should be put through that at Christmas, right?

We have said that we will happily pay for Christmas dinner (or a meal in the days following) for people at our local pub, which does nice dinners. It would cost £50pp so a huge amount of money for us, but at the same time it feels like the only way we can "take our turn" and give everyone else a break.

His siblings have said no to this, because both of their children struggle to behave in public due to learning disabilities. Fair enough.

But his parents are now saying that my partner won't be welcome to Christmas lunch again until he's taken his turn.

It all just seems a bit sad. He has offered to contribute money for Christmas dinner, he always gets turned down. Asks if he should bring anything, they say no (but he always takes plenty of drink).

I don't know what to do! How are we supposed to host Christmas in a house the size of a shoebox?

OP posts:
SoupDragon · 03/01/2020 15:01

Yes, because nothing says "partner" like telling them it's not your problem. 🙄

AryaStarkWolf · 03/01/2020 15:03

Yes, because nothing says "partner" like telling them it's not your problem

Normally you would have a point but in this instance for one, they never eat Christmas Dinner together so hosting his family shouldn't be her concern and secondly even if she did agree to do it he DH is using the I can't cook get out clause so she would end up doing it all, that doesn't sound exactly partner like either

SoupDragon · 03/01/2020 15:07

they never eat Christmas Dinner together

The op goes round there for the evening. Does hosting only mean Christmas dinner?

MrsGolightyly · 03/01/2020 15:09

Just do what suits you.

safariboot · 03/01/2020 15:10

OP, it's not your problem to solve. Your DP should be thinking of how he can host

This. It's an issue between your DH and his parents. OP, it's not your problem.

If your DH wants to do all the work himself to host at home he's welcome to.

Drum2018 · 03/01/2020 15:10

Because some families actually enjoy spending time together at least once a year. Bit sad when you only see all your kids together when there's a funeral.

Sad for you if a funeral is the only other occasion you can think of for a family get together Hmm

AryaStarkWolf · 03/01/2020 15:11

The op goes round there for the evening. Does hosting only mean Christmas dinner?

I would have taken it to mean that yes, unless you think his family would take coming round to theirs on Christmas evening for drinks as them taking their turn in hosting Christmas I suspect you agree with me as well

safariboot · 03/01/2020 15:12

And if he's a bad cook, he's got a year to practice getting better at it. Christmas dinner isn't hard. Plan all the timings in advance, get good ingredients, steam the veg (never boil!) and job done.

Instagrump · 03/01/2020 15:12

Oh I would have so much petty fun with this. I'd totally do it but let everyone try and squish up into the tiny house, eating Christmas dinner on their laps and on the floor. Well, I might borrow some patio chairs if I was feeling generous. Or I'd borrow/hire a table big enough for everyone but obviously as you don't have a dining room, it would need squashed in leaving no room to get around or they could use the settee instead of chairs. As they are well aware that your house isn't big enough they are being completely ridiculous and I would be as ridiculous back. Hey, it's THEM insisting. They know you've no room.

SoupDragon · 03/01/2020 15:18

unless you think his family would take coming round to theirs on Christmas evening for drinks as them taking their turn in hosting Christmas I suspect you agree with me as well

Confused

She goes round to the hosting family's house to join her DP. How is that not being "hosted" by them??

I don't agree with you at all, no.

SoupDragon · 03/01/2020 15:18

Ie the "hosting" is for the whole Christmas Day, not just dinner.

xSummer · 03/01/2020 15:19

Please tell me that you have a sizeable back garden?

If they are absolutely adamant that you must host at your place, which clearly is not big enough, and you still want to try and make it work, some how "miraculously" get a gazebo (a large one of course) and either do a buffet or dinner, which ever suits you, and see if they bother ever complaining again!! Grin Grin

Seriously, YANBU here, they are and I find it strange how they host for him but not for you.

But if it really comes done to it, like somebody else has said, tell everybody to bring their own fold-up chair, or go one more and tell them to bring a comfortable cushion for their arse, when they are finding themselves sat in the floor, because there is no room.

How Rude!!!

Sorry, I haven't really offered much help. But I think you are better off, just let them cancel future invites for Christmas dinner, how childish of them.

SoupDragon · 03/01/2020 15:21

Anyway' it's ridiculous. Their house isn't big enough and that is the end of it.

One of my siblings doesn't have a house big enough to host Christmas in - we all went to my parents who did have a house big enough and all chipped in. As they got older it fell to us to do the cooking,

AryaStarkWolf · 03/01/2020 15:23

Ie the "hosting" is for the whole Christmas Day, not just dinner.

Exactly which she never does ie. go for the whole day, I mean that's literally my point, there is no work (or minimal work) in pouring someone a drink, all the work of hosting is in preparing, serving and cleaning up after Christmas Dinner......you are surely aware of that? I mean if you called round to your friends house for a drink one evening, would you feel like you then owed her a cooked meal because she made a meal for her family earlier the same day?

minipie · 03/01/2020 15:32

It does sound to me like your DP is being called out for being lazy.

He has elderly parents who hosted for years, his siblings have disabled children so their lives are not exactly straightforward and yet they have also hosted several times.

He has a house, no DC (I think?) and yet he won’t host. I’m betting he doesn’t help much at the others’ houses either since he “can’t” (ie won’t) cook.

I think the best solution is that he “hosts” at one of the others’ houses. Food can be bought ready made or prepped at your house. But as others have said, it’s his job to solve this.

Confrontayshunme · 03/01/2020 15:37

I host at my DH's parents house, eith their blessing. I do all of the cooking, meal prep, shopping and planning, and we have offered to pay for their cleaner and make beds and things but they have refused.

Or maybe you could rent a giant AirBnB local to you for everyone to stay in and enjoy cooking and hosting in a bigger place, but maybe have a cheaper meal and drinks? If you can afford 50pp on a pub, you should easily be able to afford a local airbnb for a night! Spend £300 on a five bedroom house with a huge kitchen and enjoy not having to clean up after!

Love51 · 03/01/2020 15:55

OP have they ever been to your house?

My brother has never 'hosted' Xmas dinner because he has never lived somewhere suitable since we've both moved out, prior to that Xmas was still at parents home because I was a child living there. When DH and I had a small home, we catered for him and my parents. Now he has a huge family (with multiple and profound needs)and small house, he can't extend an invitation to the rest of us. I don't need to see his house to understand his situation, but, he has on various occasions cooked Xmas dinner at my parents, shared the catering with my mum, been a guest at mine, and worked on Xmas day. He and his wife make a point of being great guests, they'll bring a course, plenty of drinks or whatever. I can't imagine either myself or my parents saying he isn't welcome because he isn't in a situation to reciprocate. I suspect there's a backstory that the op may not even know about, either about her partner or his family.

Besidesthepoint · 03/01/2020 16:06

Or you could passively aggreively host and do the buffet with too many people and not enough chairs. Let them be uncomfortable, that way they learn why you hosting is a bad idea.

justdeckingthehalls1 · 03/01/2020 16:06

If it were me I'd be so tempted to do it. OP, you go to your parents for lunch as usual so you don't have to worry about fitting your family in too.

Then let DH do the hosting. If he can't cook then they'll either get a rubbish dinner or sandwiches. Which they can eat on a rota basis, 2 at a time at your breakfast bar. You can then join them at your house in the evening, but I strongly suspect that after a day of sitting in the floor tripping over each other, they'll have all left by then.

Either that or just do the Boxing Day thing at the village hall as your "turn".

FruitcakeOfHate · 03/01/2020 17:54

Still wondering what his suggestion is now they turned down the restaurant. Let me guess . . . .

catsmother · 03/01/2020 19:27

"Of course we'll take our turn hosting the Christmas get together next year but as you know it'll be physically impossible to fit everyone in here so you're all welcome to join us in the local park for a festive picnic instead. Do remember to bring umbrellas though and put plenty of layers on ...."

LovePoppy · 03/01/2020 20:03

I’d let your partner do it

You can fuck off to your parents place

katy1213 · 03/01/2020 20:11

It is January 3 ... embrace it! There is no need to fret about Christmas for at least 11 months.
There is also need for you to become embroiled in your partner's dysfunctional family. Invite him to join your family's Christmas and let his side do what the fuck they want.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread