Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To just now be done with MIL

106 replies

PinkyU · 28/12/2019 19:01

Spent yesterday with mil for Christmas, in the mayhem our 3 DD’s were given their gifts. I did my best trying to take pictures of them opening their gifts but with 3 it’s hard and I missed a lot of eldest dd (18 years old and not OH’s biological child but has raised her for the last 14 years) opening her’s, which also included birthday gifts which hadn’t been given from October.

Today dd1 and I are looking through her gifts, which were all clothing, shoes and a handbag. Literally every article of clothing mil has given dd1 is 3-4 sizes too big (dd1 is a size 6, the clothes are size 12/14)and is all summer dresses and a school pinafore so not current stock to return, the shoes are a size too small and the handbag is such a bad fake that the emblem is about 2cm off centre and has glue marks all over it.

DD’s 2&3 (both oh biologically) were gifted expensive new (weather appropriate)clothing, coats and shoes, pyjamas, toys, sweets and chocolates. There is an age gap so I can appreciate that there will be a disparity in the amount of gifts.

From the size, style and season of clothing I suspect that mil has just stuffed a bunch of her own clothing and shoes from her recent holiday into a gift bag for dd1 and so hasn’t even gone to the effort of looking for and buying her gifts.

This has been a common theme to one degree or another for years. I have raised it with oh and mil previously and it improves the following year but then resumes.

I’ve now had enough and just want to be done with her and her obvious favouritism, she’s never going to change and I’ve given her enough chances. I think if she can’t treat my children with equal care and respect then she can’t see any of them.

Oh will not support this and it will cause issues but Aibu to say “tough, my children’s feelings and mental well-being comes first” even with the fallout this will cause?

OP posts:
simplekindoflife · 29/12/2019 23:50

Horrible thing to do to your dd. Sad

What size is your mil?
Do the same to her for her birthday/Xmas presents. So if she's a size 12, get her a size 18 dress. If she's a size 6 shoe, buy a size 4. Play her at her own game, nasty cow.

Sillyscrabblegames · 29/12/2019 23:59

Sorry I haven't read all the posts so might have missed the actual age of dc2 and 3 but as dc1 is 18, an adult, isn't this all a bit ott? Surely she is a bit old now to making a stand about all of this? I think it is all a bit ridiculous really.
It's definitely worth calling out mil about the odd sizing, give it all back and say sadly nothing fits as it's all way too big. Can you exchange it... But don't turn this all into a major family drama about Inequality and bloodlines. Hmm

FraglesRock · 30/12/2019 00:10

I'd have a conversation with dp. That dd1 is upset her presents don't fit or are faulty, he needs to ask for the receipts.
Get him to ring
Get him to go round to get them.
Keep on at him that it's not fair that she doesn't have presents, and that you only need the receipt to sort it.

Nothing about how unreasonable mil is or he'll get arsy.

Stephminx · 30/12/2019 07:06

@Shesalittlemadam

I’m not sure what you mean ? I’ve not said DD1’s father is in her life. OP has said he is not and Ive wondered how the OP would feel if he was and his she’d expect his family to behave towards her other children.

Brefugee · 30/12/2019 07:46

I'd explain it all to your DH first, and check how he feels or what he thinks.
Then if he agreed I'd say to the MIL that obviously she only gave presents for form's sake and how she wants to handle it in future. I'd suggest cash or gift vouchers or nothing. But not shit gifts that don't fit

Leave the younger DC out of it - it's their grandma and they all seem to be ok.

VeganCow · 30/12/2019 08:47

I wouldn't be explaining anything about how anyone feels at this stage, I would simply stick to the facts as they are, with no emotion at all. I would ask her directly why she gave clothes several (one size can be error, 3/4 no way) sizes too large and that the disparity has been noticed before so what is going on? Put it on her to explain herself and her behaviour first, rather than on you to explain yourself and your feelings.
There is no harm to be done by questioning this, just stay calm throughout. The onus is on her, as she caused it.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread