I can’t take the newspaper on top, that might be a bit dog eared or damp, always have the take one from underneath.
I don’t like the top book from a display, I like to get one that hasn’t been flicked through or handled by a hundred greasy fingers.
I leave the top slice of bread on a loaf, which becomes the ‘bread lid’ to absorb moisture & protect the rest of the loaf. Same with biscuits.
The first squirt from a sauce bottle goes in the bin, as it might have flushed through any plastic lid debris.
Can’t take the front sandwich from the shelf.
Can’t use the top one of a pile of napkins in a cafe.
Sure there are many others 
AIBU or just a bit weird?