Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be surprised that pretty much everyone I know has given their child a ‘wacky’ name?

198 replies

custarddonut · 12/07/2019 14:21

I’m reluctant to give specific examples as it would be potentially outing but by way of comparison I mean that none of my friends’ kids have names that were fairly standard when I was growing up in the 80s. E.g. Rachel / Sarah / Lucy / Daniel / Matthew / John / David etc.

I appreciate that names go in and out of fashion, and I understand (to a degree) that parents perhaps want their kids to stand out (or at least not have what are perceived as ‘boring’ or totally run-of-the-mill names, but more often than not the names in use now (in my circles at least) are, in my opinion, pretentious at best and verging on the ridiculous at worst! Worst-case is where they are sort of just random words, rather than actual names, e.g. ‘snowy’. Or names like the Geldof children e.g. ‘Pixie’ etc. Then you get names which are like old age pensioner names but not necessarily the trendy ones …they seem so dreary to me! (e.g. Phylis) OR names which to me sound really American (and names that you’d need to be quite cool to pull off, or a bit more grown up – they don’t seem to suit kids IMO) e.g. Harrison / Grayson etc. When I think of it, not a single friend of mine has given their kid what I would consider to be a ‘normal’ name.. and this is of a circle of say, 25 kids.

AIBU to feel a bit disappointed about this? I know, each to their own, live and let live, but to me it seems a bit of a shame that ‘normal’ names seem so unfashionable these days…OR, if I were to call my child something like ‘Anna’, would I be setting them up for standing out (in the wrong way) when they go to school? Will the inverse happen and names like ‘John’ become the weird names?!?

OP posts:
Piglet89 · 12/07/2019 17:26

I'm shocked at the number of people that don't realise how recruitment works. Some jobs will get tens of thousands of applicants. The first sift can be extremely brutal.

What, because the organisation is too institutionally lazy/lacking in imagination to work out a non-discriminatory sift method?

Crazy.

Alsohuman · 12/07/2019 17:38

The only objective recruitment sift is one with all the personal details removed. I’m appalled at you @Orangeballon.

ContinuityError · 12/07/2019 17:55

TheCatThatDanced we stuck with boring popular names for our DC - both top ten at the time. Although DS1 doesn’t meet that many others with his name, DS2 was one of 4 in his class - they were all known by variations of first name / surname. DS2 wasn’t at all bothered by this though, I think sometimes parents are more miffed about it than the children (unless they are called Honey).

Howlovely · 12/07/2019 18:20

In work we have a parish magazine and they have a hatches, matches ave dispatches page. We play a game where someone reads out the names and others guess. The only ones who are possible to guess are usually the marriages. They are the Rachels, Nicolas, Claires, Pauls, Darrens and Jonathans. The deaths and births are usually indistinguishable, think Hugo, Clementine, Bert, Iris.

crustycrab · 12/07/2019 18:33

"What, because the organisation is too institutionally lazy/lacking in imagination to work out a non-discriminatory sift method?"

Well yeah, that's exactly what it is. But it pretty much is the norm! Hopefully that will change but calling your child Leaf or Butternut isn't going to help them with the current way of doing things

NameChangeNugget · 12/07/2019 18:50

There was a time when Geoff, Keith & Roy were edgy.

Luxplus · 12/07/2019 18:53

or maybe we should move to a system like Scandinavian countries where parents have to choose from a pre-approved list?
Live in Denmark, we can't only choose from a list but if a name haven't been used before we have to apply to get it approved. It has to be really fare fare out there for not being approved. My dd2s name is Italian (I'm partly Italian) we applied, wrote name accented from Italy. Got it approved all in under 2 weeks, all done online.. I actually think it's fine to have just s bit of restrictions, afterall it's hopefully a name one choose for life of another human...

havinganotherbaby · 12/07/2019 18:54

My brother is Oliver, but he is of the John, Matthew, David generation. I used to be so embarrassed to say his name to friends, everyone who say it's was posh or unusual. It's funny it's such a popular name now. In contrast I have a very common 80's name.

So many 'ie' boys names around here.. Freddie, Bertie, Archie, Frankie, Bobbie, Ronnie and all the girls seem to 'a' or 'ie' Ava, Eva, Isla, Olivia, Evie, Effie, Edie, Lillie, Millie. I always wonder if their birth certificate has a proper name nosey but can't ask that.

PooWillyBumBum · 12/07/2019 19:08

Eh, names are cyclical. DD has a friend Iris whose sister is Mabel and I think they're lovely names. What's wrong with a solid name that's been around hundreds of years?!

I grew up with a very unusual name and people would either struggle to pronounce it or say "Ooooh! How lovely! How unusual!" I always wanted to die, so would never do that to my kids, but I don't have any issue with the Pixies and Snows of this world.

DD goes to a private school and there's a healthy mix of Genevieve/Venetia/Cressidas and the bog standard Olivia/Lily/Isla alongside a smattering of more avante garde names - usually those with parents who have made their money in the arts. DD has a fairly conservative name but it's not in the top 100. I didn't want her to have the issue Emilys and Beckys did in my school days (fighting to be 'Becky 1'!)

PooWillyBumBum · 12/07/2019 19:09

But yes I suppose I do mean more celebrity-style wacky names but also, to a lesser extent, the dozens of Marlows, Arlos, Wilfreds etc.

@custarddonut DH is from Marlow and friends who still live there have just had an Arlo. I shit you not. Arlo from Marlow.

Supergirlthesecond · 12/07/2019 19:18

@Purpletigers yes, I thought of that book, too ! Good call! Very interesting about why certain names appear in certain communities

Poetryinaction · 12/07/2019 19:23

I called my dd Anna. I didn't think she would stand out. We know lots of little Annas. I also know some kids with more unusual names but I would never have chosen one.

PinkieTuscadero · 12/07/2019 20:10

I would hate to live under the Danish system.

MitziK · 12/07/2019 20:18

For those people who say they would automatically bin applications with names such as 'Princess Tiaami' or 'Honey' - have you considered that your decision means you are automatically binning applications from almost solely Afro-Caribbean applicants?

It's very common for girls to be named things like Destiny, Princess, Honey, Krystal, Praise, Blessing and for boys to have similar aspirational qualities for theirs.

ellendegeneres · 12/07/2019 20:54

A friend is naming her baby Terry. I love that she’s using a family name and going old school.
Most kids I know have normal names. By that I mean in comparison to the kardashian names.
For example Sarah, Ellie, Alfie, Megan, Finlay, Jude, aiden.
Perfectly ‘normal’ and none of this attention seeking psalm or north ridiculousness.

When naming my own kids I went with names that would be timeless and sound good as children and adults.

PinkieTuscadero · 12/07/2019 20:57

Terry will be born with a fag behind one ear and an account in his local William Hill bookies.

PinkieTuscadero · 12/07/2019 20:58

and he'll swagger into nursery saying 'awight, laydeeez'.

Gloopy · 12/07/2019 21:07

Me and my OH were talking about this today. When we registered out youngest son (5) we asked the registrar what the most unusual name was.... It was Sinister....they refused the mother the name unless she at least changed the spelling. My sons both has not common but not unusual names... Well DS2 is quite common now I think, but my oldest 20 has never met another one with his name... But its a good Yorkshire name.. Lol. I hate people's desperation to find something unique and cool, ans made up names. I don't like the current trens of double barrel first name... But that my personal preference.

tillytoodles1 · 12/07/2019 21:27

I know a Grace who is almost 80 and a few little girls of that name.

Madein1995 · 12/07/2019 21:57

One of the girls I was in school was has called her child Zuri, and another has called her child Jax. What's wrong with standard names like Ellie, Madison, Elle, Isla etc. Who is going to vote for a PM called Jax for example (However considering the parents involved I doubt Jax will be encouraged to continue past GCSEs let alone go on to be PM)

ScratchyMap · 12/07/2019 22:02

I have friends with girls called Willow, Harper and Aurora. To me, those are unusual names but they were the 27th, 34th and 83rd most popular names in England in 2017.

To put that in perspective, the names in the same positions in 1984 were Danielle, Joanna & Nichola, and in 1994 were Victoria, Paige & Chantelle. None of those are unusual for their generations (although I haven’t encountered the Nichola spelling before).

Obviously this is just an example- you might not be thinking of the same types of names as I am- but it shows how we’re skewed by what we think is normal.

SausageEggAndSpam · 12/07/2019 22:15

Whilst there's a load of names I cringe at which are more recent, I was glad when people stopped using classic/ traditional/ biblical names. There seem to be a lot more names in the modern choices than were used from the classic etc ones.

At school, it was all Rebecca, Victoria, Anna, Elizabeth, Claire, Catherine, Sophie, Alexandra, Stephanie, Hannah, Michelle. I went to a girls school. So basically, every class was a load of Beckys, Kates, Vickys, Lizzies etc.

My eldest has a rarely used name people haven't often heard of, and my youngest has a common name, a flower's name. But it's not Rose or Lily (heavens no, not Lily), or Poppy. I wanted more outlandish flower child nature names but I was vetoed.

Most of my friends have kids with interesting or flower child names, but I know a lot of goths and hippies.

sirmione16 · 12/07/2019 22:57

How about Jackdaniel or Tiamarie? Grin

thehooksite.com/mum-savagely-trolled-for-naming-children-after-famous-alcoholic-spirits/

sirmione16 · 12/07/2019 23:12

@QueQueQue apologises just seen x posted. I didn't RTFT obviously