Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed at my friend for asking for money towards her drinks?

136 replies

SuperProbably · 26/06/2019 11:04

Its an essay folks, grab a cuppa...

So ive just got back from a girlie weekend away here in the UK. There were 6 of us in total but only 4 of us drinking. We had all contributed to a shopping kitty but we had decided we would bring drinks seperately as it wasnt fair to the 2 non-drinkers to be adding alcohol into the kitty. The 4 of us had conferred beforehand about what everyone was in the mood for drinking or what we would be drinking. I said i was bringing about 4 bottles of various wines and 1 spirit. My friend 1 mentioned she will be bringing prosecco. She ended up bringing about 5 bottles and friend 3 bought gin. The fourth bought cans of Carling for herself. Anyway, turned out we ended up with alot more booze than we needed, a friend who couldn't make it gifted us a bottle and the hosts of the airbnb gifted us a bottle of wine too. friend 1 was the one who was pretty much opening and pouring the drinks all weekend. When we were leaving and packing up i noticed none of mine had been touched and friend 3's gin hadnt been touched either. Friend 1 asked us both to contribute to her prosecco because she said she couldn't really afford to cover 5 bottles but didnt mind covering about 3 of them. To top it off she said she wouldn't be asking friend 4 for any as she feels she didnt really drink any of it. Just to confirm she did drink plenty of it but only on the one night because she over did it and couldnt stomach any the following night. Friend 1 is majorly sympathetic to friend 4 because she suffers from depression and has told her shes struggling with money many times so i think deep down thats why she didnt want to ask her.

Myself and friend 3 were really put out by her request. We assumed the drinks were a potluck type of situation. The whole reason id bought bottles with me was so that i wouldnt have to spend more money when i got there. And i even offered my unopened bottle as recompense but she declined. If i had known i would have to reimburse her for drinking hers i wouldnt have touched them and stuck to my own instead. Its not like we helped ourselves to her bottles she poured them for us! The thing is if mine had been emptied i wouldnt have asked for people to compensate me because the whole reason i bought them was for them to be enjoyed by everyone.

As a bit of background, it was friend 1's hen last year, we organised a weekend away for her which she didnt shell a penny out for as per usual custom and we genuinely loved showering her with the celebrations. We all did the same booze potluck situation and at the end of the weekend some people had booze left over and some didnt. Nobody asked anyone to reimburse them for their bottles because we had all budgeted for it. This weekend was supposed to be our friend 1's way of thanking all of us for throwing her an amazing hen weekend. She wanted to take on all of the planning for it but she ended up making me feel really crap which kind of ruined what she was trying to do for us. As i dropped her off to the train station (after also picking her up and driving her around all weekend as well as others) she said i dont need to give her anything because ive driven them everywhere and she owes me petrol money which i would never ask for. Im the only one that drives and am often ferrying people around. But my issue is though that seems like we're square, she should never have asked for what she did in the first place. We've been friends for 20 years and shes made me feel so awkward with such an ill thought comment i feel like im questioning everything. I dont know whether to mention it to her or let it go for the sake of our friendship? AIBU with how shes made me feel? Or was she right to do so? I feel like if shed mentioned it from the start we wouldnt have been so taken aback. The whole weekend was poorly communicated in terms of money. Instead of telling us beforehand what to budget etc for the shopping she just sprung it on us over lunch in a pub on the saturday. Also i think something else is adding to my ire, one of the girls couldnt make it in the end and we all had to pay a little more to cover her share for the airbnb. That wasnt a problem as it was only about £13 more. However a part of me wonders whether she took the extra amount off friend 4, as she had said to me she was worried about friend 4 being able to afford it a while ago, i never talk about my own money struggles but i think she thinks because im a SAHM and we own our own house and run 2 cars im immediately financially better off than the single friend who lives alone in a rented flat.

Sorry for the essay guys, i dont know why i cant shake this. I feel like its changed our relationship now. I always treat friends with trust regarding money. Sometimes one buys coffees one time and the other gets it the next time but this friend has never been like that and its making me take stock of it all which i never would have done had she not made me feel like this.

Would love to know anyone else's thoughts. I should probably just get over it i know Hmm

OP posts:
Deadringer · 26/06/2019 16:18

I offered her my prosecco to make up for drinking hers but she wanted the money so the friend brought 5 bottles of prosecco, drank loads and went home with two plus the offer of a third, and she wants money, she is a cf.

Upfeet · 26/06/2019 16:29

You drank all her drink and kept your own. You should offer some money towards the expense. I would not be happy if I were her. You and your friend who drank all her alcohol were rude.

Allhailthesun · 26/06/2019 16:41

Upfeet no, the friend who is offering her drinks then expecting money is rude. There was plenty of other bottles for her to open.

honeygirlz · 26/06/2019 16:41

The thing is the drinks kitty was agreed in advance.

And the wine might be the same price as Prosecco.

stayathomer · 26/06/2019 16:45

I think you are all being a bit unreasonable and none of you are being unreasonable! So you should have opened your own drink and or offered her money in the first place and she should have accepted your offer and not brought up money. It’s a pity friends would be so snitty at each other, you should all just forget about it and move on

timeandtimeagain42 · 26/06/2019 17:43

Nobody forced the Prosecco down your throat though, why didn't you and friend 3 open and start drinking the drinks you'd brought??
I think that she's right, you were a bit cheeky to drink all her drink, take yours home untouched and then get offended at being asked to contribute towards hers.
Just buy her a bottle of Prosecco each then you're done.

StealthPolarBear · 26/06/2019 18:01

timeandtimeagain42 she offered her friend prosecco. Friend wanted cash. Effectively the friend wanted to seel some of the wjne she'd brought

BadnessInTheFolds · 26/06/2019 18:32

I think given this was a supposed thank you from "Friend 1" she should have let it go.

She brought 5 bottles, chose to serve them, went home with 2 bottles and was offered a 3rd. Asking for a fiver towards booze on top of that is ridiculous!

eddielizzard · 26/06/2019 18:34

Hmm I think your OP was misleading tbh, and your update paints her in a less favourable light. She seems to be inclined to treat you all differently.

SunniDay · 26/06/2019 18:39

I'm still intrigued how your friend was thanking/treating you. You all paid accommodation, you all paid groceries, you all took your own noise, you drive. What was the treat? Gracing you with her company?

SunniDay · 26/06/2019 18:40

*Booze! (Noise)

Idontwanttotalk · 26/06/2019 18:53

"I've read this as 3 or 4 of you drank the gifted wine and all of friends prosecco and took home your untouched booze?

Sounds fair to contribute if I've understood correctly."
This is how I read it too, although I think friend 4 drank her own lager? I know friend 1 poured it but you drank it. I think, if you are taking your own booze back home, you should contribute to the prossecco.

Next time do it differently. Put money in a kitty and go out and buy the drinks from that.

StealthPolarBear · 26/06/2019 19:54

The friend took the airbnb wine and the gift home with her.

vincettenoir · 27/06/2019 18:10

This is bonkers. Let it go.

nuxe1984 · 27/06/2019 18:23

You should have drunk what you brought.

You've been asked to contribute for 1 bottle of prosecco and have taken all your wines/spirit back home.

You've also drunk free alcohol provided by an absent friend and the Airbnb owner.

Doesn't seem too much to me … YABVU … and whiny ….

Pantsomime · 27/06/2019 18:47

So you brought say £20 worth to party and took home again, but had something worth £x while there. Friend 1 brought £20 to party and goes home with nothing - you contribute - it’s called having your cake and eating it

honeygirlz · 27/06/2019 18:57

Pantsomime but OP offered her friend wine.

It would be unfair for Prosecco friend to go home with cash and OP and other friend to go home with unwanted Boobooze

honeygirlz · 27/06/2019 18:58

And Op drove everyone there!

Carriecakes80 · 27/06/2019 19:06

I think she probably felt you lot were being right tight-arses and not pouring the drinks, you say she kept ouring, but were you insistant and bringing out your booze? Maybe she knows what you lot are like and didn't want to ask if you lot were going to open your own alcohol...so she kindly just kept pouring hers...you've already proved she's kind by thinking of your friend who has depression and barely and money...while you are whining about paying for some prosecco? Jesus.
Give me these types of problems please Lordy! lol x

Armadilloboss · 27/06/2019 19:44

Prosecco is literally £6-10. She’s willing to pay for 3 bottles so £18-30. She is literally asking you and your friend to contribute one bottle each. I wouldn’t fall out with a friend over £10. Particularly if you saved your full bottle of gin. Just give her a tenner and remember it for when you’s are drinking together again

Yabbers · 27/06/2019 19:57

Changed my mind with your update OP

Of course you have. The story changed from OP bringing various wines and a bottle of spirit to the OP bringing Prosecco. Probably because she realised she was the CF of the story.

MissRhubarb · 27/06/2019 19:59

This really isn't worth falling out with good mates over.

Mylittlepea · 27/06/2019 22:00

I got bored reading by paragraph 3.....

DaisyYellow · 27/06/2019 22:05

I think more people would have agreed that YANBU if they’d had the will to read your OP to the end.

livefornaps · 27/06/2019 22:32

Personally, i had lost the will to live by the end of it.

Maybe you could sell your riveting "stories" as a cure for insomnia