Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I cannot handle my sister in law and I think it'll make me absolutely lose my mind.

143 replies

LH2016 · 10/06/2019 09:20

Hi wise ones, please help me! To cut a long story short my SIL is a little older than me in her early forties, not in a relationship, and no kids. She's bossy, arrogant, opinionated and always makes me feel like shit. No filter or respect for me being her brother's wife, even though she wouldn't dare talk to the other SIL the way she talks to me. She corrects my grammar, tells me what to say and not to say, and then I thought, oh well she'll get better when we have kids because she wouldn't dare correct my parenting. I have had a difficult time telling my husband for the last seven years how she makes me feel and he basically always excuses her and never has my back. ONCE he picked her up on something. Never again. He always finds an excuse.
Yesterday she said really aggressively I do hope you aren't giving him too much fruit juice. I said, excuse me? I was so shocked. She goes on about it being the leading cause of hospital admissions. My husband starts rambling about how it's ok because we use a straw and I'm like WTF this was your chance to tell her to STFU as we are not idiots and we have it covered thanks, and so I tell him how out of order it was in the car on the way home and then I'm told his family is off limits and then we had a huge row and I called her an interfering bit*h. I think that's pretty good going once in seven years. I am his family but feel like the lowest level on the pecking order because he will NEVER correct her. So he said ok, I'll call her and tell her what she said was out of order. But then it'll get back to the MIL, the BILs and I'll be the horrible person, so guess what, I told him not to bother because of how hard it will be for HIM. So she still is free to carry on. I hate her with my every ounce of energy and live in fear that when my MIL dies, we will inherit this miserable, opinionated arrogant woman to come and ruin our Christmas and Easter and children's birthdays, She makes me feel like shit CONSTANTLY. It rips me apart and despite having a fairly good chat to clear the air for a few hours last night, the upshot is husband still thinks I should just 'challenge her respectfully' next time she does something but I know even the smack down I gave her yesterday - well you don't have a toddler so all this theoretical parenting is easy isn't it - won't be enough to stop her because she has no respect for me. My mum hates her, my friends hate her, I just can't handle it. I don't even know what I want here, there's no answer, I just cannot deal with it.

OP posts:
Oliversmumsarmy · 10/06/2019 15:44

Next time you see her I would thank her for letting you know about the dangers of orange juice. Tell her you have swapped dc onto colaGrin

GabriellaMontez · 10/06/2019 16:16

She sounds v irritating. I think your husband probably tunes her out which is why he's not noticed. I think he'll start to notice when you strt standing up for yourself.

You could try.

"Who made you the grammar police?" With a little laugh. If it persists. " please stop correcting me, it makes you sound very rude and I'm sure you don't mean to be"

EuromumAussiekid · 10/06/2019 16:41

Honestly your husband has to grow a a pair and stick up for his wife. Tell her next time ' they are my children. Don't tell me how to parent my own children' I would show her the front door too.

poobumwee · 10/06/2019 17:15

She sounds like a bitch and your husband needs to grow a pair. Next time she says anything call her out on it, straight away. . Don't be rude. Stay calm but don't let it go until she answers you. If she makes any comment about awkwardness just tell her thats how she has treated you the last 7 years and it stops. Immediately. If it doesn't nc. Its just not worth it.

Idontwanttotalk · 10/06/2019 18:06

@2toddlers

"She sounds like a bitch, she's probably just jealous of what you have if she's in her 40s single no kids, clearly no one would put up with her to actually stay with her!"
Why the heck do posters jump on the ' jealous of you' line - she is probably just a controlling , know-it-all. It's not the most mature comment to make. You should realise that your comment may upset others on MN who may be single, in their 40s and haven't kids. (That isn't my situation by the way).

HoppingPavlova · 11/06/2019 00:59

the biggest mistake gentle people make, is to say nothing and say nothing and then when we can't handle it any more, EXPLODE with rage.

I disagree with this. Surely the biggest mistake is engaging in the first place? The OP’s husband has obviously lived a lifetime of this and has managed quite nicely by completely tuning out. The OP seems to have spent the last seven years tuning in and getting upset by it. That’s the problem. Nothing about standing up for yourself, just don’t engage with an idiot, easily fixed. The bonus is when you don’t engage people desist as they realise it’s pointless or if they are that socially unaware then it doesn’t matter because you have turned your listening ears off so don’t know what they are saying anyway and there is no annoyance.

MummyParanoia101 · 11/06/2019 01:07

@LH2016 So his sister can say/do whatever she wants and can criticise who she likes but you can't? So she's more important than you are? HmmHmmHmmHmm

Itwouldtakemuchmorethanthis · 11/06/2019 01:15

I have held back for seven years out of respect for them all
What an odd way to behave. Just tell her to fuck off. Your life will improve no end if she does.

CSIblonde · 11/06/2019 01:21

Limit your time with her massively. Any digs, change subject or physically leave the room to 'check' on something. Don't engage as your reaction is what she's looking for. Your reactions are feeding & fueling her toxic MO/ dynamic. So shut it down. Being ignored is embarrassing & doesn't give her the 'hit' she needs that she's upset you.

DeeCeeCherry · 11/06/2019 01:42

Don't spend any time with her then. Don't have conversation with her. If she's around your house enough to bother you to this extent (and she shouldn't be around so often, it's your family home not hers) then sorry but your husband is spineless and should go off and live with his sister. The whole dynamic sounds weird. Didn't you see it before you married him..?

Guylian2019 · 11/06/2019 05:12

''She sounds like a bitch, she's probably just jealous of what you have if she's in her 40s single no kids, clearly no one would put up with her to actually stay with her!''

I love the views people have of single, childless women like me. Makes me feel so good Hmm

Durgasarrow · 11/06/2019 05:39

This is what I would say: "Karen, I just want you to know that if you have a problem with something I do or say, please keep your thoughts to yourself. I am an adult doing the best I can, and I am only interested in hearing positive words. I will give you the same courtesy. I think it would be best if we treated each other with at least as much politeness as we would give a stranger."

1624RL · 11/06/2019 06:38

''She sounds like a bitch, she's probably just jealous of what you have if she's in her 40s single no kids, clearly no one would put up with her to actually stay with her!''

Hrtwt, but I’m going to cut the SIL some slack. Yes, I absolutely agree with all the PP that you need to set some boundaries, but quite possibly she behaves the way she does because you have everything that she wants and she finds the whole situation heartbreakingly unbearable. I felt similarly when my younger DBs got married and had DC before I did. I just avoided them, so SILs probably thought I was rude or weird, but I simply couldn’t bear to see their happiness with everything that I wanted.

VeganCow · 11/06/2019 07:52

Ellisandra has it spot on here. Never justify your reasons for anything, or argue about it. Just pull her up on her rudeness, regardless of the topic it is about.

Spiceupyourlife · 11/06/2019 08:24

Maybe try a ‘I’m sure if you EVER have children you’ll be a very proficient parent....how’s your love life? Anybody new on the scene? Did you know that being old and lovely is a leading cause of depression? Have you tried tinder? 🤔’

Spiceupyourlife · 11/06/2019 08:25

*lonley

Wanderlusting99 · 11/06/2019 11:47

I'm sure she's got the wrong end of the stick here, maybe fastest rising cause of hospital admissions? But it didn't even make the top 10 a few years ago and I can't see teeth ever overtaking respiratory illnesses for hospital admissions

www.theguardian.com/society/2017/apr/23/hospital-admissions-infants-nhs-

Deuxcaggages · 11/06/2019 12:17

I don’t think you should make passive aggressive comments to her, just be clear that her advice isn’t wanted.
Also out of curiosity prior to fruit juice incident how did you respond to her commentary, is there a chance in the past she’s misinterpreted your passiveness as you welcoming her advice. Some people just need to be told very clearly that you do not find their behaviour acceptable, before the penny drops.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page