Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people buy clear dog poo bags

147 replies

Littlefroggy18 · 02/04/2019 17:56

I mean really...should they even exist?? Why why would you buy a clear one where you can see all the poo inside considering you usually have to walk some distance before you get to a bin?! The amount of people I see daily walking round with see through bags full of shit is ridiculous! Buy black ones!!!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MenuPlant · 03/04/2019 14:07

Our area has recently become v popular with dog walkers and also seems loads of people getting dogs at mo so round here is an awful lot of dogs about and some nice places to go but still quite densely populated iyswim. Outer London.

WendyWoofer · 03/04/2019 15:33

I've just returned from walking my dog in a stick and flick area. If anyone wants to take their children to a stick and flick area to play that's up to them.

Most parents take their children to family friendly places where dogs are not allowed, like parks, or other public areas where the bag and bin it rule is enforced.

Any parent who chooses to let their kids run loose in an - unsuitable for children - stick and flick area do so knowing there will be dog and other animal mess under the hedges. The choice is theirs.

To wonder why people buy clear dog poo bags
To wonder why people buy clear dog poo bags
HaroldsSocalledBluetits · 03/04/2019 16:12

LOL so children shouldn't be allowed in the green spaces made unsafe for them by dog owners being scuzzy. Let's just designate said precious resource as "dog toilet" eh. Oh and fuck all the other wildlife affected by the behaviour of these so called animal lovers as well.

Thing is, there currently isn't a way to dispose of pet waste that is both green and hygienic. I think this is a problem. Even dog owners who want to behave responsibly wrt fellow humans and wildlife accessing green spaces or to minimise their environmental footprint are largely unable to do so, other than to compost the waste themselves. There are a handful of good initiatives like powering a light through the gases released by decomposition but they are few and far between.

It's great that we are at least partially finding solutions to other waste caused by human activity but we really need to crack on with how to deal with waste caused by the human activity of pet ownership.

In the meantime, paper bag and into landfill seems the only hassle free way. But that is still many tonnes a year of landfill waste.

WendyWoofer · 03/04/2019 16:54

LOL so children shouldn't be allowed in the green spaces made unsafe for them by dog owners being scuzzy

They are not safe for children because they consist of narrow paths, surrounded by gorse bushes and in the area I mentioned is on a cliff top. They are not areas where children can run and play ball or search the hedges for bugs.

Of course if parents feel their children would benefit from these areas they by all means take them. These areas are not frequented by families because they are not family friendly.

You'll find that areas that are of interest to the public will have plenty of bins and a bag and bin it policy.

If you want to hike your children through gorse bushes on a cliff top feel free to do so. Nobody's stopping you.

Monkeybunkey · 03/04/2019 16:57

I've never seen clear dog poo bags for sale and I've bought thousands over the years from many different places. I do, however, know someone who nicks the clear fruit and veg bags in supermarkets to use as poo bags (not me!).

StoneofDestiny · 03/04/2019 17:08

Black plastic cannot go into recycling so should never be used

You can recycle some as they are 'green' dyed black with a dye that can be detectable for recycling.

MenuPlant · 03/04/2019 17:31

That looks like a nice walk to me you're seriously suggesting that it's not 'for' families and just for people without kids and people with dogs

And children should stick to designated child areas like the play areas in parks

OK wow that's an awful attitude

MenuPlant · 03/04/2019 17:32

So areas made specifically for children are for children and everywhere else is for dogs

That feels totally the wrong way round to me but whatever

I know a lot of dog people can be quite extreme but that's the best I've heard yet!

MenuPlant · 03/04/2019 17:33

What age do you think children should be allowed in that path lol

10
13
16
21

???

Bonkers

MenuPlant · 03/04/2019 17:35

I like the way dog owners appear to have decided anywhere without bins in? undefined radius its good for them to fling shit all over the sides of the paths and say the area is 'not suitable' for children.

This is honestly quite funny.

Humans eh.

Doggydoggydoggy · 03/04/2019 17:52

Definitely not me!

I don’t know anyone personally that would ever consider not bagging and binning.

I agree it looks a gorgeous walk and I would be really pissed off to be basically told you shouldn’t take kids here due to shit, stick to the parks and designated child friendly zones.

Public green spaces should be for the benefit of everyone and everyone should treat them respectfully which includes not leaving shit that you could easily pick up and dispose of.

StoneofDestiny · 03/04/2019 22:10

There are pubic areas where you can just chuck dog shit around 🤮🤮. What a totally revolting idea.

Smotheroffive · 03/04/2019 22:14

This thread well reflects the toxic shit it's 'discussing' Hmm

Butteredghost · 03/04/2019 22:50

Black plastic cannot go into recycling so should never be used

Neither can clear plastic if it's filled with poo! What do you imagine happens? You throw a clear bag filled with dog shit in to the trash and someone at the rubbish dump opens the bag, puts the shit somewhere and recycles the bag? Use common sense!

And please do not say you put plastic bags filled with dog poo in the recycling?! Shock

HaroldsSocalledBluetits · 03/04/2019 22:54

Doggydoggydoggy completely agree. I bet the same people who stick and flick wouldn't dream of chucking their unfinished picnic under a hedge - but they will do so with shit!

One thing that we all including me need to start getting our heads around is that when you throw something away, there isn't actually an "away" to throw it into. You're just moving it to a different part of the planet. Same as when people say that the rain washes their dog's shit "away" - it doesn't vanish. It seeps into the soil, into the groundwater and eventually into streams and rivers and, yes, the sea. Obviously it isn't just dog shit that we need to apply this thinking to, but it is something that I've heard said by lots of owners.

lozster · 03/04/2019 23:00

Of course if parents feel their children would benefit from these areas they by all means take them. These areas are not frequented by families because they are not family friendly.

Hilarious!

If the area is officially stick and flick, then I disagree but you ARE in the right as it were. In my county, only the forestry commission is stick and flick. Elsewhere, any land accessible to the public is covered by a bylaw obliging instant pick up. There is a maximum 1k fine and possibility of criminal conviction.

Dog poo is a pain to children, buggies, wheelchairs, runners and anyone who doesn’t enjoy tiptoeing through the turds. Stick and flick assumes that there are places that no one will go to, that there is an accuracy in the chucking, that the stick will be disposed of too, that the flicker will have sound judgement in where to place the deposit. I have some doubts on most of those points given that we are talking here about a hard core (minority) who think it is reasonable to hang a plastic bag with poop in on a tree.

The comparison to wildlife just doesn’t stack up. There are 9 million dogs in the UK walked on regular routes. There are half a million foxes dispersed across open country. As for cows, sheep etc - they are herbivores and the farmer is indeed subject to rules about how they handle manure. It can’t just be disposed of at will.

Use a paper bag, use an old margarine tub, fund a methane light a la the malvern hills but don’t make your problems other people’s and seek to restrict their freedom because of your choices.

TheDarkPassenger · 03/04/2019 23:23

I didn’t realise poo could cause such a kerfuffle!

None of the things on this thread bother me, I use black poo bags but I had to use sandwich bags for a week when the dog ate all the balls from hungry hippos and I had to email hasbro, ask them how many there were, then count them in my dogs shit until they were all out.

Mostly stick to black bags though Grin

WendyWoofer · 04/04/2019 00:08

I didn’t realise poo could cause such a kerfuffle

In real life it doesn't.

Smotheroffive · 04/04/2019 02:15

Helpful link for dog poo paper bags? Harolds can you not link this, it would be really good for any that want to do something poositive and make a difference, dontcha thunk?

CuriousaboutSamphire · 04/04/2019 03:08

I like the way dog owners appear to have decided anywhere without bins in? undefined radius its good for them to fling shit all over the sides of the paths and say the area is 'not suitable' for children You mean one anonymous MN poster who may or may not actually own a dog?

Smotheroffive · 04/04/2019 03:35

I can't say I have ever seen one solitary soul fling shit all over the place and if I and other dog walkers saw it, it wouldn't go unchallenged.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 04/04/2019 03:55

I've never seen it done but round here we are having a Town Spring Clean and the pictures of hanging poo bags... OMG! Hang on, I'll grab one or two for you! It's disgusting!

CuriousaboutSamphire · 04/04/2019 04:00

I mean, once you have spotted it, how did Poo2 get there? Who flings poos bags like that?

There is a poo bin about 10 metres from these. They wer found in a beautiful area that many people walk their dogs in, off lead is allowed, encouraged even and is, for the most part poo free. Yes some get missed, there are too many trees for that not to happen every now and then. But it is perfectly safe for kids to run round in... and they do, it's on a regular school run!

To wonder why people buy clear dog poo bags
To wonder why people buy clear dog poo bags
Smotheroffive · 04/04/2019 04:10

I've always wondered about the gits that throw bags full! Or those that hang them in trees! Nope,no idea at all...complete loss, its gross and inane

lozster · 04/04/2019 08:31

If you want to find an item to buy such as paper dog bags, I find google is really useful. I put in ‘paper dog bags’ and found Trixie bags, if you want a picture of a dog on the front. If you search for ‘paper bag’ you will find lots of non-doggy themed bags. Or use what you have at home already. Worried about it soaking through? Reuse one plastic bag as a liner. Or Put it in Tupperware.
Or Put it in an old biscuit tin. Then take it home.

The power of Google also found me a range of dog composters to use in the garden.

And Wendy, dog shit causes a huge kerfuffle in real life. That’s why my local authority have legislated to fine dog owners. Don’t assume everyone using an open area is using it in the same way as you. There are lovely public spaces near me where I might risk a slow walk surveying the floor and shouting ‘watch the dog poo!’ to my kid and grabbing him by the shoulders at intervals to steer him round the mess but I wouldn’t risk a run.