Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm so dumb...

192 replies

StupidSis · 10/11/2018 08:00

I chose my username because I know that I'm being stupid but my feelings are still very hurt. I don't know what to do about them.

My younger brother is getting married. I am 36 and he is 33. He has chosen his wedding party. I have 3 brothers in total. One of them is estranged and he would have been the best man if he was speaking to the rest of our family. The second brother is a groomsman. 2 of our cousins are a bridesmaid and a groomsman respectively. The other roles are filled out by friends.

I feel very hurt that I was not asked to be a bridesmaid or a groomswoman. I am the only sister and it's painful to see cousins were chosen for those roles ahead of me. At the last minute, I was given a role as a reader. It was also embarrassing to find out that I was not chosen to be a wedding party member in a very public way. My brother and his fiancee had a huge engagement party. They called up everyone who was involved in the wedding to the front of a large room in the restaurant where the party was held. Many of our close friends and relatives were whispering about the fact that I wasn't a bridesmaid. Our mother asked me if I was going to go up to the front when the wedding party members were called and I quietly informed our mother that I was a reader. I left the party soon after that.

I always thought that my brother and I were close. We usually got along well as kids and adults. I was always there for him in many ways. Years ago, my brother and fiancee were in a long distance relationship and he was very sad about her absence. I gave him plane fare and some spending money to go see her because I hated seeing my little brother in pain. I have always supported his relationship with his fiancee as well. My brother is always praising me to others because I am a "wonderful aunt" to his daughters.

My husband understands why I'm so hurt and so does the rest of our family. In our culture and our family, siblings are always in wedding parties unless there is an extenuating circumstance such as serious illness or feuds. My mother thinks that including one sibling and not the other was very rude and so was choosing cousins over a sister.

I do not even want to attend the wedding since I feel that my brother and his fiancee do not like me. Nevertheless, boycotting the wedding would cause more drama. My husband offered to plan a minibreak the same weekend of the wedding. On the invitations, we will specify that we will only attend the ceremony. A cousin of mine warned me that only attending the ceremony could lead to wagging tongues as well as upsetting my brother and his fiancee.

I greatly appreciate all who read this far. Once again, I know that I sound stupid and immature but I can't help how I feel. I have been quite sad about this for a few months. It hurts to find out that you aren't important to a close family member.

OP posts:
MoaningSickness · 10/11/2018 09:45

Honestly I can't see the problem at all here. Bridesmaids are traditionally the bride's close female friends/family (which you are not), and Groomsmen are the groom's close male friends/family (which you are not). Hence to include you they made you a reader.

In a similar situation I gave my brother a role as witness, as he wasn't close enough to DH to be a groomsman, nor female enough to be a bridesmaid!

You also say that your role as reader was 'last minute' but also that you knew about it when the wedding party was announced, so it wasn't 'last minute' at all, was it. They had clearly thought about you and given you an important and appropriate role.

seven201 · 10/11/2018 09:47

You need to have a heart to heart with your brother. This is already a big 'thing' that will affect your relationship. You need to discuss so you can move forward.

I'd be very hurt too.

Dollymixture22 · 10/11/2018 09:49

To those saying this is normal, I think OP has said her cousins are bridesmaids, so if I have picked this up correctly the grooms cousins are bridesmaids but his sister is not.

Toddlerteaplease · 10/11/2018 09:58

Being asked to do a reading is a fairly important part of a wedding. Can't see what your problem is.

Oomph · 10/11/2018 10:04

Why don’t you just talk to your brother about it? Much better than going off all offended and setting further tongues a-wagging.

ambereeree · 10/11/2018 10:08

Are the cousins younger than you or unmarried? I always thought doing a reading a big part in a wedding.

AnnaMagnani · 10/11/2018 10:10

Am I being dumb here but isn't being a reader being part of the wedding?

I'd have walked up to the front when they called for people involved in the wedding if I was a reader Confused

OK, there's no outfit but it's a lot better than usher/groomsman because you have a serious thing to do. And bridesmaid involves wearing something that doesn't suit you, walking up the aisle and that's it.

Could this all be a massive misunderstanding and they think that have involved you, and given you a better role?

SilentIsla · 10/11/2018 10:14

What a horrible thing they have done. Of course you are are not dumb but they are ignorant.

SilentIsla · 10/11/2018 10:15

Sisters are before cousins in the pecking order.

planechocolate · 10/11/2018 10:15

Perhaps this is something for your mother to talk to him about? She clearly feels much the same as you do.

gamerwidow · 10/11/2018 10:15

I agree that the bride usually chooses bridesmaids but the OP would have been just as happy being a groomswoman which is definitely in her brother's power to choose.
Doing a reading can be an important part of a wedding but the fact no-one included the OP when they called the wedding party to the front at the engagement party suggests it is a bit of an afterthought and they don't see her as a core part of the day.
Speak to you brother before the wedding it's better to get the bad feeling out now than on the day.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe2726 · 10/11/2018 10:17

Please don't specify on the invitation that you'll 'Only attend the ceremony'. What's the point of that? It will just eat you up. Better to miss the whole thing than that - take up your husband's offer to be on holiday.

Better still - speak to your bother and his fiancée to ask what's happened here and why - and how everybody can 'keep face' with the decisions made. Including you in the wedding party now is going to be noticed, and excluding you from it has already been noticed. You need a plan.

If you can get over this raw reaction once you've spoken to your brother/fiancée, can it be covered up by saying that you a) wanted to take a less public role (although I don't know if that applies to reader) b) maybe don't be a reader? That would back it up...

I don't know OP, it's very odd. If it were me and I had a good and close relationship with my brother, I'd ask him outright for an explanation, gloves off.

I can see how sad you are. I would be too. If you think there's going to be 'talk' anyway then don't be part of it. People can speculate all they want (and they do). They don't know. Keep them out of your business and do whatever will make this easiest for you.

So sorry that you have to deal with this nonsense. Flowers

Gazelda · 10/11/2018 10:24

I think you're being over sensitive.

Talk to your brother.
Surely that would be easier and cause less drama than only going to the ceremony (which I think would be very petty and rude). Your strategy will create repercussions for the whole family for a long time. Yes, your DB's decision about the make up of the bridal party may be the root cause, but you can choose to have an open conversation or to make the wedding about you.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 10/11/2018 10:26

I really don't think you need to be sad. They have incorporated a role as a reader for you. All attention will be focused on you whilst you are performing your role so arguably more important than groomsmen or bridesmaid. With regards to calling the wedding party up did they do so by name or was it step forward wedding party and you chose to remain where you were.

magoria · 10/11/2018 10:33

I agree with some of the others you are being over sensitive.

If you and the bride are not that close why would you expect to be one of her bridesmaids? Also traditionally aren't bridesmaids unmarried?

As for a grooms woman. I wouldn't expect one of them traditionally either.

Don't get others involved.

Either appreciate and gracefully do the reading they have asked you too or decline and just be a guest.

You are being unreasonable.

CupoBlood · 10/11/2018 10:37

I felt the same, I've never discussed it with them.

Isthereeveranexcuse · 10/11/2018 10:42

Ive never discussed it with my brother and his now wife either - that would be a recipe for a shitshow and I just wouldn't and didn't want to go there. I've just, as they say, taken it under advisement and have born it in mind going forward. And I'll never ever put myself out for them ever ever again.

Orchidflower1 · 10/11/2018 10:44

As pp said - how old are the cousins? Does the bride want all children/ teenagers for bridesmaids?

PurpleDaisies · 10/11/2018 10:49

What a horrible thing they have done. Of course you are are not dumb but they are ignorant.

In what way is it “ignorant”?

Women are free to choose their bridesmaids. It isn’t as if the op isn’t invited to the wedding. Confused

I really don’t understand a lot of these comments.

worridmum · 10/11/2018 10:52

Basically by the sounds of it the OP is the only immidete family member exculded from the wedding party so she has a right to be upset.

In her place i simply would not go and not give a gift just a card.

LIVVI1234 · 10/11/2018 10:55

Ordinarily I would say you were being unreasonable BUT if she picked your cousins to be bridesmaids (who are not any closer to her than you are, in fact as cousins they will be much less close) I think I understand your point. It would be different if they were her cousins, but its super weird she asked her fiances cousins to be bridesmaids and not his sister (unless she was somehow friends with them)

PurpleDaisies · 10/11/2018 11:11

In her place i simply would not go and not give a gift just a card.

You really wouldn’t go to your own brother’s wedding because you were pissed of about not being asked to be a bridesmaid?

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe2726 · 10/11/2018 11:43

What do bridesmaids actually do? Little ones do nothing. Older ones don't do that much either beyond hen nights (apparently). Bride doesn't get to have free reign over all the wedding choices - and a decent person wouldn't allow a family member to be so obviously excluded.

OP speaks of a culture. Best find out what that is before we put our own 'stamp' on it.

Olderbyaminute · 10/11/2018 11:47

CostaCoffee I had my husband’s sister as a bridesmaid in our wedding as well my two sisters and a friend as MOH-I would be hurt as well

sweeneytoddsrazor · 10/11/2018 11:52

Instead of being oh so hurt why cant you all see it from a different angle. A reading is usually something important to the couple so words that havea special meaning delivered by someone special to the couple. I would regard that as an honour not a snub.