Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm so dumb...

192 replies

StupidSis · 10/11/2018 08:00

I chose my username because I know that I'm being stupid but my feelings are still very hurt. I don't know what to do about them.

My younger brother is getting married. I am 36 and he is 33. He has chosen his wedding party. I have 3 brothers in total. One of them is estranged and he would have been the best man if he was speaking to the rest of our family. The second brother is a groomsman. 2 of our cousins are a bridesmaid and a groomsman respectively. The other roles are filled out by friends.

I feel very hurt that I was not asked to be a bridesmaid or a groomswoman. I am the only sister and it's painful to see cousins were chosen for those roles ahead of me. At the last minute, I was given a role as a reader. It was also embarrassing to find out that I was not chosen to be a wedding party member in a very public way. My brother and his fiancee had a huge engagement party. They called up everyone who was involved in the wedding to the front of a large room in the restaurant where the party was held. Many of our close friends and relatives were whispering about the fact that I wasn't a bridesmaid. Our mother asked me if I was going to go up to the front when the wedding party members were called and I quietly informed our mother that I was a reader. I left the party soon after that.

I always thought that my brother and I were close. We usually got along well as kids and adults. I was always there for him in many ways. Years ago, my brother and fiancee were in a long distance relationship and he was very sad about her absence. I gave him plane fare and some spending money to go see her because I hated seeing my little brother in pain. I have always supported his relationship with his fiancee as well. My brother is always praising me to others because I am a "wonderful aunt" to his daughters.

My husband understands why I'm so hurt and so does the rest of our family. In our culture and our family, siblings are always in wedding parties unless there is an extenuating circumstance such as serious illness or feuds. My mother thinks that including one sibling and not the other was very rude and so was choosing cousins over a sister.

I do not even want to attend the wedding since I feel that my brother and his fiancee do not like me. Nevertheless, boycotting the wedding would cause more drama. My husband offered to plan a minibreak the same weekend of the wedding. On the invitations, we will specify that we will only attend the ceremony. A cousin of mine warned me that only attending the ceremony could lead to wagging tongues as well as upsetting my brother and his fiancee.

I greatly appreciate all who read this far. Once again, I know that I sound stupid and immature but I can't help how I feel. I have been quite sad about this for a few months. It hurts to find out that you aren't important to a close family member.

OP posts:
Godowneasy · 10/11/2018 08:57

36 is rather old to be a bridesmaid though isn't it?

I don't think it's reasonable to expect to be a maid of honour unless you and the the prospecctive bride are on a 'best friend' sort of level.

How old is the cousin who is going to be a bridesmaid- is she a lot younger, or a close friend of the bride?

SheWoreBlueVelvet · 10/11/2018 08:58

Agree you need ask why the cousin is bridesmaid - or do you already know? I take it she's a close long time friend of the bride then. I had a similar school friend who turned out to be a second cousin of the bloke I went out with in later life.
I'd put your exclusion down to gender roles - you should be a groomsman. The bride gets to chose whoever she counts as close. After that reader is pretty much the only other bit.

I would have been sad at the engagement party too but I'd just go to the wedding and have a great time eating and drinking with old family members. At the end of the day a bridesmaid is a nice dress and flowers and a headache organising a hen do.

MatildaTheCat · 10/11/2018 09:00

Talk to your brother.

It sounds painful for you but you get along and if you boycott his wedding that relationship will be soured forever and you will be cast as spiteful.

I would go, do the reading to the best of my ability and be gracious. Then go on a fabulous weekend with your dh the next weekend.

Have to say that being a bridesmaid is my idea of hell so I might not be on the same page.

bringbackthestripes · 10/11/2018 09:01

There aren’t really any traditional roles for sisters of the groom

^This. Are the cousins younger than you? As in children? I think it’s odd that you expect to be included tbh and awful that you would create drama that could potentially overshadow the bride and grooms special day.

florentina1 · 10/11/2018 09:04

I suspect that this has been done out of jealousy. The fiancé most likely feels threatened by your closeness to your brother and is try to ‘put you on you place’. I expect you will not feel the same about her in the future and. O body will blame you for that. I would pretend it did not matter just to maintain the closeness to your brother,

Fireba11 · 10/11/2018 09:08

I was bridesmaid at my older sister's wedding but when I mentioned to my mum about having her as one of my bridesmaids she said she was a bit old really and she was sure she'd much rather just enjoy the day without responsibility. As PP said, as you're older than you brother, he may have felt the same. Equally, as sister of the groom, there isn't a traditional role so I wouldn't automatically assume you would be bridesmaid (although it wouldn't be surprising if you were - I was at my brother's wedding, along with SIL's sister).

LordPickle · 10/11/2018 09:08

I wouldn't go. Why are you worried about causing drama when they have excluded you from the wedding? THEY have caused the issue. I wouldn't waste my time and would enjoy a mini-break with DH that weekend.

wombat1a · 10/11/2018 09:12

I think you have been remember and included, you are a reader. A the bride chooses her bridesmaids + most of the time bridesmaids are unmarried so there is no insult there. Groomswomen are still very very rare compared to groomsmen so there is no insult there.

If you're not really eligible for being a GW or a BM then what is left - Reader that's what and that's what you've got. Seems to me that they have done well to include you.

PurpleDaisies · 10/11/2018 09:12

Why are you worried about causing drama when they have excluded you from the wedding?

How? She is invited. She is a reader.

What role should she have?

MarthasGinYard · 10/11/2018 09:15

Are all the bridesmaids young though?

If so I wouldn't be to hurt TBH

My brothers both got married I wasn't a BM at either. They had younger Relatives and just SIL best friend.

I wouldn't have wanted to really be one though.

Greyponcho · 10/11/2018 09:17

Is it possible that they think that they wouldn’t want to bog you down with bridesmaids duties, that you’ve got better things to be spending your time on? Is it that bride and cousin are more aligned in their interests, perhaps where cousin would be able to plan a hen do she knows that bride would love?

ILiveInSalemsLot · 10/11/2018 09:17

Talk to your brother.
It’s natural that you feel hurt but don’t assume they dislike you.

Bellabonkers · 10/11/2018 09:20

As hard as it may be, personally I would paint on a big smile. Choose a lovely outfit for the wedding and do the reading with your head held high.

If there was any intentional snub do not give them the satisfaction of any reaction.
You will gain much respect by doing this and it will reflect badly on the bride and groom...not you.

easterholidays · 10/11/2018 09:20

Is your cousin unmarried? Some people feel that bridesmaids shouldn't be married, so it might be as simple as that. I do think you should just ask your brother what the thinking was, because if it's making you unhappy now it won't go away and the relationship will stay damaged. It sounds most likely to me that it's just mismatched expectations, rather than an intentional snub.

ButchyRestingFace · 10/11/2018 09:24

36 is rather old to be a bridesmaid though isn't it?

Why? Confused

Is a 36 yo not able to perform some bridesmaid's duties?

noenergy · 10/11/2018 09:27

To me a bridesmaid is the brides sisters, cousins or friends. A bit strange that your cousin was chosen to be one. Is she quite young? I think the age thing could be a part of it.

But if it is bothering you so much I would have a word with your brother. Don't let it simmer and cause bad feeling and end up spoiling the day for you.

Isthereeveranexcuse · 10/11/2018 09:29

Happened to me at my brother's wedding. Every other member of both families had a role, or a speech. Except for me. They all got given huge bunches of flowers on the day. None for me.

And I'm a photographer and did their wedding photos for free. And an album. And it never even got a mention.

Lesson learnt.

ButchyRestingFace · 10/11/2018 09:30

Asking two of your cousins to be bridesmaids and not you seems like a real snub to me. And a rather obvious one at that.

How do you usually get on with the bride?

ButchyRestingFace · 10/11/2018 09:32

Every other member of both families had a role, or a speech. Except for me. They all got given huge bunches of flowers on the day. None for me.

Did they at least say "thank you"?

Sounds like they somehow switched into seeing you as the hired help mode. Except they hadn't actually hired you as they weren't paying you.

People (can) suck. Sad

Isthereeveranexcuse · 10/11/2018 09:34

No, they didn't even say thank you.

It literally didn't get a mention.

I wasn't expecting to be bridesmaid or anything, because I said I'd do the photos but I did think when the flowers started to come out at the reception that I'd get a bunch.

I didn't.

I always thought I got on OK with his now wife as well, no rows or fall outs or anything.

Whisky2014 · 10/11/2018 09:36

It doesnt matter how old anyone is.
It's likely the brother chose the groomsmen and the bride chose the bridesmaid. They still included op to be a reader.
I think op is unreasonable.
And who gives a fudge about people's wagging tongues? They all sound pathetic and drama loving.

Frustratedmum78 · 10/11/2018 09:39

Urgh, families are rubbish at times. Usually the one who puts themselves out the most is the one who gets shat on.
Ask your DB, see what he has to say. It may be as someone else pointed out, that his DG is putting you in your place.

ButchyRestingFace · 10/11/2018 09:39

No, they didn't even say thank you.

It literally didn't get a mention.

Well, they sound rude and incredibly self-involved. But at least you know this now. I suppose it could only have been worse had they had the temerity to complain about the photos too! Grin

Weddings seems to bring out the worst in some people.

Isthereeveranexcuse · 10/11/2018 09:41

She counted the number of photos of each "side" in the album and I had one more of my side than her side and she made sure I was aware.

I had kept them roughly even but hadn't counted 50/50 it was literally just that there was a gorgeous one of one person on my side with my brother that I put in.

But hey she showed me what she thought of me and they have yet to say thank you either for the album or the cheque they got, given that it's 5 years ago I'm not holding my breath!

Dollymixture22 · 10/11/2018 09:42

Can’t offer any advice but I can see how this would be hurtful and embarrassing.