Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not invite one of 3 'best friends' to be bridesmaid?

114 replies

bridetobe89 · 13/09/2018 12:01

Firstly this does reference things like group chats and social media and on a few threads I've seen people mention anything like this there's been unhelpful responses calling them childish or whatever but I'm 24 and it's all relevant to the situation so please don't patronise me because I am genuinely concerned over this and don't want to hurt anyone's feelings.

I'm getting married next year, and I've been going over what to do in regards to my bridal party for months but can't seem to come to a conclusion.

I've known friend A in school and have been close ever since. I met friend B through uni two years ago, and we've been close ever since, I see and talk to her more than I do with friend A.

I introduced friends A & B as was planning a night out and wanted them to meet as my closest friends. I set up a group chat on Facebook where we all spoke for a couple of days prior just to sort of break the ice between them. They met and have been good friends ever since. The three of us kept in touch via the group chat and used it to arrange plans regularly.

Next we plan to go to a nearby city for a larger night out and get a hotel. Friend A invites her closest friend, Friend C. Neither me or friend B have ever met friend C but we add her to the group chat where we are making all the plans and all get on. We went out on the night out and had a good time.

Rather than making a new group chat we'd used the existing one and just added friend C, we used this chat most days so we continued to do so. This is where it gets a little awkward as it's now been well over a year of this group chat being used most days, Friend A & Friend C are still extremely close, however both Friend B and I have only met her twice more since that initial night out, but we are both close with Friend A. The group chat is still our main communication as we all live about 50 minutes apart etc, which the 4 of us are in.

Friend C is a nice girl, and frequently reposts photos of us from the few times we've met saying things like "miss my best friends" and refers to us as such frequently in the group chat and to other people etc. I guess I just feel awkward because I literally don't know her. If I ever want to post anything or plan anything with friend A & B I always ensure to include Friend C, as I don't want to be bitchy and look I'm leaving one person out.. but I don't know her?! Not really?!

I want Friend A & B to be in my bridal party, preferably with friend B as Maid of Honour and then friend A as a bridesmaid along with my sister. I just feel I'll look so nasty not asking Friend C? She's gotten upset in the past over such little things like me and Friend B tagging each other and Friend A in funny pictures on Facebook and not her (I know this sounds childish) and I know she'll take it personally.

I just feel strange having someone Ive met three times as my bridesmaid.. I feel slightly strange even inviting her to the wedding as I just do not feel like I know her at all. it's such a strange situation having someone call you their best friend when I only really seem them as an acquaintance and I've gone along with it for over a year just out of sheer awkwardness and not wanting to upset anyone.. but it just seems strange. I don't know if Friend B feels the same and don't want to ask in case I look catty. I dealt with lots of bitchy girls in school and don't want to be that girl Sad

OP posts:
TheCakeCrusader · 13/09/2018 13:31

You've stated that you are not that close or 'best friends' and you've only met her a few times. Just because she's proclaimed that you are her best friend on the WhatsApp group, doesn't mean that she is automatically a default bridesmaid at your wedding!

Don't feel guilty!

Mushroomsarehorrible · 13/09/2018 13:32

I only had my two oldest and best friends plus my sis as MoH at my wedding, I didn't ask some of my other close friends as that's what I wanted, for MY wedding.

Toughen up, OP.

Figgygal · 13/09/2018 13:36

Group chat and occasional nights out are one thing but expecting to be a BM is completely the other extreme ends of true and lasting freindships (well ideally anyway).

I am sure that isn't her expectation.

NoSquirrels · 13/09/2018 13:38

Everything that SE13 says. I'd also make sure I discussed it well with Friend A, and explain to her you really don't want to upset C, but you don't know her well enough to automatically include her in the bridal party as you really want your closest, oldest friends. But that of course C will be invited to hen do etc. Friend A should help manage C's reaction.

SuckOnTHATRyan · 13/09/2018 13:44

You’re overthinking. Your dp is right. Definitely weird to have her as bm out of politeness. I don’t imagine she’ll be expecting anything at all and if she is, well that’s life isn’t it? She isn’t a close friend as you’ve never met on your own and only three times total. Just ask friends A & B as planned.

TheWinterofOurDiscountTentsMk2 · 13/09/2018 13:44

I just feel strange having someone Ive met three times as my bridesmaid.. I feel slightly strange even inviting her to the wedding as I just do not feel like I know her at all

Well yeah it would be nuts,but then so is you describing someone you have met three times as one of your best friends! She's practically a stranger to you Confused

Ameliarose16 · 13/09/2018 13:46

The first thing I found in picking my bridal party was someone is always upset. I was MOH for a friend, was shocked she had asked as we weren't that close at the time... I asked my BF and my 3 sisters to be my BM and the friend who I was MOH is no longer speaking to me and didn't even come to the wedding. She was involved in other ways. I asked other close friends to do stuff such as be our witness or do a reading.... I don't think friend C should get this though, also her posting all these posts on fb is because fb is just a lie, shes trying to make herself more interesting etc...

bridetobe89 · 13/09/2018 13:47

I haven't checked what friend A or B would think about this as want to ask in person, if I message them to ask what they think it'll ruin that.

Wish this whole thing wasn't so stressful! Already feel awkward how Friend A is going to react when Ask Friend B to be Maid of Honour as I've known Friend A 10+ years longer than B.. worried she'll be even more unhappy if it then looks like I'm leaving our friend C. I do need to toughen up, this day is for me and DH I just overthink all these things Blush

OP posts:
KarmaStar · 13/09/2018 13:49

Hi op,as they say, "your wedding,your way"and it is exactly that,your very special day and you don't owe anyone anything.friend C is not a friend of yours and if you feel you would like her at the wedding then invite her but don't do it because you don't want to upset anyone.
Imho,I'd suggest inviting her to the evening part of you are having one.
This day will go by in a flash and you will have many happy memories,enjoy it and don't worry for a second about this other lady.she is an adult ,she should be able to see your acquaintances for what it is.If she doesn't,it's her issue not yours.
If you feel the need to justify your choice(which you dont)you have the fall back of limited numbers and cost.
Have a wonderful,magical day Flowers

flowery · 13/09/2018 13:51

”Already feel awkward how Friend A is going to react when Ask Friend B to be Maid of Honour”

Don’t have a maid of honour then! Why do you need one?

SuckOnTHATRyan · 13/09/2018 13:51

I haven't checked what friend A or B would think about this as want to ask in person, if I message them to ask what they think it'll ruin that.

Check when you ask them? Or phone them?

You’re definitely blowing this out of proportion a little bit. It’s only being bm! Lovely to be asked (usually Grin), but not life changing. It’s all fine. Enjoy your engagement and relax a bit if you can!

NoSquirrels · 13/09/2018 13:52

What flowery said. Make your sister MoH. Job done.

SuckOnTHATRyan · 13/09/2018 13:52

I also agree with flowery, just have two bms. No need for a MoH at all.

SuckOnTHATRyan · 13/09/2018 13:53

Oh sorry forgot the sister. Of course she should be MoH! She’s your sister. Or at least that’s how it works among my friends and family, but maybe you aren’t that close.

Feefeetrixabelle · 13/09/2018 13:55

I think you may be overthinking things. It’s ok to not have her in your bridal party are you going to invite her to the evening part?

Maybe she is a bit lonely if you like her why not arrange a few more meet ups? Like you said you know what’s it’s like to feel left out so if you like her then make an effort. If you don’t just set up a new WhatsApp just for bridal party stuff and let the other group die out.

0hCrepe · 13/09/2018 13:57

She does sound a bit clingy but of course she wouldn’t be your bridesmaid! If she did question you (which would be weird) just be ready to say I’ve known A&B years, I know you’re great friends with A/B but I’ve met you 3 times! No apologies.
Also set up a second WhatsApp group with just a and b and yes both.

0hCrepe · 13/09/2018 13:58

*use both

theymademejoin · 13/09/2018 13:59

Definitely don't ask her to be a bridesmaid. An evening invitation would be kind.

On a different note, you said you were concerned about friend A being hurt if friend B is moh. Would you not ask your sister to be moh then? It's not like there's really any difference in the roles other than a title and signing the register as a witness.

wafflyversatile · 13/09/2018 14:02

I thought bridesmaids were unmarried and maids of honour married.

Putting up group photos with reference to besties or whatever doesn't mean they think everyone is their equal friend. Hopefully...

Does she meet up with friend A separately from you? If so she surely must understand that you are not all equal friends.

You could always just have your sister as bridesmaid. No rule saying you need to have more than 1.

Ngaio2 · 13/09/2018 14:03

You definitely need to have a quiet word with A re C. Just explain your reasoning as you have here and tell her you’re worried that because C is rather sensitive that she may feel hurt. Then if C says anything to A, A will have a ready reply for her.
If the numbers allow invite C to the wedding. It seems she’ll be around for sometime and will be a closer friend in the future.

bridetobe89 · 13/09/2018 14:06

I was asking friend B to be MOH as she is 100% my closest friend, I have 2 sisters so planned to make them both BM but my eldest sister doesn't want to be as she's 15 years older than me and said she'd feel silly. I'm not that close to sisters however they are best friends with each other and were each other's MOH.

OP posts:
WhitefriarsDillyDuck · 13/09/2018 14:06

Just don't have adult bridesmaids, in my opinion (note that phrase before you all jump on me) there is always something slightly tacky about it. Much better to have children .

bridetobe89 · 13/09/2018 14:08

@WhitefriarsDillyDuck Only female children in both families are currently 2 months & 14 months so won't really work! Or I definitely would have.

OP posts:
Newtothis2017 · 13/09/2018 14:09

I had my 2 best friends as my bridesmaids. I never said one of them was moh and they never asked. And I think traditionally the moh is married

Mugglemom · 13/09/2018 14:11

Your bridal party isn't the time to be appeasing people's feelings.

It's your day. Have friends A and B. Friend C can build a bridge and get over it.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread