Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think it’s appropriate for adolescents to be sentenced to life without parole? **MNHQ WARNING details of murder mentioned**

127 replies

Frosty6611 · 15/08/2018 08:34

Was watching an interesting documentary recently about a 14 year old in America who got a life without parole sentence for stabbing someone to death. The crime was really brutal and he definitely needed to be punished harshly for it, but I couldn’t help thinking that not giving him the chance to ever move beyond what he’s done is a bit much?
Sentencing in the UK is pitiful (the Jamie Bulger case is one that sticks out in my mind - even though the boys were very young when they murdered him, they still shouldn’t have been let out when they were).
It seems to me like America is sometimes too harsh with their sentencing and the UK are too lenient

OP posts:
Birdinthetree · 17/08/2018 00:42

I think people are either adults or they are kids - maybe their maturity or their life experiences need to be rakenjnti account but IMO not the crime. They makes crime as s child tgry are tried as a child.
Lots of people on this forum have protested at the thought of seeing evening 18 as adults. They are still behaving like immature adults - we all know this, they are victims too!

AgathaMystery · 17/08/2018 00:59

God it's really emotive and very much down to the individual crime.

I think it's interesting that the OP mentions Jon Venables in their post. The 2 convicted murderer served 8 years and were released. One lives a quiet life with a long term partner & one is back in prison for accessing thousands of indecent images of child abuse. What's really interesting is how much we, as a nation, hate them.

We do. I think we hate them because we know their names. We saw their mugshots and we know their names. So no sentence will ever, ever be long enough.

Apparently the last time Jon Venables was caught with images the David Blunkett was 'mildly surprised' that his own parole officers had breached JV's conditions of release but not providing regular access to psychiatric help.

It beggars belief.

A few years ago in Norway (I think it was a Norway, maybe 10 yrs ago) 2 little boys aged 5 & 6 murdered a 6yr old girl. They were not named & were back in Kindergarten a week or so later. It didn't even make the news here. They were immediately started on long term rehabilitation & cannot be hate figures because hardly anyone knows their name and what they look like.

I guess my point is, we can't have it both ways. We can't name and photograph violent child murderers, imprison them, tell them that lying and violence is wrong & then upon their release build them a legend, give them a new identity and make them lie to everyone they ever meet. Forever.

It's asking the almost impossible. Very few have managed it. I can only think of Mary Bell and Robert Thompson.

We are very backward in the U.K. with the age of accountability.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page