Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is taking the piss

122 replies

user1471432735 · 17/02/2018 12:14

DH and I have been together 18 years, married 11.

Relationship with inlaws has had its ups and downs, we are very, very different people. I think they would much prefer a quiet housewife who had babies and "let" DH live in his hometown so we could rely on PIL's for their sage wisdom and input into every piece of our life (like my SIL, basically)

Instead I'm what my PIL's call a "career woman" I work in senior management and travel quite a bit. We've never discussed it with them, but I earn about 3x what DH does and we live in major city, about three hours away and are not planning on having children. DH is very happy with this arrangement, he moved out of hometown the moment he left high school, but based on many comments and behaviour over the years, its clear that PIL think I'm forcing it all on him and preventing him from being happy.

They're also incredibly disorganized and always late. It's not uncommon for them to turn up more than an hour after the agreed time or to attempt to do all the Christmas dinner shopping at 5pm on Christmas Eve and be incredulous when there are no turkeys or puddings left. I'm very organised, potentially a little too rigid with timing and planning and the disconnect has lead to some frustrations over the years.

When I was younger I used to take it personally, but mostly I just accept that rather than being malicious and cruel they are disorganized and thoughtless.

Mostly I just go with the flow and we see them about 5 times a year, which I use ally nudge DH to organise.

The one thing that stings a little bit is that they never remember my birthday. In the 18 years we have been together, I'd guess that they've acknowledged it maybe 5 times. Once was my 21st and another was because it happened to be three days before we got married. On the other occasions it's only been due to DH orchestrating it, and I told him that although I appreciated it, it was very uncomfortable knowing that they'd been forced to call me.

I don't expect presents or a card or a fuss or even a phone call. A text of FB message would suffice, to show that they acknowledge the existence of the woman who has been with their son for almost half his life and made him (mostly happy)

Anyway, this year they forgot by birthday again. DH called them a week after and told them (again) how disappointed and hurt he is that they don't even make an effort and they murmured some weak apologies, but haven't bothered to get in touch. My birthday is early January (so they've had time since DH spoke to them)

Normally this would just be what it is, but this week DH was talking to his mum to get more info on the plans for his dads 70th early next month. We were told in November to put the date aside but have had no further info since and given their track record and the fact that we'll need to travel, book accommodation and pet sitters, we needed to know what was planned (if anything)

Turns out the party is going ahead for 50 people at the village hall. Caterers have been booked etc

But. MIL asked DH to ask me if I would make the cake.

For 50 people

For a man who hasn't spoken to me since Christmas Eve and ignored my birthday.

MIL didn't ask me, because that might be awkward, given she also hasn't spoken to me since Xmas or acknowledged my birthday and she likes to pretend something hasn't happened if she's in the wrong or might be embarrassed.

Apparently they thought it might be nice for me to do. Because wives make cakes

(Actually I do enjoy baking and have made cakes for friends, but they've asked me directly or I've offered and they treat me like I exist and remember my birthday)

DH pointed out that
A) she should ask me herself
B) while she's at it, she should maybe apologize for forgetting my birthday
C) giving someone who works 50+ hours and has three OS business trips in the next few weeks, three weeks notice to make a cake for 50 people when the party is 3 hours away from that persons kitchen, is.... a bit shit.

At this point MIL had to finish the call as something very incredibly urgent had just come up. We haven't heard back

In the interests of being the bigger person, I will make the cake, as they're my DH's parents and I don't want more awkwardness to limit their already distant relationship, because then DH would feel guilty.

But I'm allowed to think that this is slightly taking the piss, right?

OP posts:
RJnomore1 · 17/02/2018 15:42

See I would make the most amazing cake too...

I enjoy a bit of smugness. I realise it's one of my less desirable qualities TBH.

callmekitten · 17/02/2018 15:48

The birthday thing wouldn't really bother me. Some people make a fuss about birthdays and some don't. They do seem rather self-centered though and that is not cool. But, they will be in your life and are not likely to change at this point so I would just try to stop wasting my emotional energy on them. Behave toward them in a way that you can be proud of and that is in line with your character, not in a way that is just to retaliate.

TheDevilMadeMeDoIt · 17/02/2018 15:55

I would probably have gone the 'absolutely bloody amazing cake' route myself, just for my own satisfaction.

But AnnieAnoniMouse has made a point I hadn't thought of that seems extremely important now I've read it. Your DH stood up to his mother on your behalf. If you make the cake, for whatever good reasons you think you have, you will be undermining him enormously.

He set it as a condition that MiL had to ask you herself. Show him support, show her that you and DH stand together. Don't make the cake unless she asks you directly.

HermioneWeasley · 17/02/2018 15:57

I agree they are handing you a golden PR opportunity. Be fabulous and give them no ammunition. Their friends will be telling them how talented and thoughtful you are and it will kill them.

Ellendegeneres · 17/02/2018 15:58

charalois or whatever your user name is, suppose you’d be saying the same to a poster who said they were unable to have dc, right? Course. Cause you’re that poster who is a little prick and likes to go against the stream for a bit of an ego boost for you.

Op you’re brilliant. Quite simply brilliant. Please write the name spelled wrong though 😂😂

Aeroflotgirl · 17/02/2018 16:00

I woulden't make the cake, just because they are your in laws, does not mean you have to be treated badly.

Just off the record, do you remember her birthday?

UrADaisyIfUDo · 17/02/2018 16:12

I love baking but for people who actually care about me, I'd never bake anything for such selfish, thoughtless people as your in-laws.

Aeroflotgirl · 17/02/2018 16:42

Oh god charalois aren't you a little gem. How's the 1950s btw. How do you know op is not able to have children or can have them! Very insensitive and nasty remarks, anyway, not everyone has to have kids, its not a right.

TheStoic · 17/02/2018 16:43

Don’t be a martyr, OP.

AJPTaylor · 17/02/2018 16:50

Just get dh to order it and let everyone you assume you made it

LizB62A · 17/02/2018 17:28

Wait for your MIL to ask you
Make the cake
Charge them for the ingredients and your labour

They clearly don't treat you as family, why should you treat them as family?

PuppyMonkey · 17/02/2018 17:39

All the party guests will just think “oh CF in laws are so adored by all the family, look at the lovely cake DIL made.”

That’s not good PR for you OP.

Ohyesiam · 17/02/2018 21:02

I've only read the op.
Your husband sounds lovely.
I would say no to making the cake, and I'm quite a push over.

In the bigger scheme, I'd let go if expecting anything for my birthday, but maybe you have, and your just saying it to illustrate what a piss take it is to then expect you to bake.

SundaysFunday · 17/02/2018 21:17

@Charolais what nasty and bitter post.

user1471432735 · 17/02/2018 21:23

What an interesting array of messages to wake up to. Thank you for being my online therapy and sounding board

DH and I have agreed that I will only make the cake if they ask.

I like making cakes and take pride in them, so this is a way for me to be recognized for doing something good. Not by them, but in front of them... which I don't get many opportunities at.

Yes, we remember and acknowledge their birthdays etc. We see them five time a year (ish) because those are the times that we organisé. Left to them, it might be once a year but we're trying to be the better people.

They don't walk all over us. We have (mostly) pretty firm boundaries and do things on our terms, but try not to see other people being twats as a reason for us to be.

To the delightful poster who attributed my lack of reproduction as their excuse, if that was the case I would have nothing to do with them, or anyone who thought that was a legitimate way to treat someone. Fuck, are you trying to be the most odious person in the world? Shall I make you a special cake.

As posted previously, I'm not after a fuss. Not looking for presents or cards or parties or even a bloody phone call. A text message or Facebook would be lovely - Just to show that they can be arsed to remember this tiny detail about the person their son has spent 18 years with. And normally I don't care, but when it's followed by a request to make a birthday cake, I think it's a bit ordinary.

I think it's MIL's incredibly dysfunctional way of trying to involve me. It's the only thing I'm good at that she understands... but her execution and context is very very awkward (like her)

If i believed they were doing it to be deliberately mean or spiteful it would be a different scenario, but they really are just self centered and this daft.

I've also realized that there are two family weddings this year, so it will nice to have brownie points from the other friends and family ahead of that...

So, selfish and inconsiderate, absolutely, but it's an opportunity for me to make it work for me. But only if she asks...

OP posts:
petbear · 17/02/2018 21:27

@charolais post is hilarious.

You ONLY see them 5 times a year so no wonder they forget your birthday! The OP doesn't forget THEIRS though. Hmm

And they don't like her coz of the disappointment of her not providing a grandchild.

Jesus fucking wept.

Pay no attention OP. Almost everyone is on your side!

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 18/02/2018 09:47

Good, I think you've done the right thing to back off with the cake unless she asks. It was a very good point that you would have undermined your DH if you had just made it anyway, and also a very good point that, if they don't ask, they might just get one from elsewhere anyway.

I still think you should make one for yourself with "Happy Belated Birthday to Me" on it though...

TheEgregiousPeach · 18/02/2018 10:19

you're a bigger disappointment for not giving them grandchildren 😂😂

Don't be dim Charolais. What a daft comment. No one is under any obligation to provide children for their in laws. I wouldn't provide cake for these buggers, let alone feel obliged to provide grandchildren.

Blackteadrinker77 · 18/02/2018 10:35

*You are being very petty with your disappointed about them forgetting your birthday when you are a bigger disappointment to them for not giving them grandchildren. If they had your attitude, it would be just you and your dogs.......or probably a herd of cats.

You see them 5 times a year and then wonder why they forget your birthday.

I think we are getting our 'cheeky fuckers' mixed up.

Good luck getting your dogs to remember your birthday*

Ouch, the 1950s are calling.

Thankfully women get a choice.

hazell42 · 18/02/2018 10:43

Actually i think you are being a but precious. You say that they are a bit disorganised and not really birthday oriented. Is disorganised a euphemism for laid back and carefree? Disorganised ia not a crime you know. Forgetting to fb you on your birthday is not the end of the world. They seem to be disorganised in the whole of their life not just with you. Which is their prerogative. They dont have to do things your way. If you dont want to make the cake politely decline with excuses of overwork and go to the party and toast your fils health. Get over yourself maybe.

CheekyRedhead · 18/02/2018 10:43

You are being very petty with your disappointed about them forgetting your birthday when you are p bigger disappointment to them for not giving them grandchildren

^ Wow. Not everyone wants kids. To blame a poor relationship on lack of giving grandchildren is disgusting.

CheekyRedhead · 18/02/2018 10:44

Sorry don't know how to do bold

New posts on this thread. Refresh page