Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is taking the piss

122 replies

user1471432735 · 17/02/2018 12:14

DH and I have been together 18 years, married 11.

Relationship with inlaws has had its ups and downs, we are very, very different people. I think they would much prefer a quiet housewife who had babies and "let" DH live in his hometown so we could rely on PIL's for their sage wisdom and input into every piece of our life (like my SIL, basically)

Instead I'm what my PIL's call a "career woman" I work in senior management and travel quite a bit. We've never discussed it with them, but I earn about 3x what DH does and we live in major city, about three hours away and are not planning on having children. DH is very happy with this arrangement, he moved out of hometown the moment he left high school, but based on many comments and behaviour over the years, its clear that PIL think I'm forcing it all on him and preventing him from being happy.

They're also incredibly disorganized and always late. It's not uncommon for them to turn up more than an hour after the agreed time or to attempt to do all the Christmas dinner shopping at 5pm on Christmas Eve and be incredulous when there are no turkeys or puddings left. I'm very organised, potentially a little too rigid with timing and planning and the disconnect has lead to some frustrations over the years.

When I was younger I used to take it personally, but mostly I just accept that rather than being malicious and cruel they are disorganized and thoughtless.

Mostly I just go with the flow and we see them about 5 times a year, which I use ally nudge DH to organise.

The one thing that stings a little bit is that they never remember my birthday. In the 18 years we have been together, I'd guess that they've acknowledged it maybe 5 times. Once was my 21st and another was because it happened to be three days before we got married. On the other occasions it's only been due to DH orchestrating it, and I told him that although I appreciated it, it was very uncomfortable knowing that they'd been forced to call me.

I don't expect presents or a card or a fuss or even a phone call. A text of FB message would suffice, to show that they acknowledge the existence of the woman who has been with their son for almost half his life and made him (mostly happy)

Anyway, this year they forgot by birthday again. DH called them a week after and told them (again) how disappointed and hurt he is that they don't even make an effort and they murmured some weak apologies, but haven't bothered to get in touch. My birthday is early January (so they've had time since DH spoke to them)

Normally this would just be what it is, but this week DH was talking to his mum to get more info on the plans for his dads 70th early next month. We were told in November to put the date aside but have had no further info since and given their track record and the fact that we'll need to travel, book accommodation and pet sitters, we needed to know what was planned (if anything)

Turns out the party is going ahead for 50 people at the village hall. Caterers have been booked etc

But. MIL asked DH to ask me if I would make the cake.

For 50 people

For a man who hasn't spoken to me since Christmas Eve and ignored my birthday.

MIL didn't ask me, because that might be awkward, given she also hasn't spoken to me since Xmas or acknowledged my birthday and she likes to pretend something hasn't happened if she's in the wrong or might be embarrassed.

Apparently they thought it might be nice for me to do. Because wives make cakes

(Actually I do enjoy baking and have made cakes for friends, but they've asked me directly or I've offered and they treat me like I exist and remember my birthday)

DH pointed out that
A) she should ask me herself
B) while she's at it, she should maybe apologize for forgetting my birthday
C) giving someone who works 50+ hours and has three OS business trips in the next few weeks, three weeks notice to make a cake for 50 people when the party is 3 hours away from that persons kitchen, is.... a bit shit.

At this point MIL had to finish the call as something very incredibly urgent had just come up. We haven't heard back

In the interests of being the bigger person, I will make the cake, as they're my DH's parents and I don't want more awkwardness to limit their already distant relationship, because then DH would feel guilty.

But I'm allowed to think that this is slightly taking the piss, right?

OP posts:
MichaelBendfaster · 17/02/2018 13:10

I don't think you can continue to moan about them if you continue rewarding their behaviour by doing things like making giant cakes on request.

They do sound like a pair of twunts though. I wouldn't bother with them at all, personally, and certainly wouldn't 'nudge DH to organise' seeing them.

Fuck em.

But, again, YABU to make the cake.

Lobsterquadrille2 · 17/02/2018 13:11

I'm with OP - who sounds like a complete perfectionist in most areas of her life - if a thing's worth doing etc. I'd make a fantastic cake, thereby proving that successful career women can pull off just about anything if they choose to do so. Then I'd hang around near PILs at the party and to any compliment offered with regard to the cake, I'd maintain a very modest expression but "thank you so much, I'm so glad you liked it" to the guests.

Sprinklestar · 17/02/2018 13:18

Your choice but I wouldn’t bother. In fact, I likely wouldn’t go to the party, either. Where’s your DH in all this? Why isn’t he making the cake?

Paperdolly · 17/02/2018 13:18

A hash cake perhaps? Then all would be chilled and/or giggly at the bit of a do. 😊

LanaorAna2 · 17/02/2018 13:20

OP, it takes guts and strength to be as nice as you are. Hope you enjoy the party.

DeathStare · 17/02/2018 13:23

In that case OP when you hand it over, I'd at least say.... "Do you know I completely forgot about making your cake? Only remembered last night.DH said you would completely understand and wouldn't mind in the slightest seeing as you often forget other people birthdays, but I couldn't let you down like that so I stayed up all night"

eddielizzard · 17/02/2018 13:23

wow your pil are dicks. miserly, begrudging dicks. they're missing out of course, because life could be so much nicer.

you're right to make the cake, as you'll get mega brownie points even if it is everyone BUT the twerps you made it for. it's almost like your mil is trying to get you to be as horrible to her as she is to you, so that she can point and say 'see???!'. don't give her the ammunition.

and i'd stop prodding your dh to get in contact with them. i've stopped doing that with my dh and life is so much nicer.

GracielaSabrocita · 17/02/2018 13:25

I don't think you're doing anyone any favours by making the cake, and it would be far better for all if you refused. By making it you're endorsing their behaviour towards you.

You can't do it and are not willing to discuss it further. Let them work out for themselves (which could take a long time and might not happen) why not. You owe them nothing except a polite but short refusal.

ReanimatedSGB · 17/02/2018 13:26

I think you're right to make the cake - you clearly enjoy making cakes (not taking the mickey, I am just not a baking person myself and would not know where to start with making a cake) and you will get to enjoy the moral high ground.

I'm a bit sorry for your H who is clearly more upset by the constant needling of his silly, bigoted, small-minded family than you are. But at least you can keep to fairly low contact with them.

GracielaSabrocita · 17/02/2018 13:26

However I would attend the event, and bring a card and a modest but pleasant present.

Nikephorus · 17/02/2018 13:34

I'm not actually the bigger person, I'm just better at the PR.
Grin

Nikephorus · 17/02/2018 13:38

I'd go with the cake, and a BIG card, and a birthday balloon and beautifully-wrapped present. Then when you hand it over say 'I know you don't bother much with other people's birthdays but personally I like to make an effort', smile sweetly and enjoy their discomfort. Everyone else will be awarding you brownie points for putting so much effort in to it (excellent PR!), they'll know you're making a point.

CiderwithBuda · 17/02/2018 13:41

Hmm. I think asking you to make the cake by asking your DH to ask you is a passive aggressive way of putting you in the mold they want you to be in. The little wife who does as her husband asks - bakes cakes. Not the career woman that you are. And it sends a message to everyone at the party that you are the little woman at home who makes cakes.

You've walked right into it.

pasturesgreen · 17/02/2018 13:41

Hell would freeze over before I made that cake.

Taking the moral high ground is all well and good, but I suspect they'll only take it as validation of their horrid, spiteful behaviour.

petbear · 17/02/2018 13:41

Hi @user1471432735

You poor thing I feel sorry for you. Sad

I would much rather have you as a mate than your twatty in-laws. How rude and nasty they sound. (Disorganised and thoughtless my arse, they are just roooooooood! Your FIL has not spoken to you for 2 months!) Hmm

Love the way yooooou get the blame for you and your DH not having babies. I mean do they not think for a fleeting second that your DH wants none either?!

Dunno what to suggest except hold your head high, and treat them as they treat you. And don't make the cake. I feel like your DH should be having much more of a go at them sorry. My DH would have gone batshit if his folks had treated me like this.

I am quite lucky, my in-laws actually always liked me. But I do know a number of women where their in laws are quite vile to them.

I do think your DH needs to have a go at them ... sorry if I am speaking out of line there..... JMO.

I wonder if their ire towards you is coz you (and DH) don't want babies, and they blame you?

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/02/2018 13:44

Ok you’re making the cake. Why do you care about getting brownie points from people, who struggle to acknowledge your existence and are purposefully rude?

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 17/02/2018 13:45

Ooo, ooo, I know - make the cake, but make yourself a cake as well and take it with you - with a "Happy Belated Birthday to our talented DIL" iced on it!

G'wan.

You are nice though - albeit because you don't want to give them any excuse - I'd be very anti making them a cake after their behaviour.

BitOutOfPractice · 17/02/2018 13:48

Yes, it's taking the piss. Just buy one from a bakery local to your in laws. It's not worth dying in this particular hill I don't think. You won't change them now

Mix56 · 17/02/2018 13:53

um Hang on So far she hasn't asked you to make a cake. She asked OH & he said for her to apologise ask you. She hasn't.
Please don't make a fabulous cake, only for her to provide a 2nd one & leave yours in the box.
Just don't plan it or make it until she asks you.

Itsbecauseimaleo · 17/02/2018 13:55

You are by far a better woman than I am. I would be fuming! I probably wouldn't make the cake. If I did then I'd most likely lace it with laxatives

MotherofTerriers · 17/02/2018 13:56

Hmm, there are some fantastic small business cake makers - often advertising on facebook. I'd buy one and claim I made it. They won't know, it will look lovely so you get the complements and you don't have to waste any time on them

Mix56 · 17/02/2018 13:58

Apparently they thought it might be nice for me to do. Because wives make cakes that is so PA !!! Stupid Stupid woman.
I would wait for her to ask me, then say, NOPE, too busy being a shit hot high flying Carreeeeer Superwoman

LannieDuck · 17/02/2018 13:59

I would suggest that DH make the cake. They're his parents, afterall. Why should baking = wifework?

I know you've said you'll do it... I just hate gender stereotyping.

GratedCarrotStick · 17/02/2018 14:00

I would order it from the local bakery and tell him that was his birthday present.

Otterseatpuffinsdontthey · 17/02/2018 14:02

Checking spelling - back in a miniute!.Smile