Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is taking the piss

122 replies

user1471432735 · 17/02/2018 12:14

DH and I have been together 18 years, married 11.

Relationship with inlaws has had its ups and downs, we are very, very different people. I think they would much prefer a quiet housewife who had babies and "let" DH live in his hometown so we could rely on PIL's for their sage wisdom and input into every piece of our life (like my SIL, basically)

Instead I'm what my PIL's call a "career woman" I work in senior management and travel quite a bit. We've never discussed it with them, but I earn about 3x what DH does and we live in major city, about three hours away and are not planning on having children. DH is very happy with this arrangement, he moved out of hometown the moment he left high school, but based on many comments and behaviour over the years, its clear that PIL think I'm forcing it all on him and preventing him from being happy.

They're also incredibly disorganized and always late. It's not uncommon for them to turn up more than an hour after the agreed time or to attempt to do all the Christmas dinner shopping at 5pm on Christmas Eve and be incredulous when there are no turkeys or puddings left. I'm very organised, potentially a little too rigid with timing and planning and the disconnect has lead to some frustrations over the years.

When I was younger I used to take it personally, but mostly I just accept that rather than being malicious and cruel they are disorganized and thoughtless.

Mostly I just go with the flow and we see them about 5 times a year, which I use ally nudge DH to organise.

The one thing that stings a little bit is that they never remember my birthday. In the 18 years we have been together, I'd guess that they've acknowledged it maybe 5 times. Once was my 21st and another was because it happened to be three days before we got married. On the other occasions it's only been due to DH orchestrating it, and I told him that although I appreciated it, it was very uncomfortable knowing that they'd been forced to call me.

I don't expect presents or a card or a fuss or even a phone call. A text of FB message would suffice, to show that they acknowledge the existence of the woman who has been with their son for almost half his life and made him (mostly happy)

Anyway, this year they forgot by birthday again. DH called them a week after and told them (again) how disappointed and hurt he is that they don't even make an effort and they murmured some weak apologies, but haven't bothered to get in touch. My birthday is early January (so they've had time since DH spoke to them)

Normally this would just be what it is, but this week DH was talking to his mum to get more info on the plans for his dads 70th early next month. We were told in November to put the date aside but have had no further info since and given their track record and the fact that we'll need to travel, book accommodation and pet sitters, we needed to know what was planned (if anything)

Turns out the party is going ahead for 50 people at the village hall. Caterers have been booked etc

But. MIL asked DH to ask me if I would make the cake.

For 50 people

For a man who hasn't spoken to me since Christmas Eve and ignored my birthday.

MIL didn't ask me, because that might be awkward, given she also hasn't spoken to me since Xmas or acknowledged my birthday and she likes to pretend something hasn't happened if she's in the wrong or might be embarrassed.

Apparently they thought it might be nice for me to do. Because wives make cakes

(Actually I do enjoy baking and have made cakes for friends, but they've asked me directly or I've offered and they treat me like I exist and remember my birthday)

DH pointed out that
A) she should ask me herself
B) while she's at it, she should maybe apologize for forgetting my birthday
C) giving someone who works 50+ hours and has three OS business trips in the next few weeks, three weeks notice to make a cake for 50 people when the party is 3 hours away from that persons kitchen, is.... a bit shit.

At this point MIL had to finish the call as something very incredibly urgent had just come up. We haven't heard back

In the interests of being the bigger person, I will make the cake, as they're my DH's parents and I don't want more awkwardness to limit their already distant relationship, because then DH would feel guilty.

But I'm allowed to think that this is slightly taking the piss, right?

OP posts:
user1471432735 · 17/02/2018 12:40

You're all making me laugh! Thank you!

OP posts:
Bitsy1968 · 17/02/2018 12:40

I'd buy a couple of plain cakes (maybe a fruit cake and a sponge cake?) and then decorate them. Roll out icing, perhaps using colours to "marble" it, draped over the top and some sort of topper. I certainly wouldn't spend a fortune and hours of my time making the bases. Give myself an hour or two for the icing and decoration and then call it a day. It's enough to make me feel i've done my bit, but not so much that I'd feel resentful. It's not likely to be acknowledged, is it? That would sting if I'd put a ton of effort in....

hmmwhatatodo · 17/02/2018 12:41

Buy a couple of Tesco chocolate tray bakes, shove it on the side as you walk in (still wrapped in plastic bags) and say you didn’t have time if they say anything about it.

Might they be Hoping you go out and buy a super fancy cake since they know you don’t have time but also have a good job?

Zaphodsotherhead · 17/02/2018 12:43

www.cakewrecks.com/

Get some inspiration. I also go along with mildly misspelling his name...

DeathStare · 17/02/2018 12:46

I wouldn't make the cake.... unless I was asked directly.

I would get DH to play them at their own game and say to them next time he speaks to them "Don't forget that if you want DW to make the cake you will need to call her and speak to her about what it is you want in plenty of time. I'm terribly disorganised and keep forgetting to mention it to her myself. "

If they leave it until the last minute to phone you..... "Oh gosh. It really is the last minute now. I'd have loved to have made it, if only you'd have phoned me sooner" (and then make it anyway if you want to)

Chugalug · 17/02/2018 12:46

Don't ,for the love of god, make that cake ..just dont

Caselgarcia · 17/02/2018 12:46

I'd make the cake and spell FIL's name wrong on it or put Happy 75th on it.

hmmwhatatodo · 17/02/2018 12:47

Actually no, make a plain sponge cake, leave it sitting on the side for a few days so it goes a bit dry then cover it in jam and rolled out icing but make sure it’s a bit creased and wonky and stretched where it wouldn’t quite fit, then when you’re going round the bottom to neaten it, take a bit too much off in some places and not enough in others. Then write happy birthday in those ready made icing things you get at the supermarket in packs of red yellow black and green that need muscles like the hulk to squeeze anything out. And look really pleased with yourself!

WorraLiberty · 17/02/2018 12:47

Bloody hell that took quite some reading only to discover you're going to bake it anyway.

"Sorry, I don't have time" is really all that needs to be said if you want to keep the peace.

user1471432735 · 17/02/2018 12:47

I know they're not going to suddenly have a road to Damascus conversion on the basis of a nice cake. My cakes are good but they're not magical.

It will cause them a bit of discomfort to have to acknowledge or at the very least, be party to other people acknowledging what I've done

That will blow their programming a little bit.

I'm staying at a friend's house (we don't stay with them, due to about 98 reasons) and will bake the cake the day before and ice it in the morning at my friend's place.

I've got a tin that will do the job and some leftover cake boards and decorations etc from a previous project that will work nicely.

As I said, I'm really not that nice, this is an easy win and I get some good PIL's are dickheads venting material for my next wine catch up with friends.

OP posts:
HeartOfSass · 17/02/2018 12:48

No way would I be making that cake personally under those circumstances. You will not get an acknowledgement, they will probably delight in having got you to spend your time in the kitchen rather than appreciating the gesture. There's nothing nice in the asking, it's not like they have this family bond with you so your FIL would really love it being made by you. Additionally it's saving them money to not stump up for a decorative cake that big.

I would have the cake made and give that as your gift to FIL. Make it clear that it's been made by a company and not by yourself. (get them to put it in a branded box or with a company label or sticker on it).

Seriously, I really think they are asking you as a passive aggressive strike and will lap up the thought of you fuming whilst you bake it out of duty. Then they will definitely heap coals on the fire by not appreciating it. Don't do it to yourself.

Birdsgottafly · 17/02/2018 12:48

"I fantasize about spitting in it or letting my dog lick the spoon (before I start) but I'm too much of a chicken/perfectionist."

Well that's disgusting, you're PILs won't be the only ones eating the cake. They are inconsiderate, not abusive etc, so if your DH would be apply with that, you need to go NC.

Personally, I wouldn't make the cake, the size etc, won't travel well and a 70th is a special occasion, so it needs a decent cake.

Is your DH happy that his 70 year old Father isn't getting a present and you're planning a Costco cake?

user1471432735 · 17/02/2018 12:49

Yeah, I know it's quite a read but this is much cheaper than therapy and I do Enjoy using 50 words instead of 2 when I get the chance.

OP posts:
HeartOfSass · 17/02/2018 12:52

X posts - I would bet a tenner they have planned in advance not acknowledge it! They have no intention of being discomforted by acknowledging it, and if they do, it'll be "put the cake over there".

You will still get your brownie points/win with the friends if you have a cake professionally made and decorated, everyone will ooh and ahh over how beautiful it is still, obviously they will see it's a cake company bake but won't know you were asked to make it first so you won't lose out there, and if they do know your were asked say "oh but I didn't think I could do a cake for FIL justice, I wanted it to be extra special"... get your brownie points that way. Watch as your PIL get discomforted by your fantastic professional cake get praised, that you didn't slave over in the kitchen and which was paid for out of your career woman earnings!

user1471432735 · 17/02/2018 12:53

Um birdsgottafly I said I fantasizes about it, but would never do it. You know, like people do all the time to cope with situations that are less than ideal. Fuck.

Another poster suggested I make shit pies, but I guessed that she was joking.

I also said I was making the cake. Do keep up

DH has said that if I do it, he won't be getting anything else as a present.

OP posts:
Globetrotter100 · 17/02/2018 12:54

Cheap tray bake from Tesco, iced with a ladder and smiling female stick figure at the top and the simple message "MY FABULOUS CAREER"... conveniently ignoring the birthday in question.

GnotherGnu · 17/02/2018 12:55

Birdsgotta, where did OP say she was providing a Costco cake?

viques · 17/02/2018 12:55

could you share the cake? Decorate half to celebrate your birthday and half to celebrate his?

Gazelda · 17/02/2018 12:56

viques yes! A joint birthday celebration because they haven't had chance to celebrate yours with you. Genius!

CherieBabySpliffUp · 17/02/2018 12:59

You're a better person than me OP there is no chance I would be baking a cake

April229 · 17/02/2018 13:01

At the very most minute I would buy a cake.

user1471432735 · 17/02/2018 13:01

Bless you all (well, most of you) the joint cake idea is devilishly brilliant, and I shall smirk at the thought.

Not in the U.K. So no tesco etc. We do have a Costco 45 minutes away but going there gives me a headache. I'd much rather make a cake than deal with the shit fight in the carpark and the urge that DH will get to buy several hundred dollars of bullshit in bulk.

OP posts:
Agerbilatemycardigan · 17/02/2018 13:01

Ice a penis on the top - maybe with some glitter on it

user1471432735 · 17/02/2018 13:04

Also there's Fuck all where they live so we'd have to transport a cake whether we bought it or baked it.

A baked cake(s) wrapped in foil is much easier to transport and then decorate at my mates place than something that's already been decorated and probably filled with that yucky fake cream.

This has been so helpful to vent and fantasize about what I could do tho, thank you

OP posts:
MissEliza · 17/02/2018 13:06

Fgs don't make the cake!