Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To feel awful about shouting at an older lady

540 replies

TheCrossKeys · 16/02/2018 01:17

I got the bus today with the baby, 6yo, and 4yo. Baby started having a little whinge when we first got on so I gave her a banana out of the shopping bag and she was silent for the rest of the trip, stuffing her face. 4yo and 6yo were chatting quietly but not constantly, I was across the aisle from them and could barely hear them. I am not shy about telling my DC to quiet down when they're being too loud, I will remove them if they don't and they know this as a fact.

When it got close to the stop we needed, 6yo asked me if this was our stop - it's not a route we usually travel so she wasn't familiar with it - I said yes. The older lady (maybe late 60s?) in the seat behind me piped up in a really nasty voice "good, maybe it'll be quiet now". I asked her what she meant and she pointed at the baby and DD and said "I mean the amount of noise from that and that!". I said she was being very rude about young children who had been sitting quietly and minding their own business, other passengers agreed that they were sitting quietly. She then told me "they're a disgrace and so are you". So I lost my temper and told her she was a nasty fucking witch and was sheborn this bitter or did it develop over time. I then lost whatever dignity I had left and (to my absolute shame) told her to go fuck herself.

I am not a horrible person, I try to be kind and I try to give people the benefit of the doubt. I've been having a tough time lately and the DC have been so good during it all, they are not little angels all of the time but they really were being quiet and I simply lost my rag.

We have to use that same route again tomorrow and I'm dreading it in case she's on the bus again.

OP posts:
kissmethere · 16/02/2018 11:23

OP don't feel bad it sounds like you reacted badly but I don't blame you.
I've lost my shit on the bus a couple of times and wasn't proud of it but move on. Ignoring her I'd yoi awe hwr again. Who wants to go through all that again.
I tore a strip off an older lady on the bus when she pushed my dd out of the way to get past her. She couldn't get away from me quick enough. Totally uncalled for and she was really rough with it.
Some people are just horrible and as a pp said let her stew in her own bitterness.

crazymumofthree · 16/02/2018 11:24

I think the older generation forget how small ones are, unfortunately being on public transport you do have to put up with other people - not just children but people talking into their mobile phones etc etc.she was really out of line and very rude but unfortunately responding like that probably made her feel justified in what she had said!

When my children were younger and we got the bus more often (as me and OH shared a car) the old ladies used to chat away to my children! However that didn't come without the occasional grumpy one.. one told me it was disgraceful my child called me mummy? And that he should call me Mum (he was about 2 or 3 at the time?!) and another proceeded to ask if I was still with their dad and where was he? ( midweek he's at work?!)

itsmeimcathyivecomehome · 16/02/2018 11:25

(That's if I saw her with the kids, to set a good example. If I saw her on a rare trip out by myself - nah, iPod on!!)

kissmethere · 16/02/2018 11:27

Sorry typos.

derxa · 16/02/2018 11:28

Do the people who are supporting the OP go on like this in their own daily life?

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 16/02/2018 11:28

Her nastyness was completely uncalled for and you won the moral high ground when the other passengers agreed with you. Unfortunately you then lost it by being nasty back. It would have got her goat so much more to just stick to the facts tell her that its nasty and insulting to refer to young children as "that" and that the other passengers didn't agree with her. Its really good to stand up for your children when passing strangers make nasty unwarrented remarks about them. It sounds like you are having a hard time but your kids are making up for it by being lovely, because you've brought them up nicely.Tell the kids that you are sorry for swearing and that you feel bad about it, that is also a good lesson for them, that you can admit you feel bad about it. Don't be worried about the bus, hold your head high. If you see her and an apology feels right, then make one, be prepared for more abuse and work out how you might deal with it nicely, but otherwise its a done deal nothing more you can do about it other than reflect on how you might do it differently next time, which you have on here- You never know she might accept the apology, even if she doesn't you will have made one and corrected behaviour you feel bad about. Enjoy the rest of half term. I love the picture you drew of baby stuffing their face on the bus. Best of luck.

PasDeDeux · 16/02/2018 11:31

Sounds to me like she deserved a mouthful!

MichaelBendfaster · 16/02/2018 11:32

Do the people who are supporting the OP go on like this in their own daily life?

No, but I can understand a) why she did and b) that she felt bad about it.

KalaLaka · 16/02/2018 11:33

She was horrible to all of you. She deserved it! Don't feel bad, she may think twice before being so awful to someone else.

RoseWhiteTips · 16/02/2018 11:35

derxa

Do the people who are supporting the OP go on like this in their own daily life?

I hope not. Think it might be AIBU bravado.

itsmeimcathyivecomehome · 16/02/2018 11:37

Michael has summed it up. No, I wouldn't have done it.

But I can see how people snap. And I can see that the OP regrets it.

What's the point of telling her that she's disgusting and doesn't deserve respect blah blah?!

UgandanKnuckles · 16/02/2018 11:40

@MichaelBendfaster

Yes. We're always going about screaming at randoms to go fuck themselves. Don't you? Hmm

Sallystyle · 16/02/2018 11:41

Yes, you went over the top. Nothing you can do about that now, except put it behind you.

I am a pretty placid person and I am not prone to shouting and swearing at members of public, but I did it once. It wasn't pretty and I still cringe when I think back to how I reacted. It shocked me as I have never lost control like that and I completely lost the high ground that I did actually have.

MichaelBendfaster · 16/02/2018 11:45

Ugandan, you may have misunderstood my post. The question in bold is a quote from another poster, not my question.

Sallystyle · 16/02/2018 11:50

You do realise that your children will go on and repeat this behaviour, don't you? You will no doubt be called in to school at some point because one of your DC has told one of their classmates to fuck themself. And the DC will say to the teacher: "But Mummy said it to a lady on the bus". Good luck with that one.

Well, like I said. I did it once around my child. I was never called to the school because he had told someone to fuck off . Never happened. Probably because he only witnessed it once and I explained to him after how I was wrong to react the way I did.

Shimmershimmerandshine · 16/02/2018 11:51

Absolutely - but she didn’t treat the other passengers to a volley of disgusting swear words.

No, but she referred to the OP's DC in a non human way, which is absolutely disgusting.

It reminds me of when I was a child a friend of DM's had a daughter with mild CP. She was out furniture shopping and some foul woman said when her dd sat on a sofa 'I can't believe they are letting THAT sit on the furniture'. The girl's mum went for her tooth and nail, and I would forgive anything she had said in fact she was justified. It isn't just swearing that is foul.

UgandanKnuckles · 16/02/2018 11:51

^ sorry, somehow complete misread it! Blush

I direct that at whoever asked such a stupid question in the first place XD

Bexter801 · 16/02/2018 11:51

You lost your cool under pressure,it happens :) you overreacted,but you already know this....I would say a passing comment,if you see her on the bus again(only because I'm guessing your stuck at the front,where she may be seating?) I'd say something along the lines,'sorry things got out of hand the other day' it'll make your bus journeys a lot less awkward,your kids will see your not condoning speaking like that,and the woman will hopefully not feel the need to give her commentary on parenting again

Bluntness100 · 16/02/2018 11:55

Two wrongs really don't make a right....

And agree, I suspect much of this support is Aibu bravado as previously indicated. Written by folks who wouldn't say boo to a goose. Sigh. Alternatively some right rough folks on here who regularly shout go fuck uourself at folks on public transport in front of their kids.

Either way it's not very admirable is it.

Triliteration · 16/02/2018 11:56

She sounds very unpleasant and I don’t find it surprising that you lost your temper and did something you now regret.

You can’t change something you’ve already done. Learn from it. If you feel bad, think about why, determine that if you find yourself in a similar situation in future that you’ll do better. Then forget about it. Continuing to beat yourself up is pointless.

PoisonousSmurf · 16/02/2018 11:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Graphista · 16/02/2018 11:58

Knowing me I'd have probably said something like "they're only small children and a baby and they've better manners than you have though eh?! Don't think it's us that's a disgrace!" Then a big cheesy grin and bright and breezy fun voice in dealing with getting DC off the bus.

After years of dealing with "awkward customers" (of all ages and backgrounds) I've learned the best way to piss em off and make it clear they're the ones in the wrong is to be calm but very assertive in a cold way. The more riled they get the calmer and quieter I appear - they hate it!

Rude cow!

Yes you were unreasonable but honestly I doubt you're the only person she's done this with (written before driver update 😉) so - meh karma - while it was an overreaction maybe it'll make her think twice before SHE overreacts and is rude and hurtful.

"she's like that with everyone" not at all surprised

I'm also older and slightly less tolerant than I was. I don't think it's age I think it's just not being used to the noise any more (and as a former childminder I used to have a noisy houseful!) that is STILL no excuse to be so rude.

I wouldn't apologise to her (particularly in light of update from driver) and I would hold my head high if she is on the bus and be tempted to give her a banana to otherwise occupy HER mouth

"Her age is utterly irrelevant"

I disagree there are some situations where older folk are very judgmental and honestly horrible to younger folk because PURELY due to their being older they think they know better/can get away with it. Age doesn't always equal wisdom and in this case doesn't seem to equal good manners either.

Even my mum and aunt (same approx age of this lady) agree that they've noticed a fair few of their generation can be very rude. I've been present when they've called a few out (and it is kinda fun to see these rude people blusteringly trying to justify unacceptable behaviour to someone the same age or even slightly older than them, when they've thought they'll get away with it because they were doing it to a less confident and experienced youngster - ageism works both ways!) I've noticed it more last few years. How they treat service personnel, queue jumping, letting doors go in people's faces, not thanking those that hold doors for them etc (lost count of how many times myself or dd have held door open at local mall and a troop of older folk have walked through without so much as a smile in our direction - must admit I have on occasion ostentatiously said "you're welcome!") no idea why but it does seem to be a certain element of this particular generation as my grandparents and parents would never behave/ have behaved like that.

"Thing is the woman acted like a matriarch. Some older men and women act like in this way. Age has something to do with this scenario imo. And I say this despite being no spring chicken." Exactly!

Charolais has a certain shall we say, style of posting, such that I was taken aback by that post too - until I saw who posted it.

"She then said that some people are rude, nasty or evil cunts throughout their lives, and this doesn’t suddenly change when they retire or get a free bus pass, but they simply become old rude, nasty or evil cunts!" So true, I worked in elderly care for several years and once a new at the time, younger colleague was criticising a residents family for not visiting more, being somewhat cool when they did visit. In this particular residents' case I happened to know they'd been quite abusive to their DC in the past (still weren't very pleasant to them when they visited) and the DC actually found it very difficult to visit at all. I said to her, "you don't know what's gone before, don't judge what you don't know". Just because someone is now older doesn't mean they automatically deserve respect or forgiveness.

"Maybe that lady was just having a really bad day, maybe something terrible had happened that day - who knows?" That's NO excuse

"but it’s not always possible to think of appropriate quips in the heat of the moment." True I'm an expert at l'esprit d'escalier - thinking of the perfect response hours later. But I think generally being calm but still calling the person out on THEIR poor behaviour is the way to go.

All that said (and I am NOT condoning) but if she'd tried that where I live (fairly deprived area with lots of large families) she'd have been VERY lucky to get away with not getting actually slapped or something thrown at her - and not even necessarily by the mother. Certainly highly likely another passenger would've told her to "get tae fuck hen" swearing's like breathing here!

"So you took a quick survey of the other passengers" I'm guessing based on having witnessed similar scenarios that it's more a case as the woman was being rude to op other passengers commented things like "they weren't being too noisy" "don't be daft they were fine"

StopCallingMeShirley · 16/02/2018 12:01

There's a chance this old lady had dementia. People in their right mind tend not to refer to children, especially to the mother, as that.

My father refers to my son as 'it'. He refuses to use his name. I no longer visit his house for my own mental wellbeing. He does not have dementia and is of perfectly sound mind. He is just a vile, cantankerous, bitter, (and, yes) old bully. He thinks nothing of criticising random members of the public loudly and wonders why his interactions with others are usually difficult. I can absolutely picture him sitting on a bus grumbling loudly about perfectly well behaved children because he believes they should be seen and not heard, preferably not even seen. If he were to treat a younger woman like this, he would absolutely deserve the response the OP gave this woman.

MichaelBendfaster · 16/02/2018 12:02

No worries, Ugandan!

KurriKurri · 16/02/2018 12:05

Her age is irrelevant - she was rude - she's probaby been rude and grumpy all her life.

'I think the older generation forget how small ones are,'

Not all of them - we are individulas just like every other age group or section of society. Some people are rude and grumpy, some people over react to rudeness and swear.

I wouldn't declare that all young mothers swear at old people because it is obviously untrue, just as it is untrue that old people are clueless about young children and are permanently bad tempered and are 'old bag' - we seem to be a section of society that people reserve especially vile insults for, particularly older women (older men aren't usually referred to as bags and bats simply because of their age.)

I am older, I have not forgotten what small chilcren are like - I've had two and in fact I worked with children for years so possibly have more idea than people with just a couple of young children of thier own.
I like children I always smile at them and engage if they speak to me, if they are acting up I share a sympathetic look witht he parent as I understand how children canget tired and fractious and bored on public transport.

So please don't treat all older women as if they were a homogenous lump of humanity.

The woman was rude - if she turns up tomorrow ignore her, if she tries to start an argument tell her you don't want to talk to her. If she harasses you, tell the driver.