Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not agree to support my husbands point of view

107 replies

feelingshittyagain · 30/03/2017 21:57

Ok I'll try to keep it brief. Basically I have a child with my DH who is over 18. When they were born DH and I were not married and we decided to give our child a double barrelled surname, DHs surname and my maiden name. When we married we renamed the child with my DHs surname as I was taking it too, so we would all be the same.

Our child has recently decided that they would like to revert back to the double barrelled name. They say it's because they want to feel like they are honouring both families. Our child is over 18, lives at home still and is very family oriented.

DH has flipped, he thinks our child is dishonouring his name and breaking up the family unit. I don't agree, I think our child is an adult and if they want to change their name then that's their choice. I don't think we can control the actions of our children, only guide them to make the right choices. I have suggested that our child use the name in social media but not change it officially yet, as I feel he should get a feel for it rather than make a rash decision. DH thinks it's a stupid idea completely but has told our child that it's their decision he just doesn't agree with it.

However, the real issue here, finally, is that DH is really pissed at me for not supporting him, not backing him up in telling our child not to change their name. We don't agree on this issue and I don't feel that I should back him up just because he wants me to. Aibu? I see where he's coming from but I don't agree with his opinion, should I be supporting an opinion I don't share to support my husband?

OP posts:
DaffodilsinMarch · 31/03/2017 15:35

You are DEFINITELY NOT being unreasonable. But your DH is being VERY unreasonable (and a few other things besides...!) But you clearly know that already and are dealing with a difficult situation calmly and with humour from what I can see. I wish you luck in resolving not only this but the other issues that exist with your DH. Please take from this thread that there are people who agree with your position (wholeheartedly) and are sending you support and strength to deal with it. His attitude is appallingly sexist and I hope he comes to realise it before it upsets his relationship with your DS even more.

And thanks to DingDong and others for the clear, spirited and correct defence of double-barrelled surnames. My two (double-barrelled surnamed) DCs thank you!

amberdillyduck · 31/03/2017 19:48

Now when Chlamydia and Timberlake meet and get married, what do they call their child Brexita?Is it Brexita White-Brown-Black-Green?

You can laugh but I know a quadruple named primary age child

XX Mum-Dad - unmarried
Mum married someone else XX Mum-Dad- New Husband
Split up, new boyfriend

XX Mum-Dad- New Husband- New boyfriend,

harderandharder2breathe · 31/03/2017 20:04

I don't like double barrelled names. That doesn't matter. Your adult child has decided they do like double barrelled names and you and DH liked it enough to use previously, I can see why they didn't expect it to be a problem to revert back to double barrelled. Your DH is BU. He should support your adult child, not try to persuade you that you shouldn't support them!

ThomasandFriends · 31/03/2017 20:14

amber - when I was at Junior school many years ago there was a boy with a double-barrelled name. Both names happened to be fairly common boys' names.

When he was about 8 his parents had a daughter. And gave her a double-barrelled first name as well. I always felt sorry for her.

honeylulu · 31/03/2017 20:27

Bloody hell. My kids have double barrelled names. I didn't realise that was so dreadful.
We gave the option of choosing to revert to one at secondary school age if they wanted. Our son chose to use just my surname. It was a complete non event.

Electrolens · 31/03/2017 20:35

YANBU. I changed the spelling of my first name as a young teenager and legally once I was 18 as that was how it was then - as a young 13yo it was part of asserting my identity and my parents accepted it and now it's my name and who I am.

A friend of mine took her mother's maiden name as a teenager because she preferred it.

It doesn't comment on your child's relationship with his father - he wants both names! He's an adult now and should be supported with the name he wants and the life he wants to lead.

minionsrule · 31/03/2017 20:41

OP unanimous YANBU.
What I don't understand is what your husband hopes to achieve even if you agree with him? Your DS can do whatever he wants, he doesn't need permission so even if you did agree with DH what difference would it make?
It not like standing together with a 5 year old who wants to stay up late and play on the X Box

New posts on this thread. Refresh page