Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother Who Doesn't Know I Exist.

111 replies

rumplestiltskins · 01/02/2017 02:14

TLDR: I am friends with my brother, and he has no idea we're even related. Our shared father has stopped me from telling him for 16 years.

Hello mums (and others).

So this is a pretty crazy story, which I hope I can paint clearly for you in this post. I guess I'll have to start at the beginning, so I apologise in advance.

I didn't have a present father when I was growing up. I only really ever had my mum. She was awesome, but I always wanted to know where the other part of my DNA came from. Milkman, Secret Agent, Sperm Bank, whatever. I had assumptions, like every kid in that situation would - but they only ever came to light when I was around 12 years old. She had this friend (who we'll call K) who was periodically around the house. Sometimes he'd visit for coffee, she'd pick him up from the pub, or they'd get drunk and he'd spend the night. Never anything more than that.

One evening, I asked her if he was my dad. She said he was. At the time, I was excited. Adolescentently, I thought that once I'd uncovered his identity he'd suddenly become the dad I wanted. I was wrong.

Turns out he already had a family who lived one street away from my mum and I. He had a wife... a daughter who was 2 years older than me... and a son who was 2 years younger than me.

That's right. I was the love child of a married man who decided to stay with his wife and keep me a secret.

Fast forward.

In my early 20's I was in a rock band which was gaining some national hype. Before leaving for a short UK stint, we were invited for an interview with a local music magazine in our home town. We sat down on one side of the desk, and on the other side sat my brother. Needless to say, I could barely get a sentence together.

In any case, the interview went well, and it turned out that he and I got on really well. So much so that HE decided to keep in touch. We aren't best friends or anything, but he'd happily drop me a line to talk about music.

I've asked my biological father on countless occasions to allow me the opportunity to approach my brother and form a true relationship. He denies it at every turn, claiming that it wouldn't a good time due to university exams, or other such nonsense.

Fast forward.

I've since had 2 daughters, the latter of whom will be turning 1 in a fortnight. K has nothing to do with these children and has met neither. Since having kids, I've approached my father again - in the hopes that he could understand why I want my brother (and to a similar extent, sister) to be involved in my family.

I feel like I've reached the end of my tether, and I need to bring this to a close. It's been 16 years of waiting. And I think about my brother every day.

Am I being unreasonable to disregard my "father" and his wishes.... by just approaching my brother anyway and trying to get what I've always wanted?

OP posts:
HibernoCaledonian · 03/02/2017 22:40

Hairyhat TLDR stands for Too Long, Didn't Read.

Hairyhat · 04/02/2017 11:15

Ah thanks

Wigbert · 04/02/2017 12:01

Op, I haven't experience of this, and agree that you should write to your brother to tell him, but have you considered that your brother may already know since he sought you out and befriended you?

emmyrose2000 · 05/02/2017 05:49

but have you considered that your brother may already know since he sought you out and befriended you?

Interesting perspective - it'd certainly shine a different, and ironic, light on things. Curious OP, as to how you'd feel if this was the case?

A few thoughts I had on the subject:
If I was the half sibling and it came out later via another means (ie. not the OP) that the OP had known about this for years and not told me, I'd be terribly upset. I'd be wondering if the OP had been laughing at me behind my back at not knowing. Also, I'd wonder if OP had only befriended me to keep tabs on me or something. It'd feel like a huge betrayal. It'd probably be a friendship breaker and I certainly wouldn't want to play 'happy families' with him after that.

I disagree with telling the brother via email/letter. Feelings and tone can be lost in written correspondence. This is a time where I'd want the recipient to know how genuine I was in breaking the news, so I'd do it face to face. It'd also be a huge shock to open the email or letter and be faced with the news. What I would do, however, is send a 'heads up' text/letter/email to say I had something really important to discuss with brother and when would be a good time to meet up?

Also, OP, how are you planning on telling your half sister? Would that best be left to her brother, or is it something you could do together?

Your father's feelings on this are irrelevant. He lost any right to make decisions on this matter when he cheated on his wife with your mother (and quite possibly other woman). He's a gutless coward who'll never do the right thing by any of his children.

DrivingMeBonkers · 05/02/2017 09:17

What do you hope to achieve?

Your "friend" with whom you have a good relationship, will the relationship turn overnight from friendship into a sibling relationship? You may lose that friend. The relationship will alter.

What do you want from your father?

Or is this simply too big a secret you are bursting to share?

LexieLulu · 05/02/2017 09:44

Have you sent an email yet? Good luck

ChasedByBees · 05/02/2017 09:54

You definitely need to get in touch and while your father is still alive. Give your brother a chance to work this out with him and have an opportunity to ask him questions. So don't wait.

Also don't give your father warning. He's had enough chances. If you send an email, do follow up with a call. Your brother may be shocked and not know what to say - that may lead to a delay in contacting you which then makes it more difficult to establish contact.

So don't take no reply as a rejection. You've known this for some time - it's new to him. It sounds like he likes you as a person - he may well be pleased and proud to call you his brother.

HeartsTrumpDiamonds · 05/02/2017 21:37

I agree, in person with a warning beforehand.

bangingmyheadoffabrickwall · 05/02/2017 22:14

Please tell us how you got on.

emmyrose2000 · 06/02/2017 03:01

You definitely need to get in touch and while your father is still alive. Give your brother a chance to work this out with him and have an opportunity to ask him questions. So don't wait

I agree.
I've heard/read numerous stories about people who've found long lost family members only to discover that the person they were looking for has since died. A very common reaction is anger at not being able to talk to the person to discuss the situation around the separation.

So, yes, if you can talk to your brother whilst the dad is still around he might have a chance at having some of his questions answered (or not, if dad is being a wanker).

chatnanny · 06/02/2017 09:19

Having had some experience of this I am a strong believer in using an intermediary - perhaps not with your brother who is your friend which is an unusual situation - but for anyone else thinking of approaching a birth relative an intermediary helps hugely. Social Services will often appoint one which is free and there are also lots of professional intermediaries. You can read more here: www.adoptionsearchreunion.org.uk

An intermediary will filter extreme emotions and act tactfully and professionally.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.