Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother Who Doesn't Know I Exist.

111 replies

rumplestiltskins · 01/02/2017 02:14

TLDR: I am friends with my brother, and he has no idea we're even related. Our shared father has stopped me from telling him for 16 years.

Hello mums (and others).

So this is a pretty crazy story, which I hope I can paint clearly for you in this post. I guess I'll have to start at the beginning, so I apologise in advance.

I didn't have a present father when I was growing up. I only really ever had my mum. She was awesome, but I always wanted to know where the other part of my DNA came from. Milkman, Secret Agent, Sperm Bank, whatever. I had assumptions, like every kid in that situation would - but they only ever came to light when I was around 12 years old. She had this friend (who we'll call K) who was periodically around the house. Sometimes he'd visit for coffee, she'd pick him up from the pub, or they'd get drunk and he'd spend the night. Never anything more than that.

One evening, I asked her if he was my dad. She said he was. At the time, I was excited. Adolescentently, I thought that once I'd uncovered his identity he'd suddenly become the dad I wanted. I was wrong.

Turns out he already had a family who lived one street away from my mum and I. He had a wife... a daughter who was 2 years older than me... and a son who was 2 years younger than me.

That's right. I was the love child of a married man who decided to stay with his wife and keep me a secret.

Fast forward.

In my early 20's I was in a rock band which was gaining some national hype. Before leaving for a short UK stint, we were invited for an interview with a local music magazine in our home town. We sat down on one side of the desk, and on the other side sat my brother. Needless to say, I could barely get a sentence together.

In any case, the interview went well, and it turned out that he and I got on really well. So much so that HE decided to keep in touch. We aren't best friends or anything, but he'd happily drop me a line to talk about music.

I've asked my biological father on countless occasions to allow me the opportunity to approach my brother and form a true relationship. He denies it at every turn, claiming that it wouldn't a good time due to university exams, or other such nonsense.

Fast forward.

I've since had 2 daughters, the latter of whom will be turning 1 in a fortnight. K has nothing to do with these children and has met neither. Since having kids, I've approached my father again - in the hopes that he could understand why I want my brother (and to a similar extent, sister) to be involved in my family.

I feel like I've reached the end of my tether, and I need to bring this to a close. It's been 16 years of waiting. And I think about my brother every day.

Am I being unreasonable to disregard my "father" and his wishes.... by just approaching my brother anyway and trying to get what I've always wanted?

OP posts:
BoomBoomsCousin · 01/02/2017 18:50

I don't think Pinbasket is suggesting giving the father a chance for the father's sake, but rather trying to force the father to take responsibility and do the ugly work so that the OP doesn't have to face the possible fall out from breaking the news. You do identify the risk of this strategy though - that the father will not do it, but instead undermine the OP's credibility.

PossumInAPearTree · 01/02/2017 18:56

I think you should maybe consider telling him face to face. Can you email asking him to meet up but maybe drop a heavy hint that there is something very important you need to discuss?

TinselTwins · 01/02/2017 18:58

but rather trying to force the father to take responsibility and do the ugly work so that the OP doesn't have to face the possible fall out from breaking the news.

His mistress(es?) giving birth to his own offspring didn't make him face up to his responsibilities and actions so I really don't think the OP asking now will change anything

BoomBoomsCousin · 01/02/2017 19:07

It may not, though he might be selfish and vein enough to be moved by the potential risk to his relationship with his "legal" (for want of a better term) family and the desire to frame himself in the best possible light.

TinselTwins · 01/02/2017 19:30

BoomBooms that motivation does usually play out as "discredit the woman" rather than "do the right thing and own up"

Just ask MNers who have told men to come clean to their wives about un-welcome sexting etc.. tends to go "stop texting me, I'm not interested, and tell her or I will"… following week rumours all over the playground about the desperate woman harassing poor husbands..

BoomBoomsCousin · 01/02/2017 19:39

It can go both ways, and it's definitely a risk that may well make it an unwise action. I was challenging more the way you focused on it being something Pinbasket thought the father deserved as though Pinbasket was some kind of apologist for his actions, but that was definitely not the tone of their post.

rumplestiltskins · 01/02/2017 20:06

If ever I was to approach K with an ultimatum, it was always with the selfish intent of removing myself from doing his dirty work. I fear the idea of being the bringer of possible bad news. Certain shocking news, at any rate.

Ive decided to pen an e-mail to C. I might also pen an email to K. Whether i decide to send the latter will depend on some reflection.

I have to he very certain that i have enough evidence (pictures and messages) to attach in order to remove any deniability on K's part. I wont give him any wiggle room, with which he could try and paint me in an uncredible light.

OP posts:
fassbendersmistress · 01/02/2017 20:39

Really brave decision Mr Rumple. In the long term you won't regret it.

Not to minimise or anything, but half families, bros and sis's here and there is totally normal these days. What's not normal is the years of deceit and hurt behind all this and you really don't want to play any part in that. As an adult now you have a choice. It has quite rightly taken you time to get here, but now you are ready, just go for it!

NotMyPenguin · 01/02/2017 21:10

I really don't think you need to worry about deniability; you've got the shared DNA so could easily prove it that way if you needed to.

Best of luck to you and I hope it goes as well as possible.

rumplestiltskins · 01/02/2017 22:39

Would anyone have idea idea's on how I would start an email to him?

I think I'm definitely going to do it.

OP posts:
TinselTwins · 01/02/2017 23:32

Hi bro's name
It's a bit awkward this far down the line since we've gotten to know each other a bit through the music, but there was never really a good time and I need to ask, do you know who I am/recognise me?…..

dowhatnow · 02/02/2017 00:08

How will you feel if he wants nothing to do with you ever again?

Hairyhat · 03/02/2017 18:26

Hi Mr Rump, I'm in exactly the same position as you except my Mum dues 4 years ago and my Dad and his wife are still alive. My half sister is 6 months (!) older than me. My dad did the dirty on his wife with my mum while she was pregnant. My Dad's wife is a very lovely lady (as is my half sister) and I have kept the secret of who my dad is since I was 6 to protect her. I plan to tell my half sister when they are both deceased.

Hairyhat · 03/02/2017 18:26

*my mum died

Hairyhat · 03/02/2017 18:30

I know completely how you feel. Guilty for living a lie when you see your brother and you don't tell him your related? I have done this for decades but the alternative would be to hurt someone who I consider innocent. I also think that my sibling will forgive me when she finds out because she will realise I was protecting her mum. I can have a sisterly relationship with her now as well as later (we keep in occasional touch like you I think). Just some food for thought

Danglybits · 03/02/2017 18:39

Following. Without going into details, I'm in a similar scenario myself. Good luck.

Aworldofmyown · 03/02/2017 18:40

I think you have to tell him. How you you feel if K died and the truth came out then? Your sibling would be grieving and having to deal with never being able to reconcile with his Dad. If they have a good relationship they will get through it.

I have a little experience with this as my father denied I was his for years. I only met my 4 siblings when I was 20.

bonfireheart · 03/02/2017 18:56

So have you been friends with your brother for the past 16 years?

Namesarehard · 03/02/2017 19:01

Good luck. I truly hope you get a good outcome.

oleoleoleole · 03/02/2017 19:35

I would start by saying the contents are your email are going to be a huge shock and life changing for him. I would then explain what you've told us. He could side with his dad and cut you off and you could lose all of them. Be prepared for that. Think through every outcome.

debbs77 · 03/02/2017 19:41

No advice but wanted to say good luck!

seven201 · 03/02/2017 20:43

Oh gosh, good luck.

I think make sure your brother doesn't dismiss the email by thinking it's spam or a weird round robin thing. So make sure you use names somewhere in the first few sentences and definitely be careful with the email title.

Linning · 03/02/2017 21:17

I am in a similar situation. My father have had various children with different women and while I got to meet one of my stepsiblings a few times, I also know he has at least 2 other sons with other women. They are both much younger than me and still young children but I plan on getting in touch with them when they turn 18. I have a very unique last name so finding them shouldn't be hard at all, not sure whether or not they know about me and my brother though (and stepsister from previous relationship). I am not in touch with my father at all so don't know whether or not he is still in their lives but I would love to get to know them and hear about their childhood and stuff. I definitely do not plan to seek and ask permission to my father though.

Glad to hear you have made up your mind and will finally tell the truth to your brother. Good luck and come back to tell us what happened ! Smile

Hairyhat · 03/02/2017 22:33

(What does "TLDR" mean please folks?)

JessieMcJessie · 03/02/2017 22:39

"Too Long, Didn't Read" : an executive summary for those not prepared to read a long post.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.