Maybe I can help in a different way.
I have lived in big cities, big towns, small town, villages and in a very rural nowhere.
Cities and big towns: too noisy, to dirty. I am constantly surprised at the contents of my hanky after a visit. But I did like the easy access to just about everything, including intenet and a variety of fresh, non local fruit and veg, good bread etc, oh, and cultural stuff
Villages: must have a shop, school and pub to meet the real criteria: nice but a bit too close, nosy. Main shopping was always done elswehere but the local shop did local delicacies and good bread. Nice compromise, garden big enough to GYO, enough available locally to live quite close, lots of lovely places to go out to.
Rural Nowhere: was bliss! Birds, bees, the milk lorry and the weather. Lost of just pottering. Very few people. Shopping done on the way back from wherever, fruit picked straight from tree/bush, veg grown in garden or Garden Gate swapped for other stuff, chickens kept (and sorely missed).
Small rural town (current residence): shops, buses, schools, leisure centre and library!!!! thriving running club, nice people, coffee shop - shite bread in local bakery and no interest in changing. Fortunately the next village along gets deliveries of the very best bread ever in a very nice coffee shop/deli! Easy access to all of the stuf we had in the middle of nowehre, but if I forget an onion I walk 100 yards and get one (except Sundays, when the walk is a bit longer).
And I grew up mostly in a a very rural farm and small village - and yes. All year round mum opened the doors in the morning and we found our way home in the afternoons. Loads to do, never got bored.
For cchoice I would still beliving very rurally but DH needed a bit more, so we comprmised. Edge of a very small town, close to walks, shops, city and motorway!