Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MIL’s comments during my pregnancy are horribly inappropriate?

131 replies

IsThisYourSanderling · 14/08/2016 20:44

After three gruelling years of infertility, I’m due my first baby in six weeks’ time, and throughout my pregnancy MIL has been making comments about things going wrong. Today she noticed via Instagram that we’ve bought a cot, and texted to say that she thinks it’s wrong to buy big things in advance, in case something bad happens. She said the same when we were visiting her a month ago – that we were ‘brave’ to have bought things, because something might still happen. These hints about the possibility of a stillbirth feel horribly inappropriate and insensitive, especially as the due date is approaching. I got a bit upset about it this evening.

It goes further back too. She visited us when I was 13 weeks pregnant, and treated me to detailed stories of everyone she’s ever known who either had a stillbirth, a miscarriage, or themselves almost died in childbirth. It was barrel-scraping stuff – her neighbour’s cousin’s bridesmaid, that sort of thing. I did ask her to stop, but she smiled and carried on.

Before that, when we told her I was pregnant at about 6 weeks, her first response was to tell us not to get excited because my endometriosis means I have a ‘toxic womb’.

She has four healthy children and has never experienced a miscarriage (she told me it had never happened to her while regaling me with tales of others’ losses), so it’s not that she’s over-anxious based any losses of her own. She also has five healthy grandchildren. My own pregnancy has been healthy throughout, thankfully.

I just don’t get it. How normal is this sort of behaviour? Has anyone else experienced it, and did you just brush it off in the end?

OP posts:
HermioneWeasley · 14/08/2016 21:42

Well DH will just have to tell her that's you're still recovering after the birth and in no position to have guests, so she'll just have to stay in a hotel.

I assume DH will be taking that week off work so you do t have to entertain the mad bat on your own?

blankmind · 14/08/2016 21:44

I'd have to call her on it and would probably quite forcefully tell her to keep her opinions to herself, but here's a few more polite ways to get her to consider keeping her big mouth firmly shut.
MIL..
Why have you said that, what do you actually mean?
Are you trying to upset me?
That's not very supportive, is it, I'd hoped for a much better reaction from you.
Did you really mean to be so negative?
We are looking forward to having our baby, why are you saying things like that?

hazeimcgee · 14/08/2016 21:44

Can BIL host her??

Why are baby showers and presents before the birth inapprpriate?

Your MIL would have jad a field day with me - ALL the big stuff was bought by 17 weeks

passingthrough1 · 14/08/2016 21:46

Oh I totally agree with 4 weeks alone first. I have a one month old and some people I was fine to see straight away - but people I was worried would give unsolicited opinions and help (like your MIL) I needed to avoid until I was confident I could feed, change a nappy etc. The last thing you want is someone saying "oh, you're doing it that way... Maybe that's why they're crying..." (Still bitter!!)
I am not understanding people saying "that's just how it was". Sharing lots and lots of stories of late term MC and still birth is how things were? I don't think so. Yes some of my older relatives didn't tell people or buy presents until the baby was here but that's very different to telling you horror stories which have about a 0.1% chance of happening.

April241 · 14/08/2016 21:49

If you feel like a weeks visit will be too much just say she'll need to stay in a hotel or perhaps BIL will have her for the week. Maybe see how she is on the phone/via text when the baby is here and if you feel like you can't have her in your house constantly for a week then don't put yourself through that.

headinthecloud · 14/08/2016 21:51

What an awful woman. Please don't let this ruin such a special time for you. Block her ignore her cold shoulder anything but give her a wide berth

DixieNormas · 14/08/2016 21:54

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

YouTheCat · 14/08/2016 21:55

Fill the spare room with baby stuff and tell the old fart there's no room for her. Make sure she knows she's welcome to stay in a hotel and put her off for as long as possible.

And those saying 'oh people in their 50s are like this' or 'it's opinion of its time' - utter bollocks. Being born in the 1960s does not mean you believe this kind of crap. I don't know a single person of that age who would spout such nonsense. My ex mil (in her late 70s) would spout this kind of rubbish but she's really not very bright.

happyhearts7 · 14/08/2016 21:56

Congratulations IsThisYourSanderling Flowers

Tell your MIL to simply "Butt out!"
She obviously doesn't care that she's upsetting you so I wouldn't bother with being nice about it but then that's me after putting up with crap like that for years from certain people.

When I was pregnant I bought all my stuff very early (I was about 13 weeks when I brought my pram home) despite most people yapping about it!

When my 1st baby was a couple of months old my parents bought him a highchair as a present, when my step MIL found out I was told "Well, if you'd saved first before you got yourself pregnant you could have bought it yourself" Hmm I just took it and said nothing to her.. now she'd know better to say anything remotely like that as I don't take crap like that anymore am not a pushover any more.
She even accused me of being jealous and said I copied her as she had got pregnant 2 months before me Hmm Actually all 5 of our DSs were planned but no.. apparently she knew better Angry
Just ignore and see less of her which is what I had to do in the end!!

HarryPottersMagicWand · 14/08/2016 21:58

YANBU! It sounds like if the worse ever happened, she would say "I told you so!"

Tell her very firmly you have heard enough and don't want to hear it anymore and walk away. Do this every time. Who wants to hear this, especially after struggling to get there. We took 3 years too and I have endometriosis. I would have flipped at being told I had a toxic womb! And endo isn't even confined to the womb, stupid woman doesn't even know what she's on about.

LanaorAna1 · 14/08/2016 22:05

The key now is - don't let her in after you've had the baby. Pre-empt by doing something to the spare room (eg redecorate, naturally removing the bed) so you can't have her to stay.

Yes, it's fine to stand up to her. If your instinct tells you she's being a bitch, it's usually right. Note she didn't say sorry when DH called her - but she justified what she said.

Yes, it's fine to remove furniture to keep her out. Do it this week.

OhMrBadger · 14/08/2016 22:09

OP Did she do the same with her other grandchildren? Is she a matriarchaI type? Always right, her DSs/DDs running around after her? I just wonder if she has a problem with not being the only mother in the family anymore and that she'd somehow created a twisted view of you as not being a threat to her role as Queen Bee...and now you ARE going to be a mother just like she is, and she doesn't like it one little bit.

Like she previously had a hold over you but that's gone now. The unpleasant comments might be her way of trying to re-establish control.

Wauden · 14/08/2016 22:13

Re-arrange the spare room, fill it with baby things, get some things from the charity shop and stuff it to the gills. 'Sorry but with baby, we had to make some changes, there is a hotel nearby, see you in x months.'

I don't think ppl in their 50s do normally talk like that, she does sound anxious herself, really.

confuugled1 · 14/08/2016 22:13

I'd just say straight out, that after the way that MIL has treated you through your pregnancy, then you do not want to host her for her stay as you don't trust her enough to stay with you.

If she had started to tell misery stories once and had shut up as soon as you asked her to, then you could chalk it up to different ages/cultures/etc and move on. But the way that she seems to have revelled in telling you horrible stories even after you have asked her and dh has asked her to stop - I'd just say sorry, tough. That's what comes of being horrible.

If DH complains, then point out that if even BIL is saying not to let her stay then it's really not worth the pain of having her to stay. And if she doesn't want to spend the money on coming to see you for a week - then fine. Come for 3 days or don't come at all.

And quickly, find a different purpose for the spare room! Can you lend the mattress out to someone or pretend it's damaged or something, anything, to make the room uninhabitable for her?

Enjoy the rest of your pregnancy and your new baby when s/he arrives. And if MIL is rotten again when you talk to her, give her one warning to stop - and if she doesn't then say that's it, I've asked you to talk about something different and nice, you haven't so I'm putting the phone down/walking out/turning off Skype/etc and just go. Don't let her continue. If you have to stay and can't escape then ostentatiously stick your fingers in your ears and sing and look at your phone - anything so you don't have to listen. It will show her that you mean business and that you are prepared to stand up to her and not to take everything that she dishes out as I suspect her sons have been conditioned to do!

jcsp · 14/08/2016 22:15

Annoying and insensitive as it seems could she be preparing herself for the worst? (And then be pleased/relieved when all goes well)

Is she a lot older? Has she got that fascination with death, illness, misfortune that some of the elderly have?

CP

Sunshineonacloudyday · 14/08/2016 22:17

Congratulations and you will be fine just remember to remain calm. Maybe she is a paranoid person what has your dh said about this.

SeaEagleFeather · 14/08/2016 22:19

If your BIL has told you to put her in a hotel, listen to him

a week's difficult visit when you have a 4 week old is a seriously unpleasant experience that you never forget.

She'll see a lot of the baby during the day. Give yourself that gift of the end-of-the-day alone with your baby and husband.

badg3r · 14/08/2016 22:21

Absolutely don't let her stay at yours!! Tell her it's not how you were brought up to have family guests for at least ten years after giving birth, and then roll off a list of friends' colleagues' ex neighbours etc who have gone NC/poisoned/broken the legs of insensitive MILs in a postnatal hormonal rage.

MadamDeathstare · 14/08/2016 22:22

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Joydgreen88 · 14/08/2016 22:23

Whatever you do, stick her in a hotel! The first fees weeks of your baby's life should be a put getting to know each other and falling in love. Not fielding the inevitable mad comments from the old bat. Honestly, you'll be knackered, stressed, thinking about feeds and nappies and any comment from her will most likely really knock you back. Don't risk it! She's already proven she's a nightmare, it's YOUR baby, do things on YOUR terms. Whatever is best for your little family.

Sunshineonacloudyday · 14/08/2016 22:23

I just read your last post it is good that he standing up to his mother. Its not an easy thing to do.

Sunshineonacloudyday · 14/08/2016 22:24

You should trash the spare room and make out you are redecorating.

Kidsrulethishouse · 14/08/2016 22:27

What horrible things for her to say, obviously not the things that anyone should be saying to any pregnant lady ever.

maddening · 14/08/2016 22:28

Next time just say "oh shut up you morbid bitch" :)

gandalf456 · 14/08/2016 22:28

When I first read your post I just thought it was down to superstition - the bit about not buying things before the baby comes. My mother is a bit like that. I think it might be a generational thing. But when I got further down, there does seem to be an issue there. I do think you need to nip this in the bud now if your DH is not going to do it and it would sound better coming from him. When the baby comes, you'll be doing it all wrong, too, but it is her issue, not yours and it's best to ignore and distance yourself from her as much as possible if she doesn't stop