Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MIL’s comments during my pregnancy are horribly inappropriate?

131 replies

IsThisYourSanderling · 14/08/2016 20:44

After three gruelling years of infertility, I’m due my first baby in six weeks’ time, and throughout my pregnancy MIL has been making comments about things going wrong. Today she noticed via Instagram that we’ve bought a cot, and texted to say that she thinks it’s wrong to buy big things in advance, in case something bad happens. She said the same when we were visiting her a month ago – that we were ‘brave’ to have bought things, because something might still happen. These hints about the possibility of a stillbirth feel horribly inappropriate and insensitive, especially as the due date is approaching. I got a bit upset about it this evening.

It goes further back too. She visited us when I was 13 weeks pregnant, and treated me to detailed stories of everyone she’s ever known who either had a stillbirth, a miscarriage, or themselves almost died in childbirth. It was barrel-scraping stuff – her neighbour’s cousin’s bridesmaid, that sort of thing. I did ask her to stop, but she smiled and carried on.

Before that, when we told her I was pregnant at about 6 weeks, her first response was to tell us not to get excited because my endometriosis means I have a ‘toxic womb’.

She has four healthy children and has never experienced a miscarriage (she told me it had never happened to her while regaling me with tales of others’ losses), so it’s not that she’s over-anxious based any losses of her own. She also has five healthy grandchildren. My own pregnancy has been healthy throughout, thankfully.

I just don’t get it. How normal is this sort of behaviour? Has anyone else experienced it, and did you just brush it off in the end?

OP posts:
DelicatePreciousThing1 · 14/08/2016 21:09

This woman is being insensitive - to say the least. All decent people would be supportive, especially given the family connection.
Everything will be fine,IsThisYourSanderling. I wish you all good wishes.x

TowerRavenSeven · 14/08/2016 21:11

I had a co worker like her. I finally told her I wasn't going to talk about it and if she started up I was going to walk out. She did, and I walked out. A few times. She finally got the message. Don't stand for it.

BettyOBarley · 14/08/2016 21:12

Yes agree your DH should be telling her to back off - what has he said about it all?

Im 8 months pregnant and apart from the 2 scans my MIL has completely ignored the fact I'm pregnant, not a word, even though I see her every week. The only thing she has said is that she was going to buy some clothes (at about 22 weeks) but thought no its far too early anything could happen still. Gee thanks for that. I'm now 35 weeks and I'm not even convinced she knows the due date.

specialsubject · 14/08/2016 21:13

No, of course that is not normal ! Telling disaster stories to a pregnant woman is as bad as telling them to someone awaiting an operation.

I dont buy gifts until a baby arrives. Not because i am a superstitious cave dweller but because it isnt appropriate and i am not an american. But with six weeks to go, i think it is time to get the kit!

Hope all goes very well.

timelytess · 14/08/2016 21:13

If she's in her fifties, its the stuff they used to tell us. I remember ordering a cot and not being expected to collected until after the birth.

rumblingDMexploitingbstds · 14/08/2016 21:17

Oh God my DM used to do this, from the moment she knew I was pregnant. It was so upsetting. Thanks I'm sorry your MiL is doing this to you. It is as pps are saying, about her, but DH needs to step in and very firmly tell her how upsetting and stressful it is for you.

I put my foot down quite firmly with DM the second we knew my Dsis was expecting so she couldn't do a repeat performance and she was quite surprised to realise she did it. I think with her it was in part anxiety and in part just social script of 'things to say when someone's pregnant'. A definite, "Mum DO NOT TELL HER x y and z," did stop it.

niceday · 14/08/2016 21:18

That's how things were in her time and that's her way to cope with her own anxiety. It's not rational, so you cannot explain it to her.
Don't take it personally but distance from her emotionally.

EverySongbirdSays · 14/08/2016 21:18

I'd have bitten back by now, I'd have looked her dead in the eye, and calmly asked :

Are you actively trying to upset me?

And allowed the awkward silence to happen so her behaviour could sink in

Also : you have a DH problem that he hasn't done this for you as it's easier to challenge ones DM than ones MIL

WanderingTrolley1 · 14/08/2016 21:18

What an absolute cow. She seems to be revelling in scaring you.

ScarlettDarling · 14/08/2016 21:19

Yes, horribly inappropriate. Just horrible infact. Silly woman, you can't leave buying a cot, pushchair etc til after the baby is here!

You've had a healthy pregnancy. The birth will be fine. Your baby will be amazing. Your mil is an arse Grin!

Deep breaths. Tell your Dh that he needs to tell her in no uncertain terms that she must not talk about such things to you. If she does, leave the room.

Now go get excited and do some online baby shopping...gorgeous tiny sleep suits, soft bedding, night lights....you lucky thing!

jbee664 · 14/08/2016 21:20

Whaaaaatttttttt....how very inappropriate!!

Yes, your DH needs to tell her.

I've had 2 mc's but wouldn't talk about them to somebody at that stage of pregnancy!

pigsDOfly · 14/08/2016 21:20

What a peach she sounds.

If your DH isn't prepared to tell her to keep her nasty stories to herself then you need to do it.

Do it with a smile and tell her you really don't want to hear it. If she goes on just walk away. What's the worst she can do?

Why do women - yes it's usually women - do this to pregnant women? It's almost as if they can't bear to see someone else happy, it's so spiteful.

Atenco · 14/08/2016 21:20

How awful and I am by nature a pessimist who likes to prepare for the worst but I've never understood people like that.

However when it comes to having a baby, statistics are definitely on your side, OP. The vast, vast majority of babies are born live and healthy.

abbsismyhero · 14/08/2016 21:21

i remember when i got my first pram from mothercare they offered to deliver it after the baby was born i was a bit Hmm but my exs mom said she would keep it at her house until baby was born i found it all very weird but tbh i wasn't expecting to have children so the stillbirth/miscarriage rates were unknown to me and if i had known my thyroid problems meant i was more prone to a loss i would have been terrified (although after 13 weeks i think the risk goes back to the same as everyone else)

im waffling she is being a miserable baggage ignore her dont involve her enjoy the rest of your pregnancy Flowers

FellOutOfBed2wice · 14/08/2016 21:24

What- that's nuts!!!! My best friend is a midwife and tells me all the stories- the good, bad, ugly and tragic.... But throughout my pregnancies she's been very strict about not discussing "on the job" stuff and just says "you don't need to hear this stuff" which I think is very considerate. What's your MILs excuse, is she just a fucking sadist?!

April241 · 14/08/2016 21:25

What awful things to say!! I'd be furious with that. I hope it hasn't ruined your pregnancy experience. My Gran was utterly appalled that we have the pram in the house, I'm due in 8 weeks and don't get superstitious over baby things. We also have the nursery furniture although it isn't built up yet.

Glad things have been going well otherwise and not long to go now!! Try to just ignore it and get your DH to say something, clearly you telling her hasn't stopped it in any way :(

ScarletForYa · 14/08/2016 21:27

What a horrible bitch.

Please tell me your husband is going to deal with her.

ZippyNeedsFeeding · 14/08/2016 21:28

Tell her that you have decided to suck every last drop of joy from this pregnancy and you will not feel any bit better about any theoretical disaster for having spent the whole time worrying about it.
Or tell her to fuck off, the choice is yours.
I wonder if my mother (Official Prophet Of Doom, caters for all occasions, squashing all forms of joy a speciality) has s secret sister?

Obsidian77 · 14/08/2016 21:30

Congratulations on your pregnancy. Flowers
You've gone through so much to get here, cherish this time. Your MIL sounds dreadful, mine is very similar. She gets away with it because people think she's tactless rather than straight out mean and DH never stands up to her because i) he's grown up with this nonsense so it probably washes over him and ii) he can't face the drama of upsetting her.
Like fabulous says, you won't change her, but you can control your reaction to her.
You could either shut her down "MIL, what you're saying is very unkind and I don't want to hear it" or change the subject, "ooh, did I tell you my friend is getting a new puppy". Do this every single time she opens her mouth and she'll eventually get the message.
In my situation I figure that since DH will never stand up to her, I have the right to try manage the terms of the conversation.
I would expect your MIL to continue being a prize nuisance and epic tact deficit once your baby arrives. Get used to standing up to her for your own peace of mind.
Best wishes.

rosieappletree · 14/08/2016 21:33

Lots of babies arrive early. My ds was 6 weeks early. We had the cot ( thank goodness) but no mattress or car seat.
We then had to sort it out after ds arrival. It would have been much easier to have got it all before.
Just tell her you're getting it all organised now as you will be far too busy with baby once he/ she has arrived. Enjoy the rest of your pregnancy. 💐

GabsAlot · 14/08/2016 21:34

its one thing to be worried because of earlier problems its another to keep haroping on about it

your baby you stuff when u want and im with others your dh should be saying something to her

congrats x

NavyandWhite · 14/08/2016 21:34

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

passingthrough1 · 14/08/2016 21:35

How horrible! I don't have it nearly this bad but MIL has said things about my baby that upset me.. What upsets me more is that OH doesn't say anything. I think you need to make yours speak up.

IsThisYourSanderling · 14/08/2016 21:38

Thanks all, it's actually been eye-opening to see the strength of your reactions / support for my predicament. It's easy to just get used to this kind of behaviour from an in law, and lose sight of what is normal or acceptable.

DH has said things, he just did on the phone this evening and she conceded that it's 'just how she was brought up'. I get that, but as a grown woman with a lifetime's experience of interacting with other humans, she should surely know when to keep her thoughts to herself on such an emotive topic. Instead, it does seem as if she is deliberately trying to upset me / us. All my interactions with her tend to be upsetting tbh - and it seems to have gotten worse since the pregnancy. Perhaps because I'm not able to just think 'oh whatever, this doesn't concern me' any more. Part of the problem, like with googietheegg, DH is so used to her stupid insensitive remarks that he barely notices them anymore. When he has them pointed out to him, he does react. But generally he's conditioned himself not to hear them. So he doesn't always react instantly... it is a problem, but he is definitely getting better. The family dynamic is set up so that she simply is not challenged most of the time, by anybody, and DH has just now begun to break this pattern in the last couple of years.

I'm glad people are saying to avoid her once the baby arrives. Because of various incidents of bad behaviour during the pregnancy, I have decided that I want four weeks to ourselves before she is welcome to visit (she lives in another country, so it's not just a question of her popping over to see us for an hour - it means a week's stay). I'm dreading her visit, and I think four weeks to establish feeding and bonding and recovering and learning how to look after our baby and getting to know him is what I need, emotionally, before she comes over. Because she will have a destabilising effect on us.

BIL has just texted to say that on no account should we let her stay in our house when she visits. God, it would be brilliant if we could get her to stay in the hotel down the road, but we have a big spare room with a double bed and she's very funny about spending money, so I'm not sure that's realistic.

Thanks again everybody, you've made me feel a bit less mad.

OP posts:
andthedog · 14/08/2016 21:39

Congratulations on your pregnancy.
Going against the grain here I think mil may be projecting her own anxiety. In a wierd way she may be trying to protect you from hurt by trying to prepare you for hurt. She may just feel you've hurt enough. But still, I see how awful this is for you in a vulnerable state. Ask your dh to explain how difficult her stories are.

Swipe left for the next trending thread