Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

name stealer ?

123 replies

rubybleu2 · 15/05/2016 19:29

Way back when I was in secondary school, of a year group of around 125, there were at least 6 Sarahs , 8 Emmas countless Claires, and an army of Amys. My own name was also a very popular one, there were 7 of us I think.....when I had my own DDs I was keen to avoid this, so after research on the office for national satistics website I chose a couple of old family names, that were ranked something like 225 & 210 most popular names of the previous years they were born.....to give you an idea of how sparsely used they are nowadays, I shall call them Shelia & Barbara ( these are examples only).....now the problem is this..... a fellow mum from our toddler group is pregnant with twins (identical), and has said if she has girls, she is going to call them the exact same names as my two....we live in a very small village, and her twins will be in the same year group as my youngest, now I realise I don't own the names, and ultimately there's not a lot I can do about it.....but AIBU to feel a bit pissed off, I even told her I thought it would be a bit weird, and why I chose my names, but my concerns didn't seem to register, we also have very similar sounding surnames, and ours is often mispronounced to the exact same as hers

OP posts:
Andylion · 15/05/2016 20:11

She must be lacking in imagination.,
I don't think I could stop myself from making a comment to that effect: "Couldn't you come up with something more original? People will think you copied me."

jollygoose · 15/05/2016 20:15

I agree with through thick and thin, tell her you have gone off those names and you really like .... if she thinks you do not like those names at all she will probably change her mind.

MissPronounced · 15/05/2016 20:15

That's really quite weird of her, IMO. YANBU to feel a bit miffed!

Backpfeifengesicht · 15/05/2016 20:18

Well you could try to see it as flattering (hard I know). No one owns a name of course but honestly this situation would be very irritating to me. Hopefully she'll have boys!

Some people are just terribly unoriginal and go through life copying their friends dress style, hair style, home decor style, choice of car and hobbies etc... and baby names! I know a few of of these types. I have one acquaintance who I point blank refuse to say where I buy my clothes from because she is guaranteed to show up a week later wearing the same thing as me. Not as annoying as copying a baby name perhaps but still...

BlackAmericanoNoSugar · 15/05/2016 20:20

Tell her that you wish you could have two more DDs as you really wish you had used (insert two names of similar style to your twins) instead of the ones that you did use.

Ilovewillow · 15/05/2016 20:22

Whilst you don't own the names to use them exactly in this way is a bit single white female!!

SoThatHappened · 15/05/2016 20:26

Well maybe she didnt know she liked the names until she heard them and never wold have thought of them herself.

You only get one shot in life and given that she isnt related to you, why shouldnt she use names she has realised she likes? It really doesnt affect you that much.

It is weird though

Becky546 · 15/05/2016 20:26

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

wasonthelist · 15/05/2016 20:33

OP why was it so important to have "rare" names in the first place?

gingerbreadmanm · 15/05/2016 20:37

Did you say first and second too so like emma louise smythe, jane mary smythe and shes going to go for emma louise smith and jane mary smith?

Weird. Very weird. As others have said though not a lot you can do except be glad yours are older.

Fwiw a close family friend called her daughter the same name as mine which wasnt at all common at the time and as i was growing up i always found it quite flattering someone was named after me Grin

wombthereitis · 15/05/2016 20:41

Nope, YANBU. At all. Thats a bit creepy really Confused

Elle80 · 15/05/2016 20:42

She is the one that will look like a tit so I wouldn't worry about it TBH. YANBU she sounds very odd, and if supposing she is winding you up, it's still an odd thing to 'joke' about

Oysterbabe · 15/05/2016 20:45

Yabu for giving your DD an "unusual" spelling. I hate it when people do that.

MiddleClassProblem · 15/05/2016 20:47

She sounds creepy, middle names too. I'm getting flashes of single white female in my head. Just keep an eye out for her dressing the same, hair cut copying etc

gladisgood · 15/05/2016 20:48

YANBU
It's strange in a small community - one name maybe could overlap ( she may have loved it for years before being pregnant/you naming your child) - but two?! Bollocks! She's just a copying weirdo. or I hope she is joking!

HooseRice · 15/05/2016 20:48

My neighbour called his dogs my kids' names. serves me right for for calling them Fido and Rex

MiddleClassProblem · 15/05/2016 20:48

OP why was it so important to have "rare" names in the first place?
She explained that in the op Hmm
And it's how lots of people feel when naming a child. I know we did.

DinosaursRoar · 15/05/2016 20:53

wasonthelist - being one of 4 of my name in my class at school (and with the middle name of over half the girls in the class!), I can completely understand the OP's desire to have an unusual name.

JingsAndCrivens · 15/05/2016 20:54

What a fruit loop! It would piss me off and I'd probably say something about how weird I found it all.

YouTheCat · 15/05/2016 21:03

Are you due to have your baby first?

DinosaursRoar · 15/05/2016 21:11

YouTheCat - the OP already has 2 DD! The friend is going to name her twin girls the same names as 2 girls already living in the same small village.

It's really odd

What does her DH think? does he know your DDs? Can someone not have a quiet word that it marking them out as crazy?

ManonCrempog · 15/05/2016 21:16

This happened to me and my sister- twin girls were given the same (v. unusual) names as we had. We were about 7 at the time and quite flattered, but I think the twin girls have found it hard, growing up. It's a really odd thing to do.

haveacupoftea · 15/05/2016 21:19

She's probably winding you up because you've been precious about your unusual baby names Grin

wasonthelist · 15/05/2016 21:22

Sorry still not getting the need for unique names - mine's quite common, were quite a few of us in school, some in my class at times - it never bothered me - why does it matter?

JingsAndCrivens · 15/05/2016 21:23

What's there to 'get' beyond recognising that some people prefer more unusual names?