Neither of us changed our names when we got married and we have never encountered any of the problems some of you have mentioned.
No one has thought be were kidnappers when we travel aboard with our children. No one has asked if we were actually married or just co habiting ( because that woudl be rude and none of their business ) .
No one has questioned our right to deal with the school,doctors, teachers, HCP because we have a different name. They just want to know that we are that child's parent - our name or marital status is irelevant to that .
Indeed, I woudl be unhappy about colluding with such a system, as it discriminates against unmarried couples , same sex couples and other " non traditional " families.
We feel like a " proper family " ( whatever that is ) , one unit, our children are not traumatised , our frends , families and neighbours politely accept our wishes to be called what we want to be called.
Neither of us consider our names to be not ours, but in fact our fathers. We have had them all our lives, that makes them ours. I don't understand why other women feel that their surname isn't really their, it's belongs to their fathers. Whereas their husbands name is actually his. Why can men own their names in a way women do not ?
We know lots of couples who have changed one or both names and other have changed neither. I think it's entirely their own business.
I admire the creativity of those who have made totally new names for theirselves ,double barrelled, whatever. I think diversity is fun and I love the way they are creating new traditions that say something about their own family and what it means to them .
I'm amazed to see so many posters have never met a woman who hasn't changed her name and never met a man who has. I can't imagine where you live ( assuming it's in a liberal western democracy ) . Please don't say a small scottish island, BTW , as I'll know you are making it up 