Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be really upset that Grandparents are moving to be near favourite grandchildren

150 replies

betty10k · 18/03/2014 14:02

This might be a long one....
We're very lucky that our in laws live nearby and have my son (19 months) one day a week and the rest of the week he goes to nursery as we both have to work full time to pay the bills. I miss him immensely and wish i didn't have to work 5 days a week and commute but i do. It was softened by the fact that he was with his grandparents once a week and they love having him - always said it was the highlight of their week. He is close to them and i feel so grateful that he has a close relationship with them. Way back when we started talking about having a family they always said they wanted to have him/her once a week, there were ideas about him going to the local primary school which is walking distance from their house and him going back to theirs everyday for his tea. All dreams and all far off i know but my parents moved abroad when i was young so all this was important to me. I'm also an only child so this is probably where some of this unreasonableness and lack of understanding is coming from....?

Everything changed last year when my brother and sister in law + 3 grandchildren (all over 10) moved to the other end of the country (4hours away). Grandparents were distraught and slowly but surely they started dropping the days they could do so they could go up there and see them and stay there. They have a holiday cottage where they can stay. (This obviously was a bit of a pain as we've had to use up our holiday to look after him when they've not been able to) So i suppose you could say he would be better off in nursery all week. But it's just not what we wanted and nor can we afford it.

They got back from 2 weeks staying with brother in law on Sunday. My husband dropped my little boy off at his grandparents this morning as usual and they announced they wanted to move to be near them (4hours away) and would be selling up and obviously wouldn't be able to have our son anymore. Husband is upset but like most blokes probably won't say anything. Although he did say he's not surprised and he always comes last anyway and no'one in his family tells him anything so from this i take it that he clearly does care. Grandparents whole family live in the same area so they won't just be leaving us.

I've now gone from angry to upset. I never thought they'd actually go as when mentioned before they said they wouldn't because we needed them. This is true. But more than anything i'm upset for my son because like my husband he's been put last by them and he adores them. I've got to see them tonight and i don't want to (sounds pathetic i know but i don't deal with confrontation well and will probably cry) What do i do or say? Tell the truth or just let the resentment simmer?

The relationship we have with them will be so different. We don't have much spare time, husband is self employed trying to grow his business and works 6-7 days a week so we will only be able to visit them twice a year at most. We have a small cottage with not much room for visitors whereas they can go and stay with brother in law whenever they like in the holiday cottage they have. Their kids are all over 10 ours isn't yet 2 and hopefully one day we will be able to afford to have another one so i thought they'd want to be here to see them grow up and be a part of that. But i can understand that brother in law's family have more time for them as sister in law doesn't work so life is one long party - family dinners every week etc. (trying not to sound jealous but i am - i'd love to be able to look after my child myself and not work!)

So a very long rambling AIBU which isn't written very well. Can someone give me some advice without making me cry please.

OP posts:
cory · 18/03/2014 14:41

picnicbasketcase Tue 18-Mar-14 14:28:49
"This is going to sound horrible and probably is, but I think I'd just let it go, they've clearly made their choice which part of the family means more to them and is more important to see so I would bother with them as little as possible from now on. Not because of them no longer being able to babysit, because that attitude obviously would be selfish in the extreme, but because I'd find it so hurtful that my family didn't seem to matter compared to the SIL's family."

So does that mean that the BIL and SIL should have bothered with them as little as possible when they chose to stay near the OP? Why is it more hurtful that they want to be near one child than that they want to be near another? Would it not equally be favouritism if they preferred being close to the OP's family?

As another poster pointed out, these IL's are between a rock and a hard place; they can't choose to live close to both children.

I know my mother was upset when I emigrated to marry dh. But he had parents too, who loved him just as well. There was no way we could choose to be near both pairs; the only fair solution would have been an oil platform in the middle of the North Sea and that wouldn't really have been much good to anyone.

Mandy21 · 18/03/2014 14:41

If you can't afford one extra day at nursery for your DS, how are you going to afford a 2nd child?

If it is indeed about your relationship with them (and your child's) rather than the childcare, there are ways of maintaining it. My parents live abroad for most of the year, but we still phone them probably every other day, Skype them a couple of times a week, they are still very much involved in the children's lives.

It does take much more effort, but if you say thats important to you, then you can do it so that the relationship continues.

Goblinchild · 18/03/2014 14:42

The grandparents could also point out that it's three grandchildren and one grandchild that they are having to choose between, and at under two, they may think that whatever they do with him won't be memorable for him, so they may not think of the relationship in quite those terms.
I was living in Germany when I was two, can't remember a thing about it, or all the people that were close to me and loved me.

DomesticSlobbess · 18/03/2014 14:44

YABU. Wherever they live they will be away from one set of grandchildren. They can't stay put and not live the life they want because you need free childcare.

This obviously was a bit of a pain as we've had to use up our holiday to look after him when they've not been able to

Erm... he's your child. It's not "looking after", it's parenting.

picnicbasketcase · 18/03/2014 14:47

I'm not saying the OP should cut all contact or anything like that, just that I personally would find it hard to keep the same relationship when they'd made it clear that they care more about regular contact with the other family. If they moved away but were somewhere halfway between the two families, that would at least be something but to move to roughly the same place sends quite a strong message. Having said that, it's a good point about whether it's a particularly idyllic location they'd be moving to, as a restful retirement plan rather than just 'to be close to family'.

Forgettable · 18/03/2014 14:53

If we were talking about caring more for one family then the ILs would have moved long before the youngest grandchild came on the scene, yes?

I think you'll find in time that there is an issue or issues that the other family are having that the grandparents feel being on-tap will help, but haven't shared with you and DH yet.

betty10k · 18/03/2014 14:54

OwlCapone - sorry to confuse. We didn't want to take their day away from them because they say how much they love being with him but i have asked the nursery if they could take him and we will find the money. This post wasn't meant to sound like i was upset just because of the childcare, that's only a very small part of it because they wanted it so much and have been encouraging me to have another baby so they can look after it. The 1 day's childcare is only money and is irrelevant in the scheme of things. I'm upset because we will miss them and i'm upset because my son won't have such a close relationship with them.

Bit horrible to assume we use them for free childcare.... that's most certainly not true.

Thanks everyone else for your advice, i'm just upset and yes i will come to terms with it. Sorry if i sounded grabby and entitled i didn't mean to. I've been fighting back the tears all day and boss keeps looking at me funny.

The holiday home is on BIL & SIL's property and belongs to them they won't be moving into that they will be buying their own property nearby. We live in a lovely part of the country it is about moving to be near them not about the area.

Talking it through has helped thank you!

OP posts:
betty10k · 18/03/2014 14:56

Mandy21 we will afford a 2nd child when we've saved up for it and my son is at school so we only have 1 set of nursery fees.

Forgettable - In laws only moved at the end of last year so they've given it 5 months and now decided to follow them

OP posts:
LoonvanBoon · 18/03/2014 14:57

But picnic, moving in between the two families would mean they were 2 hours from them both, so there would be no real benefits for anyone!

I don't think you're being unreasonable to feel the way you do, OP, but like other posters I just don't see there's much you can do about it. Will your PIL be living in their holiday cottage when they move away, or will they be buying somewhere else? Will there be room for you to go and stay? Will your PIL be able to stay with friends / in local B&Bs when they come back to visit you, as you haven't got space?

One thing I do think your DH has a right to be a bit annoyed about is the way they told him the news. Springing it on him when he was dropping off your child & then presumably on his way to work wasn't exactly making it easy for him to express any concerns / disappointment to his parents. Do you think they did that deliberately so as to prevent any discussion?

It does sound a bit as if you are a bit jealous of your BIL / SIL, or at least their lifestyle - understandable if they're living somewhere lovely & have lots of free time etc. How are your relationships with them? Are you able to stay in their home, as your PIL have been doing?

Oh, & it was a bit off of your PIL to change Christmas plans at the last minute if they'd already agreed to come to you. This obviously isn't just about where they live, but about a sense of favouritism, which is really difficult to deal with. Is this part of a long-standing pattern - ie. going back to childhooed - & is this an issue for DH?

betty10k · 18/03/2014 14:58

DomesticSlobbess - fair point that sentence sounds really bad sorry!

OP posts:
cory · 18/03/2014 14:59

So does that mean the SIL and BIL should have found it hard to keep the same relationship if they hadn't moved?

LoonvanBoon · 18/03/2014 14:59

X-posted with you, betty, I've read the bit about the holiday cottage now. Have SIL / BIL invited you to stay there since they moved?

betty10k · 18/03/2014 15:05

LoonvanBoon - we will make it work when it happens. Yes i'm a little bit jealous of SIL's lifestyle but just because in an ideal world i'd like to work a bit less and see more of my son like SIL does with her children. (please don't slate me for saying i'm jealous) It's not a big thing and it's something we've talked about and she understands. We are friends although the distance has made that harder like with any friendship. Yes we've been to visit once but husband works a lot so we can't go very often (which yes is his choice as someone said earlier but in the world we live in that is what we have to do to pay the bills!)

OP posts:
Floggingmolly · 18/03/2014 15:07

Yabu. You say in your first post that you don't do confrontation well...
Please don't even think of confronting them about their decision; it really is none of your business.

betty10k · 18/03/2014 15:08

Oh and it's their son and daughter in law.

OP posts:
betty10k · 18/03/2014 15:10

Floggingmolly - by confrontation i actually meant any sort of conversation about a subject that upsets me. So i'd cry!

They want to talk about it tonight.

OP posts:
Goblinchild · 18/03/2014 15:10

I understand Betty, my SIL doesn't work, has a house with an entire floor of guest bedrooms and grounds rather than a garden.
My other SIL has several holidays a year including a cruise with just the two of them.
I'm marrying for money in my next life. Grin

betty10k · 18/03/2014 15:10

Perhaps envious is a better word than jealous!

OP posts:
TheBody · 18/03/2014 15:12

can see why you are upset op but say in our case we have 4 kids, last 2 teens.

who would we hurt by moving nearer to/away from.

the GP lives are theirs to do with what they choose and you can't really judge them for that. sure they don't mean to hurt anyone.

in your op you mentioned your dc going to their house after school for tea every day? that's really a dream of what family life might be not how it is in reality.

hugs though and I don't think you sound entitled just sad.

LoonvanBoon · 18/03/2014 15:14

You're right, betty, envious is a better word - & I think it's human nature to be a bit envious in the circumstances. Hope it goes okay tonight. I think it's reasonable to say you're disappointed & will miss them, although you understand their decision. Also okay to talk about how they will keep in contact etc., I'd have thought. Good luck!

diddl · 18/03/2014 15:14

It might not be that they prefer the other GC-surely they haven't said that?

Just that they get to see more of the others as they work less for example?

betty10k · 18/03/2014 15:14

Goblinchild you just made me smile for the 1st time today thank you!

OP posts:
TheBody · 18/03/2014 15:14

it's fine to want more op and fine to be envious. it's human.

I am banking in a lottery win tonight. Grin

zirca · 18/03/2014 15:15

I think if it was me, I'd just arrange full-time nursery asap, and that would be that. Then you and your DC know where you all are, and the in-laws can do whatever they want, but it won't affect you.

betty10k · 18/03/2014 15:15

diddl i think you've hit the nail on the head - this obviously makes me even more envious of SIL's lifestyle!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread