Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pretty uncomfortable with home circumcision

578 replies

EastofEast · 20/10/2013 20:31

We get on very well with our neighbours and are pretty close but I was a bit shocked today, one of those moments where you find you really have opposing views on something quite fundamental.

Neighbour has a (gorgeous) two week old boy. She knocked on the door earlier to return my car keys (went to get a new battery for hers in my car) and I mentioned her new ds was unsettled for the first time ever; joking maybe he wasn't the perfect baby after all. My baby is demanding much more vocal about her needs. She said it was because he was circumcised today. I must have looked a little put off, I don't agree with it at all, as she then said 'oh he's doing really well. We were lucky the doctor came to house to do this one, all the others had to go to a clinic'. I was stunned, I'm amazed you're allowed to do such a thing at home in such an unregulated way. Frankly I wouldn't allow any deliberate harm to come to a child that wasn't medically necessary, but considering some people do do it I thought the rules would be tighter. We're both from (different) backgrounds which circumcise, although I refused to change my son, and I knew she'd do it after a related chat about whether fgm was that bad over a coffee one day but it's still upset me a bit the way it's done. The poor little thing is grumpy with loads of adults around to celebrate the event passing him round and round at 8.30pm.

I know the circumcision vs no circumcision has been done already, and not everyone shares my strong views, but at home? Should this be ok? I can't think of other similar procedures happening in a similar environment.

OP posts:
jellybeans · 24/10/2013 17:20

Yes I think any alteration of a child's genitals is wrong unless medically indicated.

MajorieDawes · 24/10/2013 17:34

jellybeans

I'm not saying I know better than anyone. But then again I'm not speaking in absolutes either.

I'm aware that there are various websites with men who regret having been circumcised. I don't personally know anyone or what their reasons are (perhaps they'd have similar angst over other parenting issues, who knows?).

I'm not sure if I would circumcise or not but if I did, it would be in the hope that I would get it right and that my son would be like the other men I know and pleased that he had been circumcised as a baby. Similarly, if I didn't, I'd also hope that I'd got it right given my family's cultural background and the potential that he could grow up and regret that he'd then have to face a more complicated and painful procedure.

It's kind of similar to many other parenting decisions I've had to make - although I'm glad I didn't have to make this particular one.

MajorieDawes · 24/10/2013 17:37

It would be their regret to have though if they made the choice as an adult.

One of my goals as a parent is to try to minimise the regrets my children have as adults about my parenting decisions while they were children.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread