Active discussions

Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Talk
AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Original poster

Is it ever appropriate to break the 4 walls of a family and tell a friend a family secret?

43 replies

HoveringKestrel · 30/04/2013 01:19

If a family problem is bothering you, like your sister is having a problem with her husband, or if your Mum is feeling down and asked you not to tell anybody, or even if you have a problem of your own....

Do you trust a friend?

OP posts:
BookieMonster · 30/04/2013 01:32

Some "secrets" are a very heavy burden to carry on your own. If you have a trusted friend who can give you support and advice that eases that burden, I don't think it is wrong.

WafflyVersatile · 30/04/2013 01:34

I was not aware that there were walls round a family that should not be breached. Maybe you could tell us more about that because talking to others about a 'private family situation' is exactly sort of thing abusive people tend to forbid.

My view on this is roughly as follows.

If someone offloads to me then this becomes part of my life, my burden, it affects me, and I'm entitled to talk about my feelings on this matter to a confidante of my own. However I should be be considerate of who I talk to.

Sometimes someone will confide a secret or talk about a sensitive issue with me that they would not want me to share with others for whatever reason. If I feel the need to talk about this I tend to choose someone who is unconnected to that person. For instance my sister is never likely to meet any of my mates as we live far away from one another. So I might tell her what is going on in a friend's life and vice versa.

AdoraBell · 30/04/2013 01:36

I have two friends I know I can trust with anything. You'd have to be absolutely sure you could trust the friend. If not you might talk to someone like a GP or counsellor.

Original poster
HoveringKestrel · 30/04/2013 01:43

What WafflyVersatile says makes a lot of sense, however I'm curious why AdoraBell mentioned counselling. It's two different approaches completely. I have never considered counselling. Hmm

OP posts:
WafflyVersatile · 30/04/2013 01:46

Well we don't have any knowledge of the problem you have in mind. Counselling or a doctor (or a priest!) might be more appropriate if you don't feel a friend is appropriate.

Original poster
HoveringKestrel · 30/04/2013 02:03

No no. Its not horrendous. I'm not about to make shockwaves. I was just wondering when/where you feel the 4 walls of a family spills over to your friends :)

OP posts:
Nehru · 30/04/2013 02:05

What's this 4 walls crap?

DonDrapersAltrEgoBigglesDraper · 30/04/2013 02:09

I don't quite get what you mean by '4 walls' either - do you mean private family matters?

Original poster
HoveringKestrel · 30/04/2013 02:12

Yes sorry, I mean 4 walls as in a family matter.

OP posts:
Original poster
HoveringKestrel · 30/04/2013 02:12

And its not 'crap', everyone has family issues that u don't want others a party to.

OP posts:
ExRatty · 30/04/2013 02:13

It depends on whether or not you feel overburdened by the secret.
Examine your need to tell someone. Has it to do with wanting to gain a fresh perspective or to help you process your thoughts and emotions? If so then I'd probably speak to a friend but remove all markers about it being to do with my family.
If it comes from a necessity to gossip. Name change and spill on MN or Twitter

Original poster
HoveringKestrel · 30/04/2013 02:21

I mean in a.....'he is treating me bad, don't tell anyone'.....or.....'I'm unhappy, don't tell anyone'..... Nothing sinister like I think people are taking it. Just.....when do you tell your friends?

If you want them to know all about you, do you tell them all about your family and their family members whose decisions and problems affects you?

OP posts:
AdoraBell · 30/04/2013 02:37

Depends what the secret is Hoveringkestral some are simply private info, others can cause the only person who knows huge amounts of stress effecting their life by having to keep it to themselves.

HintofBream · 30/04/2013 06:36

If you cannot keep a secret, neither will your friend.

TheRealFellatio · 30/04/2013 06:43

My experience, in confiding in people who are close to me is that almost ALWAYS go on to tell someone else. I hate that. I inherently distrust most people and I prefer not to tell things that I need to stay private to anyone now. I just cannot rely on anyone to keep a secret. My mum has told my ex MIL things, my sister tells my mum things, my mum tells my sister and vice versa. I don't even feel I can always trust my DH not to blurt something out that I would prefer stayed between the two of us. I don't think they mean any harm by it - they just assume that as we all care about one another then it won't matter, but it matters a lot to me. If you really, really need something to stay a secret then the only person you can really trust is yourself. don't tell anyone unless you have to.

I am more likely to tell a friend something, as few of my very close friends know one another, so there is less risk of cross contamination! Even then though - I rarely confide in people where the very big things are concerned, and I don't tell Mumsnet either - at least not under my usual name.

dogsandcats · 30/04/2013 07:00

I think it is a a balancing act.

Partly it will depend on the issue.
Partly it will depend on what sort of friends you have.
Partly it will depend on what your family members are like themselves about talking about their own issues.

dogsandcats · 30/04/2013 07:03

You mentioned about "if you want friends to know all about you".

I, for instance wouldnt tell them necessarily tell them what colour underwear I am wearing that day, so no, even to friends, you never tell them everything.

MexicanHouseThief · 30/04/2013 07:17

Agree with dogsandcats' post of 7.00.55. I would and do talk to my oldest friend about my dysfunctional family and their various issues, and vice versa. People in my family are incapable of having honest conversations with each other, which makes family secrets massively toxic and stressful. If I didn't discuss stuff with my friends I would go bananas.

tethersend · 30/04/2013 07:22

It really depends on the secret.

Incest or abuse for example, should be told.

yellowhousewithareddoor · 30/04/2013 07:30

Are we not supposed to talk about family stuff then? Oops.

Andro · 30/04/2013 08:18

Depends on the secret I guess, but I will talk about most things with my best friend (who I am significantly closer to than my own siblings...to put it mildly).

Triumphoveradversity · 30/04/2013 08:25

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

diddl · 30/04/2013 08:33

"If you want them to know all about you, do you tell them all about your family and their family members whose decisions and problems affects you?"

No, because that's not about me, it's about other people.

AuntieStella · 30/04/2013 08:35

If you want to continue to be confided in, then you don't tell.

If you do not want to be recipient of those confidences, tell the person who is seeking your help that you don't want to hear as you feel unable to respect their privacy.

AnyFucker · 30/04/2013 08:36

I think it must be utterly awful not to have someone you can trust Sad

Swipe left for the next trending thread