Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Re OH's attitude to MIL, I need some outside perspective (sorry it's v v long)

110 replies

Bearmonkeysmum · 04/02/2013 22:47

Apologies for another MIL related threat but I have no one rl to talk to about this. Bit of backstory first to hopefully shed a bit more light on the situation.

My MIL is generally ok and although we are very different people we have always gotten on reasonably well. My OH is a but of a mummy's boy & has always said MIL comes first in his life until we have DCs when it will be me & them. Oh & mil always spent a lot of time together before we got together (tea together at least once a week, shopping etc) & since moving in together I have encouraged oh to sometimes go without me as I know how much mil likes this (we do go as a family too).

In the last 18 months we have gotten engaged, found out I was pg a few days after engagement & had our lovely ds. MIL is very funny about people finding out things before her, people being more involved in stuff than she is & not behaving in a way she sees as appropriate (although this wasn't apparent before all this). Oh supports this & is very funny about mil being equal in everything with my mum. Oh is very squeamish so I had said I wanted him in labour room & my mum on standby if he was struggling (not definitely in the room but just as backup for him). Initially he was fine but later said that my mum wasn't coming in if his couldn't. We had a massive row about it but eventually he saw my pov & was ok with it (mil not, overheard her moaning to him about it when she thought I wasn't in).

In the first 4mths of ds life it was like oh was logging every minute of time my mum spent with ds to make sure she wasn't getting more time than mil. Making lots of comments like your mums been 2x this week so mil will have to come 4x next week to make up (she was on holiday at the time & my mum had literally popped in with gifts from family abroad & a pint of milk). The keeping score thing has eased off a little since then but not much.

What has really brought it all to a head for me was christmas (I know it was a while back). I'm on smp& had saved money for Xmas gifts, so had a set budget for everyone. Oh then decides to spend more of his own money on mil (fair enough, his cash) & spent most of December going on about getting mil a special charm from the baby as he thinks as grandma she should get something nice. I said it was a lovely idea but that I couldn't afford to do anything similar for my mum although she would love something like that. Come Xmas day & after we've exchanged gifts, oh decides to make a big show oh giving mil her gift from ds (everyone else's gifts were labelled from us as a family) & really laying on thick how we thought she should get a special gift from the baby. My poor mum is sitting there smiling while mil & oh are in raptures. I could tell she was upset but she didn't say anything. I was very upset (still am tbh, hence posting here). Oh didn't get me anything from ds (I didn't expect anything) but when he saw that he realised he had stuff from ds, he quickly pointed to one of his presents to me (that I had already opened & he had said were from him) & said "oh btw, that was from ds".

Aibu to want to say actually your everything has to equal rule is bs & I'm really pissed off?

There are other things that have lead to me feeling like this but you would be losing days of your life reading them.

I love my oh, he is a great dad & fiancé but I can't shake the upset tat this causes me. I've got horrendous pmt at the moment & I don't think it's helping. I am probably overreacting here but because I'm so emotional about it all I don't feel like I can look at it objectively.

I would like your perspective please mners, I can't talk to oh as he always thinks I am attacking mil & won't listen.

Thanks & well done if you got this far.

X

OP posts:
SilverOldie · 05/02/2013 17:33

He sounds like a manchild and I doubt he will ever grow up and treat you the way he should. What he did re giving his mother the bracelet from your DC was awful, your poor DM.

I went out with someone like this. He eventually decided I should have the 'honour' of meeting his mother. A long train journey and he refused to have a beer (which he normally enjoyed) because his DM would smell it on his breath.
On arrival she met us at the station and before even saying hello, she took one look at his newly grown beard, turned to me and said 'I suppose this was your idea'.

It was a very stilted atmosphere in her house and for something to say, I mentioned that she had some beautiful (antique) furniture. She replied 'don't touch it, it's precious to me' and her son agreed. After the journey home I ran for the hills, no way was I having her as my MIL.

You either put him straight about his priorities, ie you and DC first and sort out your money issues or I would seriously advise you not to marry this man.

I'm sad for you being in this relationship.

EuroShagmore · 05/02/2013 17:44

OP, I am glad that you have come back and that the blunt comments have not upset you. Counselling sounds like a good way forward.

Atavistic · 05/02/2013 18:19

Bearmonkey, thanks for coming back to the thread.
I had an issue with my DH last weekend, under a previous NN, posted about it here, and sent a link to my DH. It was really helpful for him to see other people's opinion.

Could you do similar? You have been very kind about your husband, and I think you've tried to be fair. It really is such a complex situation, and could your DH benefit from all these outsiders opinions?

For my part, I've had a major lightbulb moment, having read what OxfordBags had to say about covert incest. In common, I'm sure, with alot of others posters who have felt compelled to post on your thread, I am laden down with MIL baggage. I am now No Contact with my PILs, but am now fascinated to find out if the difficult MILs, that we mention occasionallyGrin, are, or were, unhappily married. Must start a fresh thread!

IHaveThatTshirt Good on you!

SquinkiesRule · 05/02/2013 19:58

Apart from the fact that your partner is very weird and life isn't fair you can't measure all the time the baby spends with everyone, why are you going through your savings to live on? You just had HIS baby, he needs to step up to the financial plate and support you and the baby more while you are off on leave.
Really the more I read the more twatty your partner sounds.

JamieandtheMagicTorch · 05/02/2013 20:11

Good luck OP

When I read Miggsie's post I was nodding my head

Peevish · 05/02/2013 20:11

Good for you, Bearmonkey. I think counselling - with a good counsellor, so do shop around till you find someone who suits you - is a good idea. As the mother of an only son (still a small baby), I'm all for close adult mother-son relationships, but there's close and there's claustrophobic to the extant of damaging his primary relationship.

It sounds to me as if it's not just that he sees his mother as a victim for whom he has to stand up (making you, ironically, her attacker, rather than the daughter in law who has just given her a grandchild!). All that shrill, childish 'keeping score' stuff sounds as if he has a weak sense of self - maybe because he has never quite broken away from his childish relationship to his mother, and is in some ways still not an adult. His mother sounds to me as if she has become for him a sort of symbol of his own vulnerability, and when he feels he's standing up for her, he's really like a child shouting 'Me, me, me!' because he feels at some unconscious level he's not getting enough attention, love etc.

In any case, you need to do something about it asap.

Uppermid · 05/02/2013 20:17

Wow! Just wow!

I don't think I can add anything else really, but my god does he need to grow up

Good luck tonight, think you're going to need it

hellsbellsmelons · 06/02/2013 13:45

Sooo... how did it go last night?
Anything resolved?
How are you feeling about it all now?
Really hope it went well.

FrankellyMyDearIDontGiveADamn · 07/02/2013 22:09

Any news OP?

foreverondiet · 07/02/2013 22:19

Completely out of order to give special gift to his mum in front of yours - he should have bought them both the same - I agree with the others that you need serious chat. Fwiw I always try and made it broadly fair / equal with my mil as my mum even though its more natural for me to spend time / ask for help from my mum. But he is behaving in ridiculous way.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page