Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to have found this really quite nasty and be offended?

105 replies

emsyj · 18/10/2012 12:20

OK, so this involves the dreaded Facebook ((sigh))...

A friend I met at work a few years back (who now lives on the other side of the world, so our only contact is via Facebook and emails) made a post yesterday along the lines, 'the fact that it's disguised as a cutesy monkey backpack doesn't detract from the fact that your kid is on a leash'. I assume she was referring to those backpacks with reins attached. DD has one of these, it was a gift from some friends and we have used it on occasion as she likes to walk, hates the buggy and won't reliably hold a hand (I guess it's tiring to reach up and hold an adult's hand for a long period when you're 2). So anyway, I replied saying that they were useful and better than the child running off and getting squashed by a car - all very light-hearted at this point, and I was in no way offended. A few other people (whom I don't know personally) posted too, just casual lighthearted type comments, nothing controversial.

However, later on in the day she replied with, 'Why can't you just put it in a pram or carry the child, putting it on a lead like a dog is demeaning for a child'. Hmm, so I thought this was quite rude - I am demeaning my child, am I? Hmm Also I am 6 months pg and DD weighs 30lb, so I couldn't carry her (even if either of us wanted that, which neither of us do!) and she doesn't like the buggy, she enjoys walking. How is it better to wrestle her into the buggy and listen to her scream and thrash around whilst I wheel her along?

I refrained from posting anything back but then later still, other people had responded to her and she then said that child reins are equivalent to putting people with mental disabilities and dementia on leads, and that you can 'feed your kid what you want, do what you want, but do it in public and expect others to have an opinion about it'. I was a bit Shock - and I don't really understand what her point is or why she would care so much, but AIBU to think this was a needlessly inflammatory thing to say? It seems that she is saying, (a) that I demean my child and that (b) my treatment of DD is akin to abuse of people suffering with dementia or disabled people. I was really really offended by this and have felt quite upset (pregnancy hormones) but am I being excessively precious?

Gosh, this is already long and I really didn't mean to turn it into a 'are reins okay' debate - I personally think they're fine, and I am happy for others to not like them/not approve etc, but I do draw the line at a so-called friend accusing me of abusing my child. Interestingly, this person is expecting her first baby so I posted back, 'I was a perfect parent before I had kids too - good luck with that.' Was that reasonable?

Still feel quite Sad about the whole thing.

OP posts:
Frontpaw · 18/10/2012 22:23

Didn't some moron spout that it was demeaning to the child amd harmful to their self esteem?

Viviennemary · 18/10/2012 22:28

Your friend sounds a total pain in the neck. You are doing the right thing keeping your child safe. What trouble Facebook seems to cause. But I suppose it's the people on it.

Morloth · 19/10/2012 01:13

Meh, some people are full of shit.

I have used the leash when necessary, people can get knotted if they don't like it.

I put the kid on a leash for the same reason I put the dog on a leash. So they get plenty of exercise in a nice safe controlled by me way.

SomersetONeil · 19/10/2012 02:01

It's highly possible that she will avoid using reigns with her own kids, if she's that determined. But it's beside the point - why in earth does she give a shiney one what other people do with their own kids?

And why does she think placing a set of reigns on a child demeans them? It might demean her to wear them, sure, but I've yet to see a single reigned child look even the slightest bit demeaned when they've had the on.

I mean, come on - as if a 1 or 2 year-old has the wherewithal to be demeaned by a pair of reigns. Grin Anyone who wears nappies and relies on other people to clean their bums for them without batting an eyelid is hardly going to be in the therapists chair in 20 years time because of a set of reigns.

FangsGoForTheMaidensThroat · 19/10/2012 03:46

Why did she bring people with disabilities into it anyway? She sounds like a massive arse. I use a wrist strap with my DD who s 6 and has SN, to stop her getting run over, not to 'demean' her.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page