Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or a bit control freak-ish?

105 replies

BrideofGromit · 07/05/2012 13:35

I need perspective on this as I am really aware that I can be prickly due to issues with my own family. I just wonder whether this kind of thing would bother other normal people.

My PILs are basically nice people. But they tend to treat DH and me like children. Some of the stuff they do I consider quite patronising and bit rude and I can't help feeling pissed off, even though behind it all they're just trying to be kind, I think. For example, when they come to visit, they never tell us what time they're going to arrive. The time before last I had to ask MIL about five times when they would actually be arriving before I got a straight answer. She acted as though I was asking something a bit odd by just trying to figure out when they'd be here. This time around DH had to ask them twice and they still didn't give a specific time, just a two-hour window which meant we couldn't bring DS out for a walk in case they arrived. Do other people expect visitors to give a fairly specific ETA (I mean maybe a half hour window) or am I being a bit uptight?

We bought our house not long ago and it needs a lot of work. Anytime PILs visit MIL always tells us what work she is going to do on the house (usually something in the garden) without actually asking if we want it done. Basically she is being helpful but often she takes on massive jobs without having time to finish them so we are left with a mess in the garden which means it's not safe for our toddler to run around. BTW she usually springs her projects on us when she arrives - she comes in with armfuls of gardening tools and then just gets up and starts on it later in the day without asking and without any notion of what we might want to do. Again, it's basically helpful but I know if they're visiting I might as well write the day off as I will be stuck in with DS trying to keep him away from whatever Nanna is doing in the garden. Not my idea of fun.

MIL always either turns up with a ton of food, or ends up buying a ton of food which we end up having to throw out. This is the one that annoys me the most actually. We are grown adults capable of feeding ourselves and for providing guests with lunch and dinner. And yet she turns up with acres of food that we don't want as if the cupboards are going to be bare. One time it was a massive bag of carrots which had to be chucked eventually, last time it was a massive bag of peppers, also chucked, this time it was a massive dish of macaroni cheese which will soon be chucked. It's bizarre and, IMO, rude, to turn up with food that your hosts don't necessarily want.

So hit me with it, AIBU? Would these things annoy you or am I just a bitch? DH listens to my whining about these things with amiable good grace but I do get the sense that he thinks I'm a whingy moaner. He's used to his mother trying to control everything.

OP posts:
EndoplasmicReticulum · 07/05/2012 22:11

My mum is the "gardening fairy". I didn't realise for a long time that she was doing it, I guess I just thought we had self-weeding borders or something....

I don't mind in the slightest, as I don't have time for gardening.

Slambang · 07/05/2012 22:34

Oh dear. I'm terrified of being a MIL to someone like you.
So how can I manage not to piss off my future DIL?

Share spare food and pop a macaroni cheese in the freezer every now and then? (No that's rude and implies she can't cook.)

Help out unbidden with household tasks that she hasn't got time to do?
(No that's interefering and controlling.)

You sound a bit spoilt and control freakish to me.

And as for a 2 hour window not being specific enough for you for their arrival time. What??? Just what??? Just exactly how important are you and how many lives will you be saving in that 2 hours?

Get over yourself for the sake of your dh and dcs having a good relationship with what sound like lovely PILs.

NoOnesGoingToEatYourEyes · 07/05/2012 22:42

Can you not make soup with the carrots and peppers?

I'm sorry, I know there is a bigger issue but I just can't get over the pepper chucking. Shock

Perhaps they don't give you an exact time because they are travelling along way and worry about being late? Or they might be a bit relaxed about what time the want to set off, take their time on the drive, appreciate the motorway service stations (Stransham is lovely as service stations go Smile)

And just go for your walk. If they only give a two hour window say "okay, DS usually likes to get out for a bit but we will only be at the park. If you arrive while were are there give us a ring and we'll come back or you can come to meet us there."

The projects sound annoying but well meaning. I think you might have to preempt her though and either say you'd rather she didn't start a big project she won't have time to finish or drop a big hint about a smaller job you'd appreciate her input on.

If you like I can give you a delicious recipe for roasted tomato and red pepper soup so you don't have to chuck any more vegetables out. You could even improvise and roast the carrots for it too.

NoOnesGoingToEatYourEyes · 07/05/2012 22:44

Meant to say, the soup freezes so you can do it in portions and have it for up to a month after making it.

EldritchCleavage · 08/05/2012 16:03

Ha ha, your MIL is my mother (except for gardening, she doesn't do that).

I did get very annoyed about the time thing. My mother has to know down to the quarter hour what time we will arrive when we visit them, but used to somehow avoid telling me when she and my father would arrive. Or how long they would stay. Or even that they were visiting at all. Apparently, if she told my siblings, or even just though it to herself, that counted as adequate notice. I read the riot act over that one. I had to remind them about it recently, when for some reason I never quite grasped, telling me when they intended to arrive for Christmas was not possible. It is really quite infantilising, somehow, for parents just to descend without notice. And it really isn't about being unwelcome (I love my parents dearly), just about respect and consideration.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page