I agree that teenage girls mostly don’t get the option to make up their own minds, because they are hearing the story from one side - the side that says it’s normal to remove public hair. People say ‘everyone can choose’ but you can’t choose if only half of the story or argument has been presented.
These things are cultural. When women in their 50s were teens, women had bikini waxes so ounces didn’t stick out, but removing everything wasn’t the norm or considered more hygienic. Many women still don’t remove pubes.
I think there’s an age before which, kids should be ‘natural’. Most mothers feel uncomfortable if an 8 year old wants to shave their legs or a 13 year old wants a boob-job. The idea of girls who’ve just grown pubic hair seeing it as something that needs removing, equally doesn’t feel quite right.
I think we have to accept that many of the current cultural norms have their roots in porn. It doesn’t mean everyone who removes pubic hair is intereted in porn, but it’s naive to think there’s no connection between todays trend and porn. Given 14 year old girls won’t be revealing their bits to anyone for a while, why do they need to remove the hair, even if later that’s what they want to do?
I guess the question is really whether we as mothers are discussing it with our DDs as the age they start getting pubic hair and several times later, and making sure they really do hear the different options.