Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not want family here on DATE NIGHT?

115 replies

ElizabethDarcy · 21/09/2011 11:58

DH and I have been looking forward to a date night for ages... theatre, dinner, which will lead onto a treat from DH when we get home (said treat not told to sister, but it's a sexy massage), next morning is Sunday and we want to sleep in (for a change... usually go to church). So we are really looking forward to Sat night :)

Cue sister... had some tears, rowed with housemate, crying on the phone, then texts me a looong text re how her house share wants to have friends over on Sat and as she has rowed with housemate she doesn't want to be there and can she come to us that night? She is aware we will out, but 'she doesn't mind being on her own, she will just chill at ours.. and sleep over'.

I love her and feel for her... but this is the ONE night that we want for US. She often stays over, which is fine, and we seldom say no to her. But it has put me in an awkward position. DH not keen to have her here, but he is a thoughtful man and her being single is a card often played, and he doesn't want ructions btwn us.

If she did stay, there goes our romance out the window and we'll have to get up early in the am (she will stay for the day then too, unwritten, she often does this).. and I'll have to listen to her moans (yet again)... when honestly, all I want is a relaxing, romantic Sat night and Sunday with my DH. And I am tiptoeing around my sister.... can she honestly not realise that our date doesn't end the minute we leave the theatre..??? That it might continue at home???

OP posts:
RedBlanket · 21/09/2011 21:49

If she's lying down on the couch and your DH has nowhere to sit, why don't you tell her to shift her arse?

I think you both need to stop babying her tbh.

ElizabethDarcy · 22/09/2011 08:56

Anniegetyourgun You could be right!

GenevieveHawkings Yes... she did. And there has been no reply. She is NEVER this quiet. Yes... we do think she takes the p when here... 'needing a relax'... increasing our workload... we never 'relax' at hers... as it's shared, plus we wouldn't be that rude!

anonacfr She shares as she's never grown up... says she cannot afford it... but everyone her age and in her profession rent/buy... except her... I think she doesn't want the responsibility of her own place tbh... she has never paid electricity/gas/council tax on her own... has had a cushy lifestyle.

Yes, it is used as a home from home... and if she weren't such a painful guest she'd be more welcome. And everything is about HER. DH will retire upstairs to his study as he's tired of listening to her woe/problems etc. If you let on that YOU have had a bad week too etc. she says we are comparing and gets shirty. Confused

GenevieveHawkings yes... he has his fav and I have my fav... tis all. Most of the time we are sitting together though!

FontSnob I agree with you. I hope you manage to arrange some time alone soon!

OP posts:
ElizabethDarcy · 22/09/2011 08:58

BeaOnSea 100% agree Bea!!

RedBlanket I agree. She is self indulgent. And gets the huff so quickly if something doesn't go her way... we try keep the peace. But to our detriment naturally, which we are tired of.

OP posts:
ledkr · 22/09/2011 09:01

I wonder if this is a power struggle of some sort,or a jealousy thing.
Either way put some boundaries in place,you are entitled to your own life.

ElizabethDarcy · 22/09/2011 09:14

DH says it's jealousy for sure. Yes, I am entitled to have a life of my own... and don't feel the need to involve her in every single bit of it... she tells me everything... but then goes on the 'well I don't have a partner to talk to like you do'. Honestly, the single card is played all the time. It's sad... as I really need to withdraw from her, and she is my sister.

OP posts:
Blu · 22/09/2011 09:37

My aunt stakes out territory around my mother. At Christmas she races to sit next to her while the present opening is going on, deliberately making sure that my Dad has to sit somewhere else. She comes to stay for days on end and tries to dictate everything what goes on the shopping list to what my Mum plants in the garden. She locks my Mum's time up b y involving her in doing the crossword.

Your sister will gradually encroach on your household and on you in the same way. Your DH is already retreating, in his own home.

You sound as if you have had a v rough time. Your DH is focussing on you and your relationship, wanting to do nice things for you - wanting to GIVE to you. Your sister is wanting to be in the limelight and wanting to TAKE from you - your time, your emotional energy and support for her self-infantalised lifestyle.

Why would you prioritise someone who takes over someone who gives and supports? Except in a genuine emergency. You are letting your DH down badly if you give in to your DSis.

I feel sorry for my Mum, but really, I have no respect for what she has allowed her deference to my aunt do to my Dad. Sad.

Look up Narcisisstic Personality and see if it applies to your DSis in any way.

Whatmeworry · 22/09/2011 09:44

IMO its time to be doing more things with DH, and just not being around so much. More Date Nights, days/weekends away etc :)

Also start pushing her a bit more when she is with you - talk more about yourself, do stuff while she is there, make her work more etc etc, so her comfort level starts to go down.

GenevieveHawkings · 23/09/2011 16:40

Hasn't your DH got any really hideous mates that you could offer to fix her up with ElizabethDarcy? You could invite him and her around for dinner. If she thinks you're always trying to palm her off with horrors you might be able to successfully scare her off! Alternatively it might work and then she'd be loved up and you won't see her for dust because she'll be on "date nights" all of her own!

OpenMouthInsertFoot · 23/09/2011 17:31

Still no reply?

She'll be sulking then.

I don't actually see anything wrong with telling her that she can't stay over because you have plans for the evening with your husband and you are planning on coming home from them and shagging wildly in every room of the house and you're not sure she'll enjoy his naked arse blocking the telly.

can't see the telly
ah now I can
gone again
back again
gone again
back again
gone again
back again

It'll just really put her off Question Time.

wakeupandsmellthecoffee · 24/09/2011 10:56

so whats happening then. ?

OpenMouthInsertFoot · 24/09/2011 11:04

I bet she stayed Grin

RedBlanket · 24/09/2011 17:34

Me too Openmouth

Whatmeworry · 24/09/2011 22:34

Yup odds not staying 1:100 :)

clappyhands · 25/09/2011 06:43

some good advice on here

what happened OP?

ElizabethDarcy · 04/10/2011 10:34

Hi!!! Well.... the text was never answered re Saturday night... we saw her on Friday night as planned, she was in a rotten mood. DH just told me 'ignore her'... she was behaving like a petulent child... all hard done by. We ignored her behaviour, saw the movie, she cheered up a bit afterwards when we went for a drink... but no mention of Saturday night. Since then she has sent a quick reply to a text... but is definitely cheesed... as she usually texts/calls every day.

I am enjoying the peace and quiet tbh BlushBlush

Thanks for all the fab advice here... I often think I am being a meany sister when I don't jump when she says jump.. and am sooooo tired of the 'woe is me, single sister' routine. I love her, I just don't particularly like her right now.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread