Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Rachel should have gone to Paris?

113 replies

Aworryingtrend · 12/07/2011 13:08

I watched (for the hundredth time) the last episode of Friends last night, and once again thought how unfair it was that Rachel gave up on her dream job in Paris to stay with needy Ross.

I would be interested to hear what feminists make of it but I'm too scared to post on there.

What do you think, was she right to stay or should she have gone to Paris?

OP posts:
Shellshocked1 · 12/07/2011 15:40

Skimummy, was going to say the same thing about delivery but just couldn't remember his best lines. I have the Series 10 DVD and on the outtakes they had to say 'it tastes like FEET' about 20 times because they were laughing so much.

AbsDuCroissant · 12/07/2011 15:44

Man, my eyes have been OPENED in relation to ross. I never realised he was such a controlling git. I think mostly because my one flatmate managed to convince me that he was a soppy geeky loser who was misunderstood and needed pity. Not. Any. More

The only guy I'd shag out of any of them would be Mike. He is lurvely, though I previously disliked him for his sleazy/cheesy character in Romeo and Juliet. Chandler looks, sounds and makes as bad jokes as my brother, and Joey is too stupid.

Mrs B - brilliant theory

BitOfFun · 12/07/2011 15:44

Here is the thread in Feminism...

BitOfFun · 12/07/2011 15:47

And there's a great analysis of Ross by ShowOfHands here too. I love Friends threads Grin

GetOrfMoiLand · 12/07/2011 15:52

Oh yes those outtakes when they piss themselves at 'it tastes like feet'.

I also die every time when he is getting into his leather trousers and is on the phone, he has been advised to put talc on his legs, then baby lotion, and he squeals 'it has turned into a type of paste' - the way he says paste cracks me up every time.

I am also surprised that DP hasn't stabbed me to death as every time we have moved house (3 times) I have gone PIVOT PIVOT at everything Grin

GetOrfMoiLand · 12/07/2011 15:52

BOF you are a geeeeeeenius

cjbartlett · 12/07/2011 15:55

I think Phoebe and joey would have got together if he wasn't in that daft spinoff which I watched

supergreenuk · 12/07/2011 15:55

She did the right thing. Love and family over career and money should win every time. Has no one ever seen The Family Man with Nicolas Cage.

AbsDuCroissant · 12/07/2011 16:14

That feminist thread is really interesting. I am contemplating starting one about that STUPID show Sex and the City, but it's scary over there.

Smellslikecatpee · 12/07/2011 16:33

OH MY GOD mrsbabookaloo, IT ALL MAKES SENSE NOW

you are brill, I am in awe, seriously as I read your theroy it all finally made sense.

KatieScarlett2833 · 12/07/2011 16:43

NO NO NO NO NO!

Phoebe should have married Joey

Monica should have married Richard (yum)

Chandler should have married Janice (my personal favourite charachter)

Ross should be single and alone and become extinct like the dinosaurs.

Rachel should have married Elizabeths Dad.

CherylWillBounceBack · 12/07/2011 16:54

So.....

  1. Ross is one of the great comedy characters.
  2. They were on a break when he slept with the copier girl, so you can't blame him for that.
  3. Ross had Ben in NY, so to ask him to choose between which child he see's more of is harsh.
  4. To whoever suggested it, the Dawson's creek ending was never appropriate for Friends, as Rachel and Joey didn't have the Pacey/Joey dynamic.
  5. Having said all that, Ross is also a complete idiot, so yes, YANBU. If she had gone to Paris, it would have been utterly reasonable.
HarrietJones · 12/07/2011 17:03

I'm losing hours to these threads. Have two friends and a SATC one to read

sassyTHEFIRST · 12/07/2011 17:07

Rachel and Joey would never have been alllowed. It's fine for (conservative, American) audiences to see a bright man end up with a dimmer girl but not vice versa. So Ross and Rachel = fine; Rachel and Joey = Uh,UH

KaraToytown · 12/07/2011 17:31

Where be the SATC one?

MsAnnThroppy · 12/07/2011 17:31

No no NO! Ross was not nice. Ever. I shall expound more after tea.

TheCrackFox · 12/07/2011 17:37

Completely agree that Phoebe and Joey should have ended up together.

CherylWillBounceBack · 12/07/2011 17:50

I agree MsAnnThroppy - Ross was always a deeply self obsessed, stupid person.

Funniest character in the show though.

VFVF · 12/07/2011 18:03

I remember watching a 'making of friends' show and it was actually Joey who they'd originally planned to end up with Monica!

BrandyAlexander · 12/07/2011 18:41

Oh I love this thread! It has always bugged me that Rachel stayed in New York as I couldn't stand him for all the reasons mentioned by the others. Have never said to anyone in RL because they might tell me to get a life!

HarrietJones · 12/07/2011 19:07

I'm on mobile so can't link but SATC is near the top in feminism as I've just posted

katz · 12/07/2011 19:15

Nah i can't see phoebe and joey together, however i can see Joey and Rachel if they'd let it develop like they did Monica and Chandler, although like above i'd have liked to have seen Monica with Richard and Chandler with Janice. Ross needed to just go away.

MsAnnThroppy · 12/07/2011 19:42

Right, just read ShowofHands analysis, can't disagree with that.

Also, I really disliked Rachel, but she was always portrayed as the rich super bitch and Ross the poor, hopelessly in love, well intentioned geek boy, so the balance of sympathies was always with him. Which I think was basically misogynistic.

Obviously this is a fun thread, but I do think this is important, because I think popular culture - especially something as long running as Friends, which was a multi million dollar earning, water cooler phenomenon for a years - feeds into our ideas of what is right and wrong in our rl social interactions and behaviours; especially if you are young and don't have much experience of romantic relationships. There was something in the news lately about Mills & Boon giving women a skewed idea of what is acceptable or realistic in a romantic relationship. I think the Friends/Rachel/Ross relationship dressed up a fair amount of abusive behaviour as comedy and made us think that, on the face of it, Ross was misunderstood and really a nice guy. I don't think he was.

I think he actually hated Rachel, and his whole romance of her was an attempt to "win", to defeat her. He was obsessed with her as a youngster. She didn't know he existed. Instead of that just being normal, she is somehow meant to have realised what a great guy was hiding under the spotty geek exterior. It is turned into Rachel's fault that Ross' passion is unrequited. Stalker manifesto rule number 1.

In the Brad Pitt episode, it is revealed that Ross co-founded the "I hate Rachel Green Society" at school. They spread a rumour about her being a hermaphrodite. This is not the act of a nice person; again, he is punishing Rachel because he is in love with her, but she not with him. More stalker behaviour.

When she turns up in NY and starts her new life, all the friends help Rachel, but Ross in particular does not do this out of disinterested friendship, more out of self interest. Rachel is reduced from prom queen to waitress and it is when she is reduced to a lowly position that he believes he can make his move on her. He begins to believe he has a right to be her boyfriend, because he has waited so long and they are now friends. When Paolo comes along, Ross tries to warn him off, tells him that Rachel is his (Ross's).

Ross is only magnanimous towards Rachel's romantic relationship with other men when he is with other women himself. And in these relationships, he follows the same pattern each time. Falls very hard, gets involved very deep, very quickly, declares they are "the one", drops them very quickly. First Julie, then Bonnie, with slight variations, but basically the same behaviour with Emily and Mona. Each time he is with one of these other women, Ross "allows" Rachel to have her own romances. When he is single, he is immediately jealous of anyone she might be with.

He sulked when Rachel

He was threatened when she wanted to become something other than a waitress. At the coffee shop, he could keep tabs on her. She could not become beyond him again in that lowly job. Not so at Bloomingdales. I've posted about his treatment of her career above. He holds it in contempt.

He takes absolutely no responsibility for his part in anything. He always turns it around on Rachel. His behaviour as an adolescent, her fault. His failure to ask her out and starting a relationship with Julie, her fault. The list - her fault for not understanding. His jealousy and undermining her in the workplace - her fault for not spending enough time with him and slipping away from him. His jealousy over mark - her fault for spending time with a colleague, not his fault for showing no trust when no reason to mistrust has been given. Sleeping with copy girl - Rachel's fault, he was upset, they were on a break. Rachel finding this out - everyone else's fault who failed to cover up for him. Rachel not forgiving him - her fault for being unreasonable. Rachel's pregnancy - her fault, she seduced him (he was helpless, of course, not able to stop himself or use a condom).

The rages. Already discussed above. Not acceptable behaviour.

In the denouement, Rachel is "tamed". She does not go to start a new life. He "wins"

He has a proprietary and patronising attitude to Monica also. He was angry at the relationship with Chandler until he found out it was love, not just sex. Well what business was it of his either way? He is always invading her personal space.I think he conspires by silence and inaction in their parents' blatant favouritism. He never sticks up for her with them. He is jealous of her pluck and never fails to tell her that her childhood victories over him resulted from her being fat.

He is also a greasy haired, whiny fuck

cjbartlett · 12/07/2011 19:45

*NO NO NO NO NO!

Phoebe should have married Joey

Monica should have married Richard (yum)

Chandler should have married Janice (my personal favourite charachter)

Ross should be single and alone and become extinct like the dinosaurs.

Rachel should have married Elizabeths Dad.*

Agree ! Phoebe should have married Hank Azaria no question
Richard - yum, chandler - gay, lol

mrsbabookaloo · 12/07/2011 20:01

Why, thank you, smellslikecatpee, that is very gratifying

Phoebe should have married David (was he called David?). Phoebe and Joey had a great connection, but she never really took it seriously. I would have liked her to marry the cop played by Michael Rapaport, but he did shoot that bird.
No, Rachel should not have married Elizabeth's Dad...he was a cry baby.

Must do something more constructive....