Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask does Breastfeeding need promoting?

134 replies

mummamizz · 18/06/2011 20:25

It's a bit of a follow on from the thread about the controversial "apple dumplings" Anyone who wants to watch it it's here

If your answer is yes Why? How would you personally do it? What message would you want to get across? Do you think advertising would make a difference?
OP posts:
WorzselMummage · 19/06/2011 13:20

Oh and I really want to know if Apple Dumplings is the name of the video or the production company ?

If it is the name of the video it is the most irrelevant, ridiculous name i have ever heard Confused

Lunabelly · 19/06/2011 13:20

Public eye...why. Why on this earth why? It's a form of feeding your baby which may well be XYZ compared to formula, but formula certainly isn't the nurtritional equivalent of a turkey twizzler and a pound of lard.

As someone wiser than me said earlier, feeding is only a small part of being a mother. Who is anyone to think it is up to them to dictate what a mother does in that area?

fatlazymummy · 19/06/2011 13:21

spudulika I can't remember what figures were given but it was still very low. [It was 22 years ago].
I didn't research cots or buggies either. I just went and picked one out that I liked and could afford.
In any case, no matter what government statistics are produced, people do usually take more notice of personal experience and the experience of people that they know. Therefore if all the children they see around them are healthy and formula fed then they will take note of that. I did know babies that were breastfed and bottlefed in fact the 2 i knew that were admitted to hospital as babies were breastfed.

I think this is the crux of the situation, a lot of people either don't trust government advice [sometimes with good reason] or can't relate it to themselves. A lot of people don't have strong feelings either way so aren't motivated to struggle or ask for health.

pingu2209 · 19/06/2011 13:27

When I was in hospital with DS1 trying desparately to breastfeed, the midwives sat me down and said that they could picture me on my sofa at home crying as my son wouldn't latch on. They said to me that in the 3rd world countries infant mortality is high and one of the reasons for that is when a baby will not latch on for some reason. If the mother can't breastfeed there is normally a sister, mother or aunt or someone who can wet nurse the baby. When the baby can't latch on, the babies dies. I was told that there has been research which the government have held back on these figures.

I for one come from a highly educated background and by income standards an upper middle class background, both as a child and now. However, whilst my attitudes BC (before children) were that breastfeeding was the only way and that those that bottle fed must be common, thick, lazy and all other negative opinions, my opinion changed when I actually tried breastfeeding.

If someone asked me if they should breastfeed I would say try by all means. I would be ubber honest and say that the greatest likelihood is that for practically 2 months it will be almost constant day and night and it is very hard. If they can do it easily and quickly they should thank God for it. However, being a mum is NOT about breastfeeding. If you formula feed you are just as good a mum as someone who breastfeeds.

A mum who sits on the sofa for 2 months as her youngest child is left to get on with it and not able to go to the park or out for a walk etc because the mum is struggling to breastfeed. Or has its mum who is getting Post Natal Depression because of extreme tiredness etc is not doing the best for her other children.

Spudulika - it is opinions like yours on breastfeeding that make me angry. I have read soooooooo many breastfeeding threads on this site and this is the first one I have commented on because you are so way off reality it is just not funny.

SoupDragon · 19/06/2011 13:28

Lunabelly, no one is dictating anything.

Should BF-ing be promoted as the natural thing to do? Yes.
Should ther ebe proper support to help mothers get it right? Yes.
Should bf-ing be seen out and about, on TV etc etc? Yes.
Should proper independent information about formula be available? Yes.
Should mothers be allowed to feed their baby how they want? Yes. But sometimes, feeding their baby how they want will involve extra help and support and accurate information and also, sometimes they need to be made to see breast-feeding can be an option for "people like them".

SoupDragon · 19/06/2011 13:29

By "natural thing" I mean the biological norm. Not that formula is abnormal or anything!

Lunabelly · 19/06/2011 13:29

Worzel - at the time (6 years ago) this is what we were told. DD3 was 13 months old and fully weaned when she was ill. I do know that NHS advice and bias changes all the bloody time though...I remember when mum was carrying my sibling, she was told to eat lots of liver Hmm.

RitaMorgan · 19/06/2011 13:33

pingu - it's midwives like that who are the problem, utterly useless for breastfeeding support. All the promotion in the world won't do any good if women come up against that kind of thing.

peachyuk · 19/06/2011 16:08

first of all i don't really give a shit what other people feed their dc's

i did start off bf and i had more support then i could shake a stick at. after i had given birth i was helped with getting dd latched on

on the ward we were alwas check on to see if i needed any help (was also offered a 'talk' about ff and how to make the feeds up if i wanted)

at home i had a mw or bf peer at least once a day for 3 weeks to see how we were doing. really couldn't fault the support i had.

and with all that support i still managed to 'fail' at bf due to a supply issue. i just get pissed off when some people seem to think that when people say oh i didn't make enough milk its because they didn't try hard enough

anyway back to topic, i think that if everyone was offered support like in my area then bf rates would def go up.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page